I definitely remember that he didn't do well within the MAC(I think he was average as far as winning percentage goes) but there was promise as he was a youthful coach with a good personality, good charisma, says all the right things, makes you believe that he would bring energy to the program again. People easily forget though. But, I think most people had a favorable response to the hire given that the first 2 choices declined our invitation(Stevens and Shaka Smart). He was brought in b/c of his recruiting he did at Ohio St as much as his success at Ohio U. That was the thought process behind the hire.
You're dead right about the thought process. But it was a terrible thought process. That's exactly what you DON'T do.