Illini Football 2019

Status
Not open for further replies.
#476      
And this is where the conversation inevitably goes back to what constitutes success or determines Lovie’s status going forward? I cringe every time I see someone say 5 wins and everything is ok. It’s not.
Quote from another big 10 coach.....Illinois is the laughing stock of college football...
 
#481      
Quote from another big 10 coach.....Illinois is the laughing stock of college football...
That ends this year.

Whoever it is, I hope we beat his team.

I'm guessing an Iowa coach.
 
#482      

Deleted member 29907

D
Guest
Lol wasn't fitzy....wasn't even a head coach.
And we care what some low class coach from another team says because.....? Clearly we all know where we are but comments from 'anonymous' coaches like these are just kinda 'so what?' Some guys will do whatever they can to disparage to increase their odds of recruiting success.

This league has had head coaches that supported child molesters and wife beaters in this sport alone. Perhaps some of these teams/comments should cast their gaze on addressing what is really important.
 
#483      
And we care what some low class coach from another team says because.....? Clearly we all know where we are but comments from 'anonymous' coaches like these are just kinda 'so what?' Some guys will do whatever they can to disparage to increase their odds of recruiting success.

This league has had head coaches that supported child molesters and wife beaters in this sport alone. Perhaps some of these teams/comments should cast their gaze on addressing what is really important.
I know this coach and he said it to my face after asking him how the rest of the conference viewed Illinois.
 
#484      

ChiefGritty

Chicago, IL
Quote from another big 10 coach.....Illinois is the laughing stock of college football...

And if that hasn't changed by Thanksgiving, it's time to bring in some new organizational leadership that can have this program operating along industry standards.

There has been a lot of reinventing the wheel by Lovie which is great if you're winning, but when the results look like this are just foolish hubris.
 
#485      
And if that hasn't changed by Thanksgiving, it's time to bring in some new organizational leadership that can have this program operating along industry standards.

There has been a lot of reinventing the wheel by Lovie which is great if you're winning, but when the results look like this are just foolish hubris.
I'm optimistic, but have see how the games play out starting this week. I'm not ready for another rebuild, hope this one works out.
 
#486      
In the words of an Illinois Boy, keep my name outcha mouth. Who cares what those people think. Punch em in the mouth and move on

I would love nothing more than to do just that.....however, it's difficult to beat a good heavyweight when you're fighting as a flyweight. 5 wins might look like progress to some people but we are not going to attract the type of talent we need to punch people in the mouth if we don't get to a bowl game. We have got to do more than show progress if we want to attract prime, high end talent.
 
#487      

Deleted member 649710

D
Guest
I took a look at the details underlying that talent composite. Seems clear that the Illini’s number is significantly bolstered by the incoming transfers. Looks like 24/7 used those players’ HS ratings, which none of them have lived up to yet. Here’s hoping most of them play up to their rating potential this season; they all will get the opportunity (except Ford). If they do, the Illini will have a good season.
 
#488      

Deleted member 29907

D
Guest
I would love nothing more than to do just that.....however, it's difficult to beat a good heavyweight when you're fighting as a flyweight. 5 wins might look like progress to some people but we are not going to attract the type of talent we need to punch people in the mouth if we don't get to a bowl game. We have got to do more than show progress if we want to attract prime, high end talent.
 
#489      

Deleted member 631370

D
Guest
Damn that gap between OSU and Michigan is a lot bigger than I expected


Michigan fans are talking national title this year (as they do every year it seems), but they'd be the first champion in a long time to do so with a less-than-50% blue chip percentage. Only OSU and PSU are above 50%.

But yeah, the difference between those three and the rest of the conference is pretty enormous. And Ohio State really is up at Alabama, Georgia, and Clemson's level for talent.
 
#490      

Deleted member 654622

D
Guest
I would love nothing more than to do just that.....however, it's difficult to beat a good heavyweight when you're fighting as a flyweight. 5 wins might look like progress to some people but we are not going to attract the type of talent we need to punch people in the mouth if we don't get to a bowl game. We have got to do more than show progress if we want to attract prime, high end talent.
I don't disagree with you. But I also don't expect some miracle this year. I do expect progress. I just read/hear outsiders call Lovie a joke (essentially that is what they are saying). It may not be pretty or enjoyable, but this roster is getting more and more talented. We may not end up with Mookie or AJ. But I also don't think there is a heavy weight in this division. The dudes we have started brining in are good enough to win.
 
#491      

BZuppke

Plainfield
I know this coach and he said it to my face after asking him how the rest of the conference viewed Illinois.
How does he know? Has he polled ‘the rest of the conference’? People say all sorts of stupid things and this is one of them. Tells more about him than us.
 
#492      

ChiefGritty

Chicago, IL
I am not sure if this has been posted yet, but I thought the attached rankings of composite talent were interesting. The Illini are 8th, ahead of Iowa, Minnesota, and Northwestern in the Big 10 West. Hopefully the upgraded talent will result in more wins.

https://247sports.com/Season/2019-Football/CollegeTeamTalentComposite/?Conference=Big-Ten

I'd been waiting for this to come out, and holy cow! 37th nationally, up from 61st last year.

11 of the top 12 of our players per that ranking have never played a snap for us before! (Calvin Avery is the only one)

2 of those 12 will not see the field this year of course (Beason and Ford)

But that's 9 really physically gifted guys that we have never seen before that we now have access to, in a 22 player sport. 6 of them are upperclassmen.

The point that these transfer guys were disappointments at their previous schools and shouldn't be considered elite the way they were as freshmen is true, full stop, I do not dispute that point.

Even so, I have a hard time squaring this roster with some of the national pessimism we've been seeing, not just that we'll miss a bowl, but that we'll be the clear doormat of the West. I do not foresee that, that should not be our expectation level, and we should be extremely disappointed and dismayed if that happens, IMO.
 
Last edited:
#493      

Deleted member 631370

D
Guest
I'd been waiting for this to come out, and holy cow!

11 of the top 12 of our players per that ranking have never played a snap for us before! (Calvin Avery is the only one)

2 of those 12 will not see the field this year of course (Beason and Ford)

But that's 9 really physically gifted guys that we have never seen before that we now have access to, in a 22 player sport. 6 of them are upperclassmen.

The point that these transfer guys were disappointments at their previous schools and shouldn't be considered elite the way they were as freshmen is true, full stop, I do not dispute that point.

Even so, I have a hard time squaring this roster with some of the national pessimism we've been seeing, not just that we'll miss a bowl, but that we'll be the clear doormat of the West. I do not foresee that, that should not be our expectation level, and we should be extremely disappointed and dismayed if that happens, IMO.


Time will tell.

But regarding your last point......people base their judgments on results. You don't see anybody giving Maryland a shot this year, do you? They're #5 in the Big Ten. But people know that Locksley cannot coach to save his life. Just the same, Iowa is #9 but they're preseason top-20. People recognize that Ferentz gets a good return-on-investment given their talent level.

Living far away from the Midwest these days, my anecdotal encounters with football fans that want to talk about Lovie -- upon discovering my Illinois roots -- generally have less-than-stellar things to say about him. Most like the guy personally, but don't believe he's a particularly good option for Illinois going forward.

The broader perception is one that doesn't really believe Lovie is going to get it done. Let's hope it's wrong.
 
#494      
Quote from another big 10 coach.....Illinois is the laughing stock of college football...
What a lamebrain coach. I wouldn't even say it if I believed it. Coaches like that never go very far unless they cheat(ala Pearl) And I don't have much respect for coaches that say those things. I'll be there Saturday and I hope it's the start of a respectable year. 5 minimum 7 tops wins.
 
#495      

Deleted member 654622

D
Guest
I'd been waiting for this to come out, and holy cow! 37th nationally, up from 61st last year.

11 of the top 12 of our players per that ranking have never played a snap for us before! (Calvin Avery is the only one)

2 of those 12 will not see the field this year of course (Beason and Ford)

But that's 9 really physically gifted guys that we have never seen before that we now have access to, in a 22 player sport. 6 of them are upperclassmen.

The point that these transfer guys were disappointments at their previous schools and shouldn't be considered elite the way they were as freshmen is true, full stop, I do not dispute that point.

Even so, I have a hard time squaring this roster with some of the national pessimism we've been seeing, not just that we'll miss a bowl, but that we'll be the clear doormat of the West. I do not foresee that, that should not be our expectation level, and we should be extremely disappointed and dismayed if that happens, IMO.
The infusion of higher talent is real
 
#496      

Deleted member 654622

D
Guest
Living far away from the Midwest these days, my anecdotal encounters with football fans that want to talk about Lovie -- upon discovering my Illinois roots -- generally have less-than-stellar things to say about him. Most like the guy personally, but don't believe he's a particularly good option for Illinois going forward.

The broader perception is one that doesn't really believe Lovie is going to get it done. Let's hope it's wrong.
But that is based off basically the win loss record. And rightfully so. But outsiders do not pay attention to the signs that this team is going to be better.
 
#497      

ChiefGritty

Chicago, IL
The infusion of higher talent is real

And what I'm really counting on is that those guys, combined with the age and experience of the rest of our roster, means we've reached the end of having guys out there that just have no business on a Big Ten field. Any snap where you have a couple guys like that out there is begging for disaster.

That has been a constant feature of the last two seasons. If that stops, we're playing a different ballgame.
 
#498      

BananaShampoo

Captain 'Paign
Phoenix, AZ
And what I'm really counting on is that those guys, combined with the age and experience of the rest of our roster, means we've reached the end of having guys out there that just have no business on a Big Ten field. Any snap where you have a couple guys like that out there is begging for disaster.

That has been a constant feature of the last two seasons. If that stops, we're playing a different ballgame.
It will stop as long as we remain healthy. That's the key to this season. We are absolutely a B1G caliber team on our first string at pretty much all position groups. It's after that where it gets dicey very quickly at certain positions (OL, CB, LB, QB mostly). To really become legit we need depth at every position to back up those quality starters. We can be good this year if we can be healthy, but it's next year when we'll finally have depth as even our backups will have the benefit of age and maturity (and some experience) while we also get some of our top talented transfers eligible. I honestly think next year we'll have a good chance to win the B1G West if we can hold it together.
 
#499      

Deleted member 649710

D
Guest
But that's 9 really physically gifted guys that we have never seen before that we now have access to, in a 22 player sport. 6 of them are upperclassmen.
Counterpoint: Only three of the "really physically gifted guys" play on the defensive side of the ball (Betiku, Eifler, Cooper), and maybe only one of them is a starter, and we already lost the best returning player from what was the school's worst defense of the modern era.

The success or failure of this season hinges mostly on whether the defense can improve from absolute garbage to mediocre, and most of that improvement has to come from the players already on the roster, the "new" defensive coordinator, and only one assistant coach (out of four) with more than two seasons of coaching experience. [Gulp]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.