I'm generally in the camp of BU has earned more time to right the ship. But the Loyola loss is squarely on him and will probably hang over his head forever unless he makes a Final Four. If I take my orange glasses off, what Moser did that game was one of the best coaching performances I've seen. That wasn't just a scrappy mid major who caught fire from three as often happens in tourney upsets. They knew exactly how they could hurt us. They inserted the knife and twisted it over and over and we looked more confused than anything.
Anyway, if we win that game, BU is pretty much on track. I've posted this before but every coach who has been here for 9+ years has made multiple S16's in their first 9 years. And this is how it breaks down by decade starting in the 80s:
80s: 4 S16
90s: 0 (sanctions)
00s: 4
10s: 0 (Inept leadership)
20s: 1
The way I see it, BU has one more year to get one more S16 and if he does that, then he gets four to make it to two. Longer leash than most here have for him but it just doesn't seem reasonable, IMO, to fire a guy for failing to do something that literally no one in our history has done - go to the 2nd weekend 5 times in a decade.