I've had this discussion a few times and my contention is the committee doesn't have the time to go this in depth for every situation. They'd certainly take it under consideration when looking at NC St's resume, but not sure it would impact ours. But if we're on the bubble and it's down to those last few teams, then I could see them digging deep enough to figure it out.
I know the ESPN BPI formula tries to account for injured players, but it's the only rating system that does.
I'm sure you're right. That would be incredibly complicated and at a certain point I feel like you have to ignore certain subjective factors. The committee has made some questionable decisions in the past so I've always been curious about their decision making. One thing that I do like is that it seems like they value good wins much more than bad losses.