2017 Coaching Carousel

Status
Not open for further replies.
#4,527      
I can't understand how after just dealing with one coach who had limited experience as a head coach in any college league that now Keatts is considered a good pick. Have we learned nothing from the past 5 years?

Let's talk numbers because they don't lie. His combined head coaching record between Hargrave and UNCW is 326-43. UNCW's record from 2008-2009 until Keatts took the job in 2014 was 65-139 and their record since his arrival is 64-26. The season prior to Keatts taking over UNCW won 9 games and in his first season, Keatts won them a conference title. He coached 20 different eventual NBA players at Hargrave and recruited many of the players from the Louisville championship team.

In regards to Monty, if the fodder from last night is correct and we keep Walker, have a former D1 head coach, and another assistant, that's a good staff. Monty had less control over who his players were on his team while coaching the Pelicans than would a D1 coach. He had Anthony Davis and the GM used a lottery pick on Austin Rivers one year which hasn't panned out. He is a coach with USA basketball, a lot of his former players like him, and he also has credibility as an NBA player for 5 different teams. His teams were generally in top half of the league in defense as well.
 
#4,528      
"But the insiders say Monty Williams is a done deal!"

vintage-train-animated-gif-3.gif

Literally no one has said Monty is a done deal
 
#4,529      
If you can't see any differences in their respective resumes other than length of tenure as a HC, I don't know what to tell you.

So what makes Keatts stand out as THAT much more qualified than Groce, or Weber for that matter?

"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it."
-George Santayana
 
#4,530      
I don't really get the "program builder" title being applied to Cuonzo. None of his three stops were in bad places when he arrived.

Missouri State 3 years before Cuonzo: 22-9, 22-11, 17-16 -> 61-36 (629) overall
Missouri State 3 years under Cuonzo: 11-20, 24-12, 26-9 -> 61-41 (.598) overall

Tennessee 3 years before Cuonzo: 21-13, 28-9, 19-15 -> 68-37 (.648) overall
Tennessee 3 years under Cuonzo: 19-15, 20-13, 24-13 -> 63-41 (.606) overall

Cal 3 years before Cuonzo: 24-10, 21-12, 21-14 -> 66-36 (.647) overall
Cal 3 years under Cuonzo: 18-15, 23-11, 17-6 (incomplete, on pace for something like 22-8 regular season) -> 63-34 (.649) overall

Where is the program building going on?

Results look different if you consider the previous season only, which is a better reflection of what he actually inherited:

Missouri State 1 year before Cuonzo: 17-16 (.515)
Missouri State 3 years under Cuonzo: 11-20, 24-12, 26-9 -> 61-41 (.598) overall

Tennessee 1 year before Cuonzo: 19-15 (.559)
Tennessee 3 years under Cuonzo: 19-15, 20-13, 24-13 -> 63-41 (.606) overall

Cal 1 year before Cuonzo: 21-14 (.600)
Cal 3 years under Cuonzo: 18-15, 23-11, 17-6 (incomplete, on pace for something like 22-8 regular season) -> 63-34 (.649) overall
 
#4,531      
So what makes Keatts stand out as THAT much more qualified than Groce, or Weber for that matter?

"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it."
-George Santayana

You can't see the difference between what Groce did at Ohio and what Keatts is doing at UNCW on your own?
 
#4,533      
True, but Fignon had saddle sores. Also at play was LeMond going all technology on the last time trial, reinventing the sport with aerodynamics. Kind of cool to see actually, but 50 seconds in a time trial isn't impossible despite what French media wants to tell you. I'm actually glad they have a ceremonious final stage now...ending on a time trial seems dumb in hindsight.

In hindsight, yes it doesn't seem as quite of a big deal. But at that time no one had ever done what he did. Also, Fignon had a chance to use the same sort of equipment, but he made a tactical mistake( most likely due to arrogance) by not choosing the same equipment for the last stage. If I remember right, he did finally put on a helmet and possibly the aero bars in the middle of the last stage, but it was too late by then.
 
#4,534      
So what makes Keatts stand out as THAT much more qualified than Groce, or Weber for that matter?

"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it."
-George Santayana

Refer to Cahall's post, but really your comments are just showing me you haven't actually looked at the resume of either very closely and are just locked in on "midmajor coach bad" that seems to plague some people's thinking after the Groce and Beckman flops.
 
#4,536      
True, but Fignon had saddle sores. Also at play was LeMond going all technology on the last time trial, reinventing the sport with aerodynamics. Kind of cool to see actually, but 50 seconds in a time trial isn't impossible despite what French media wants to tell you. I'm actually glad they have a ceremonious final stage now...ending on a time trial seems dumb in hindsight.

Wait, they did a time trial on the Champs Elysees?
 
#4,537      
How are you defining competitive? That roster, without a doubt, can go on the road and not lose by an average of 15 ppg with good coaching. Nobody is saying that we will be a tournament team next year, that is yet to be seen, but what Groce did this year with the experience on this roster was MASSIVELY underachieving.

I think next year will be worse than this year. I think Groce needs to go but I don't think anyone was going to get this group of players to achieve anything dramatically different. The recruiting failures and talent evaluation is why he is gone in my eyes. Just because they are losing doesn't mean they aren't being coached well or aren't trying. The players are playing hard they aren't good enough. This team needs roster turnover to get better in my opinion.
 
#4,538      
Yeah, agreed, I personally don't see Bruce as being on the hot seat there, KSU has been entirely respectable under his tenure.

He's probably doing just enough to hang on there forever, but he's definitely brought the program down from where Martin had it. Other than his first year, they have been decidedly mediocre
 
#4,540      
If you can't see any differences in their respective resumes other than length of tenure as a HC, I don't know what to tell you.



I agree with all of these points. The pieces are there, and if you get a coach who can do something with AJ/DJW, you really have something with this team next year. The existing pieces in a functional scheme are plenty talented, and while this is not stated to lend credence to the "Keep Groce for Tilmon" crowd, landing Tilmon will be a big deal as the alternative is a 5th year or a less talented HS 5 (or playing really small next year). Beyond next year, less of a big deal whether we landed Tilmon or not, but for instant gratification fans, that'll be a big decision.

Unfortunately, we may need to find a way to satisfy the instant gratification crowd or else we are going to be hearing them call for the next coach's head after year 2.

People wanting Groce gone now are absolutely justified, but the problem I have is with the fans who were calling for his head after year 2. How are you going to call for a coach to be fired who in year 1 took a group of players who went 2-11 in their last 13 games, and led them to within a blown call of going to the Sweet Sixteen, minus their lottery pick center from the previous year. Then in his second year brought in 9 new players and took them within an Abrams floater of getting into the tournament again the next year. On top of that, he brought in a top 15 recruiting class on limited time and also came close to landing a number of big time recruits that under the Weber regime would've been an absolute pipe dream.

Again, years 3-5 justify wanting a change. But the fans who called for a change after year 2 was unnecessary and just plain ignorant.
 
#4,541      
No it's not. It's a fact that Cuonzo hasn't pushed any of his programs beyond the level of success of his immediate predecessor.

On the flip side, all three of those predecessors were darned good coaches.

The quoted post shortened the span of Cuonzo predecessors without shortening Cuonzo's to year 1, for example, just to try and make a point, which is textbook confirmation bias. I posted the OP with 3 before v 3 under Cuonzo year spans for comparison. My OP wasn't even to state Cuonzo is a bad coach, just that the 'program builder' label he's being granted is unfounded in facts.
 
#4,543      
I think next year will be worse than this year. I think Groce needs to go but I don't think anyone was going to get this group of players to achieve anything dramatically different. The recruiting failures and talent evaluation is why he is gone in my eyes. Just because they are losing doesn't mean they aren't being coached well or aren't trying. The players are playing hard they aren't good enough. This team needs roster turnover to get better in my opinion.

We are getting a roster turnover in essence.

Gone: Hill, Thorne, Abrams, Tate and Mav at least

Incoming: Tilmon, Frazier, Damonte, Pickett

That's pretty substantial
 
#4,547      
We are getting a roster turnover in essence.

Gone: Hill, Thorne, Abrams, Tate and Mav at least

Incoming: Tilmon, Frazier, Damonte, Pickett

That's pretty substantial

And, presumably a significant upgrade in coaching.
 
#4,548      
We are getting a roster turnover in essence.

Gone: Hill, Thorne, Abrams, Tate and Mav at least

Incoming: Tilmon, Frazier, Damonte, Pickett

That's pretty substantial

Athleticism of the roster gets a huge bump next year, which is part of the reason they can't defend well this year. They are one of the least athletic and slowest teams in the B1G right now...
 
#4,549      
We are getting a roster turnover in essence.

Gone: Hill, Thorne, Abrams, Tate and Mav at least

Incoming: Tilmon, Frazier, Damonte, Pickett

That's pretty substantial

That's true but you can't expect much from these freshmen. They are going to have an incredibly hard time scoring next year unless Frazier is way better as a Freshman than I think he will be. Pickett,Williams and Tilmon can provide some minutes but they won't be ready to be leaned on.
 
#4,550      
Athleticism of the roster gets a huge bump next year, which is part of the reason they can't defend well this year. They are one of the least athletic and slowest teams in the B1G right now...

Nailed it. They can't keep anyone in front of them on D and they can't beat anyone off the dribble offensively. How do you coach that up?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back