Is Archie the only name out there that nobody has complaints about?
Seems like it. I think he's in everyone's top 3 or 4. I think lots of people prefer one of Monty, Bennett, Marshall, or Scott Drew, but Archie is right in that pack and less divisive than the other top candidates.
My list is 1) Monty, 2) Archie, 3) Bennett, 4) Bryce Drew, 5) Marshall, 6) Buzz Williams, 7) Scott Drew. I'm convinced that every one of these guys would be a home run hire. The thing with Archie is he has no warts: high character/good reputation, likable/dynamic personality, proven winner, plenty of experience, plays a fun style, good recruiter with midwest roots. Also has less important but still potentially helpful bonuses: was a good college player, brother is one of the top coaches in the country, etc. Every other candidate has at least one big question mark or perceived deficiency.