So with today's commitment, it got me thinking about next year's team ... and I wanted to get the board's thoughts. However, let's first rewind and look at our teams since 2019-20 (the year we finally turned things around), with my subjective comments added:
2019-20: This squad had truly turned into a solid and consistent team by the time the season was cut short due to COVID, but I would argue the ceiling wasn't super high. We all kind of knew we were one year away from making any noise.
2020-21: Let's forget the Loyola disaster for a second ... this team was a threat to win our first National Championship, period. When you are a #1 seed and one of the hottest teams in the country (IIRC, 25%+ of brackets had us winning it all), that is not that subjective of an assertion.
2021-22: A lovable team with a very high floor (early season trip-up not withstanding), but I don't know how many people were dreaming of a Final Four run or anything. Their legacy will rightfully be remembered as finally hanging another Big Ten regular season championship banner by beating rival Iowa in a thriller!
2022-23: Very frustrating team that most are probably content to somewhat forget, but they provided some exciting "high ceiling moments," such as beating #9 UCLA and #2 Texas.
2023-24: Going to go down as one of our favorite teams in modern history, but who knows where they would have stood if we didn't break through to the Elite Eight? Their main legacy (besides having one of our more likable groups ever) will be getting the Second Weekend monkey off of this program's back. If not for UConn standing in our way, maybe a Final Four was on the table ... but that would have been gravy.
2024-25: A perplexing team that was sort of a "better in every way" reiteration of our 2023 squad, IMO. They gave us great memories, they were pretty likable and they could play at a very high ceiling ... but the low floor games were hard to take, and we ended up with a pretty forgettable season on paper.
It is important to note that goals evolve as progress as made, as they should. When Underwood got here, our goal was simply to get back to being a competitive, top 25 program that people took seriously. After we were "back" during the 2019-20 season, we started talking about getting back to competing for Big Ten championships and making runs in the NCAA Tournament. By 2024, the goal was DECIDEDLY to get past the Second Round and get a Sweet Sixteen (or better) so we could dispel of the narrative that we couldn't get past the First Weekend. So what about now? I would argue the GOAL (which is loftier than the standard) is simple ... be a team that is at least putting itself in the POSITION to get back to the Final Four. We've won the Big Ten, we've won the BTT multiple times, we've been back to the Second Weekend of the Tournament, we've got multiple guys drafted and promoting us well in the NBA, etc. We need to get back to the Final Four.
So, TL;DR...
What type of team are we looking at for next year now? Last year obviously didn't cut it for this program's standards, and it really wasn't a talent issue so much as other more intangible things (experience being a big one). I think we were already setting up to have a squad similar to our 2019-20 team, where we were going to be a bit more mature, steady and good enough to be in the top 25 ... but does this commitment move the needle in getting us back to that 2024 level where we are a true threat to make some noise in March? We are probably still at least one piece from getting to the February/March 2021 level of play (again, Loyola disaster ignored!).