It's difficult to see this IU loss being ANYWHERE near deflating as it was if we don't beat South Carolina in the first place. People are forgetting this now given last week's pathetic performance, but that Citrus Bowl victory absolutely shattered the narrative that we were just getting by beating mediocre teams, limping our way to 9 wins through luck and not able to hang with good teams ... the Gamecocks were considered one of the hottest teams in the nation, and almost no experts were giving us a chance. It was an absolute statement win for our program. If we lose to SC last year, I don't think we enter the preseason polls above #20-23 at best, and thus there would have never been these dreams of a CFP berth. All just conjecture and my subjective opinion, of course, but I think it was the expectations that led to this Indiana loss being so heart breaking and sickening.
With that said, let's imagine we finished last year 9-4 and still returned everyone. We could have been into the top 20 by the time we traveled to Bloomington, and a win would catapult us easily into the top 15 and sitting pretty at 4-0. I hesitate to give up a Citrus Bowl win, though.