Buck, I don't think anyone else has thrown their two cents in here yet, so while I definitely don't claim to be the most knowledgeable person on this site and I don't know all of the stat comparisons, and some, maybe many, will disagree with me, I'll give you my perspective on the two seasons. Overall, think the two teams are very similar between 2024 and 2025. Yes, we finished the '24 regular season at 9-3, but we were two plays away from being 7-5...the Roziek sack on the 2-point conversion attempt in OT against PU, and the 4th and 13th TD against Rutgers with 13 seconds left. (We dominated Nebraska in OT in that game so that one is not in question for me.) Our guys then played the game of their life in the Citrus Bowl to bring that one home and finish an outstanding season. I won't go so far as to call 2024 an "aberration", but I will say we were very fortunate. As a very long-suffering Illini Football fan, I will most definitely take it and not apologize to anyone for our 2024 season. Heaven knows we've had more than our share of bad luck over the years. As for this year, I think this year's team did underperform at least to the extent of competitiveness in the games against IU and Washington (Oregon last year), and we definitely had a bad game against Wisky (Minnesota last year). The only down-to-the-wire nail-biter this year was the USC game, and they are a good team but our guys did enough to earn that game. Also, with Illinois coming off a 10-3 season where we beat a good SEC team in a bowl, I think teams prepared differently for us this year, so this was going to be a more difficult year and we were going to get everyone's best.
All that said, I am extremely pleased....call it ecstatic...over 18 wins over the last two seasons, with one more game to go. We've posted 18 wins over a two season span once, but never 19 wins. I would be over-the-top proud if we can get a bowl win this year to get to 9 wins. Its been said by a lot of folks on here that we need sustained success, which will bring recruits, which will bring further sustained success. I don't care how we get there but 18 (or 19) wins over two seasons is the beginning of sustained success and I believe we are really beginning to see that with this year's awesome recruiting class. Yes, next year is going to be completely different with all of the talent and experience we are losing, but we have a lot of talent still left and a lot coming in, as well. I think its going to feel different, as well. Again, I certainly don't have any "insider" privileges or knowledge to the team, but my bet is that Bret learned as much this year as probably any year prior to this in his career and he'll use that to develop the talent we have, both players and coaching staff. Will we be 10-2...maybe....maybe not. But I'll sure take another 8-4 season in a heartbeat.
I think I rambled a bit here...sorry...I just thought your message was interesting because I've thought the exact same thing you posed...wanted to provide my perspective.