I hear you and clearly understand your perspective:
(1) Quantitatively speaking, Kenpom has a slightly negative correlation to outcome. Taking points in Kenpom spread is a 59.3% winner after 5% vig. That is 7 years of data covering over 20,000 NCAA games. and 1-1 in underdog situations has no statistical value.
(2) How UCONN played against St. John's has no more relevance to how we played against Michigan at home. UCONN isn't playing St. John's on Saturday and we aren't playing Michigan on Saturday. Moreover you are mixing metaphores. You either want to use how a team plays and what their statistical average in quantified statistical areas (FG%, Rebounds, etc) or you can do the "eye test." But the two (stats or ranking and eye test) don't mix.
(3) I wasn't making any comparisons of this team to 2024. In fact, I was stating the exact opposite. The entire Illini staff learned from playing in the elite 8. When you look at the team on the floor on Saturday it is a direct reflection to changes made in terms of personel and approach to game management which resulted from the UCONN loss two years ago.
(4) I am professionally what is known as a "quant" and have been for over 44 years let me leave you with this:
Exact Calculation:
Each NCAA tournament game has 2 possible outcomes: win or loss. Over 18 games, there are
2¹⁸ = 262,144 possible win/loss sequences.
- Number of sequences with exactly 17 wins (and 1 loss): There are 18 such sequences (you can lose any one of the 18 games).
- Number of sequences with 18 wins (perfect): 1 sequence.
Probability of exactly 17 wins: 18 / 262,144 ≈
0.006866% (or about 1 in 14,563).
Probability of 17 or 18 wins: 19 / 262,144 ≈
0.007248% (or about 1 in 13,797).
Odds against exactly 17 wins: Roughly
14,563 to 1.
Odds against 17 or 18 wins: Roughly
13,797 to 1.
Only 2 other teams in the history of NCAA basketball has ever been able to do what UCONN has done in the past 4 years. It took UCLA 5 years to do it. In the 1960's the path to the NCAA tournament was more difficult and virtually all of the teams in the tourney were nationally ranked. Duke's 1990 - 1993 (4 seasons) teams won 18 of 20 and two national titles. Florida won back to back titles but 13 tourney wins in 4 years.
Please do not get me wrong, I am a 60 year Illni fan and have traveled from the corners of the world to watch them play. But to question UCONN's proficency isn't (mathematically speaking) intellectually honest. If we beat them on Saturday, we will have accomplished something.