Illinois at Duke, Tuesday, November 17th, 6:00pm CT, ESPN

#53      
This is terrible matchup on paper for us right now, but what I’m looking for is for the offense to play connected in a hostile environment and show growth from the Tech game. If the Freshman step up and Andrej, Tomi and Vaaks play like veterans this will be a positive game for us.

Duke might be too much on the glass and just have too many weapons for us but we can control how hard we play and the decisions we make - that is the biggest thing in my mind
 
#54      
This is terrible matchup on paper for us right now, but what I’m looking for is for the offense to play connected in a hostile environment and show growth from the Tech game. If the Freshman step up and Andrej, Tomi and Vaaks play like veterans this will be a positive game for us.

Duke might be too much on the glass and just have too many weapons for us but we can control how hard we play and the decisions we make - that is the biggest thing in my mind

illinois is 7th in the country in reb %, duke 17th

teams have played a very comparable schedule thus far, though eye test and results against high major teams favors duke imo
 
#55      
Duke 90
Illini 75

Don't feel great about this team just yet.
 
#57      
Ummm… actually “It’s Clobberin’ Time!” Is the catch phrase for Ben Grimm, aka The Thing
Classe Jamel Debbouze GIF by CANAL+

You're both wrong...

d8a290c4c24afb81bbfb0a09375379f8.gif
 
#58      
Yeah, but sorry you feel THAT bad.
We we're down 20 in the first half to Texas Tech. Yeah, I'm not super optimistic at the moment, but by the end of the season I expect us to be much better.
 
#59      
I typed before in frustration (after TT loss) there is no way they beat Duke.

Upon some introspection, they still lose, but I think BU will have them ready, and it will be a very close game.
 
#62      
I’m really glad Brad doesn’t have the fatalistic attitude of many on this board. 🫤

It’s so lame. It’s just “if we win I’m still a fan and can celebrate with everyone”.
Yet if we lose they get to come in and “see I told you so” pat themselves on the back.

It’s the old negative “Win Win” fan prop.
Bet on them to lose so you can be happy with either outcome.
 
#63      
I’m really glad Brad doesn’t have the fatalistic attitude of many on this board. 🫤
Hes both sides of this board. Eternally optimistic and motivating even if they went 0 for 35 while also noticing and berating every wrinkle, wart, and shortcoming even if they went 41-0.

You cant properly progress without simultaneously seeing an optimistic future no matter how bleak while also flushing out and fixing every last flaw.

You need fans who are critical even in success. Comparing your team to the ideal rather than a lesser version who were in the past. You also need fans more happy with the journey and more moderate success so your coach isnt fired every other Tuesday.
 
#64      
You need fans who are critical even in success. Comparing your team to the ideal rather than a lesser version who were in the past. You also need fans more happy with the journey and more moderate success so your coach isnt fired every other Tuesday.

Just curious: what does this accomplish other than message board fun? It just sounds like main character syndrome. I'm not sure fans being critical moves any needles in positive directions. Does criticism on here, Twitter, and so on sell more tickets or improve the players or do we think the coaches listen to this stuff at all?

If the team's internal standard of excellence depended on fans being miserable after a win, the coaches wouldn't be doing their jobs. I think there's a difference between being a "ball knower" and just needing to make sure everyone knows you spotted a flaw. Winning is hard... you're allowed to just enjoy it, you know?

PS - I’m all for the freedom to be critical through success, I just am curious what your take is on what tangible improvements it accomplishes.
 
Last edited:
#66      
Just curious: what does this accomplish other than message board fun? It just sounds like main character syndrome. I'm not sure fans being critical moves any needles in positive directions. Does criticism on here, Twitter, and so on sell more tickets or improve the players or do we think the coaches listen to this stuff at all?

If the team's internal standard of excellence depended on fans being miserable after a win, the coaches wouldn't be doing their jobs. I think there's a difference between being a "ball knower" and just needing to make sure everyone knows you spotted a flaw. Winning is hard... you're allowed to just enjoy it, you know?
Like it or not pressure to improve comes from people paying for the thing being unhappy with the product they are paying for. Donors and ticket holders being content with a 15-15 team will keep getting a 15-15 team. Internally individual players may possess that motivation to progress and improve. Sports programs improve through several ways, one of which is external pressure that the status quo isnt good enough.
 
#68      
Like it or not pressure to improve comes from people paying for the thing being unhappy with the product they are paying for. Donors and ticket holders being content with a 15-15 team will keep getting a 15-15 team. Internally individual players may possess that motivation to progress and improve. Sports programs improve through several ways, one of which is external pressure that the status quo isnt good enough.

Why are we talking about a 15-15 team?

You need fans who are critical even in success.

15-15 isn’t success. My question was why do we need critical fans when the team is going to E8s and F4s? What purpose does it serve other than for us to have fun BSing with one another?

If you meant to say failure instead of success then I fully agree (15-15 would be failure).
 
#69      
Like it or not pressure to improve comes from people paying for the thing being unhappy with the product they are paying for. Donors and ticket holders being content with a 15-15 team will keep getting a 15-15 team. Internally individual players may possess that motivation to progress and improve. Sports programs improve through several ways, one of which is external pressure that the status quo isnt good enough.
Fan pressure vs support is really interesting to me.

Obviously, there are programs that face immense fan pressure and do very well.

I’ll use football for my examples because that’s where you’ll see the most pressure to win.

You’ve got the Alabamas of the world. Lots of fan pressure and lots of success.

But you also have the Penn State’s. They had a good coach in Franklin. Maybe not elite, but definitely good. In the 3 years before he was fired, he went 24-8 and finished ranked 7, 13, and 5 in the AP poll with a CFP appearance. But that wasn’t good enough, so the fans got him fired.

With a new coach, Penn State is currently 6-4 and unranked in the AP poll.

Nebraska has similar fan pressure and it has lead to very little on-field success.

On the other hand, Indiana has very little fan pressure and they’ve done okay.

Same with UCLA.

My gut feel is that on-field results are almost completely driven by the competency of the administration, athletic department, and coaching staff. If anything, fan support that provides revenue to the university to bring in better coaches and players likely has a much larger positive impact on the program than fan criticism.
 
#70      
Illinois 88
Duke 82
Based on what we've seen, we're not holding Duke to 82.

Duke. 93
Illinois. 80

Until we get the defensive end of the floor figured out, which is not an overnight fix, it's going to be a bumpy road. They have a LOT of talent and Cameron will make the game at TT sound like Sunday mass.
 
#71      
Like it or not pressure to improve comes from people paying for the thing being unhappy with the product they are paying for. Donors and ticket holders being content with a 15-15 team will keep getting a 15-15 team. Internally individual players may possess that motivation to progress and improve. Sports programs improve through several ways, one of which is external pressure that the status quo isnt good enough.

Most of this is just semantics - because Illinois could win 135-3 and I think discussing strategy or pointing out something you might do differently is all good. It’s just when it’s worded with heat, is what I think makes people unhappy.

To the bolded, 15-15 is not us, and hasn’t been us. And while fans with passion and care is better than the alternative, too many can create a toxic environment where that “pressure” doesn’t actually equal good things. This board last year was flat out embarrassing with some takes last year - and if certain fans got their wish we’d had fired Brad for Will Wade before we even made a F4.

And finally, I think Brad and staff are winners. I think they want to win to win. I don’t think fan venom is their jockey, and if it is, they’re not fit for the job.

That said, I think the vast majority of Illini fans at this point are merely voicing frustration with certain outcomes, and it’s just written with a bit more vitriol than intended
 
#73      
It’s going to be a rough Nov and Dec.

Duke and UConn look like fairly probabilistic losses based on how our defense and rebounding look.

Buy games are glorified pep rallies.

The only games I’m interested in are at Minny to pick up road B1G win to start the conference season. And vs. a bubble team in Missouri that has the exact type of talismanic guard in Crowe that often torches us.

We’re less than 3 weeks away from UConn. Mirk can’t even condition in normal gravity.

I know it’s a tough pill to swallow. But find something other than Illini basketball to look forward to till at least the Minnesota game. Otherwise, you’re setting yourself for a pretty miserable start to the holiday season.
 
#74      
Fan pressure vs support is really interesting to me.

Obviously, there are programs that face immense fan pressure and do very well.

I’ll use football for my examples because that’s where you’ll see the most pressure to win.

You’ve got the Alabamas of the world. Lots of fan pressure and lots of success.

But you also have the Penn State’s. They had a good coach in Franklin. Maybe not elite, but definitely good. In the 3 years before he was fired, he went 24-8 and finished ranked 7, 13, and 5 in the AP poll with a CFP appearance. But that wasn’t good enough, so the fans got him fired.

With a new coach, Penn State is currently 6-4 and unranked in the AP poll.

Nebraska has similar fan pressure and it has lead to very little on-field success.

On the other hand, Indiana has very little fan pressure and they’ve done okay.

Same with UCLA.

My gut feel is that on-field results are almost completely driven by the competency of the administration, athletic department, and coaching staff. If anything, fan support that provides revenue to the university to bring in better coaches and players likely has a much larger positive impact on the program than fan criticism.
Indiana is a unicorn example. They were one of the worst programs in the history of college football and then hit on Cignetti.
 
#75      
Indiana is a unicorn example. They were one of the worst programs in the history of college football and then hit on Cignetti.
Okay, looking at this season, here are a few more examples of programs that have lower fan pressure than Nebraska, but better results:

- Kentucky
- BYU
- Wake Forest
- Utah
- Louisville
- Arizona
- Houston
- Duke
 
Back