Yeah, that would be an incorrect interpretation of it. His overall rating is the one to focus on, especially for teams in the top tier.totally get why the metric exists as a 'paper tiger' identifier, padding stats vs weak comp and fold vs real contenders
guess my point was in a vaccum people might look at a negative opp adjustment and assume it automatically means a team is struggling against good opponents when in a case like ours its a byproduct of crazy blowouts vs top 100-150 teams
just editing to add if you're talking about a team that ducks good competition and only pads stats, sure, but if its aimed at illinois it misses the point: going on the road and losing by 6 to a top 15 team or winning by 21 over a top 5 team already proves they belong with the top ones and beating little sisters of christ university by 100 points doesnt magically erase the fact illinois is 2nd in the country in most wins vs top competition over whatever timeframe it is that was measured
I do appreciate that he's trying to incorporate something like this. KenPom and Torvik essentially measure how teams are expected to do against an "average" team, which is like a 16-seed. It would be great if EvanMiya also published a "rating vs top-tier team", since that's what most teams are interested in by the tournament.
One clarification though: while losing by 6 on the road to a top-10 team isn't "bad", it will pull down the rating for a team at/near the top. Since we only have one other game against a top team, that affects us more than it eventually will. We'll know a lot more in a few months which of the TT and Duke games better represent our play against top teams.