Illinois Hoops Recruiting Thread

#151      
You might be overthinking it. The original comment you responded to said:

Wagler last year. Coleman this year. How does Illinois keep finding these guys???

That post isn't saying that Wagler and Coleman have identical recruiting profiles. They obviously don't. Coleman started his ascent in high school, whereas Keaton's didn't begin until he walked onto campus.

But 15 months ago, QC was ranked outside the top 100 on every major recruiting service. When he committed to Illinois in March, 247, which had him ranked highest out of any service, had him at #34 in his class. That's a solid player, no doubt. Think Adam Miller, even Ayo. But that's not a lottery pick.

We were QC's best offer. His second best was Texas Tech. Duke, Kentucky, Alabama, Arkansas, UConn, Houston, Kansas, Florida, Arizona, etc, didn't offer.

And he's going to get drafted top 5, top 3? I feel like asking "how does Illinois keep doing it?" is pretty fair here.
Well, to be fair, apparently we weren't his best offer 15 months ago (presumably Wake Forest was), but we were 7 months ago. By that point, he was #34 at 247 (not their composite- that bounced around in unexplainable ways between January and April even as their own rating of him jumped).

He then jumped further in the ratings in May to top 20, and we can claim to be ahead of that for sure.
 
#153      
Watching Houston vs Duke so far this season makes you realize the art of recruiting is not collating the most 5 stars, it's about identifying talent that fits your system and actually coaching it.

The cat is out of the bag on Scheyer at this point and it's been fairly clear that the Calipari system isn't producing great ROI. If you look at Lloyd, who has 3 lottery picks on his roster, 2 of those are international unknowns he discovered and coached up.

Todd Golden's three bigs were all unknowns.

It would seem the right recruiting process is having a concrete system, finding players that match/fit culture, actually coaching and then finding that one start through either HS or portal to insert.

We'll see what happens with Hurley's roster as he has 3 five stars in there all looking to make their mark.
 
#154      
Bro, HUH!? Names two US players, then blames a lack of scouting on “too many internationals”. Makes no sense.

When Brad says, “you guys are nuts, you have no idea what you’re doing”, this is the exact guy he’s talking about:

IMG_1978.jpeg
 
Last edited:
#155      
You might be overthinking it. The original comment you responded to said:

Wagler last year. Coleman this year. How does Illinois keep finding these guys???

That post isn't saying that Wagler and Coleman have identical recruiting profiles. They obviously don't. Coleman started his ascent in high school, whereas Keaton's didn't begin until he walked onto campus.

But 15 months ago, QC was ranked outside the top 100 on every major recruiting service. When he committed to Illinois in March, 247, which had him ranked highest out of any service, had him at #34 in his class. That's a solid player, no doubt. Think Adam Miller, even Ayo. But that's not a lottery pick.

We were QC's best offer. His second best was Texas Tech. Duke, Kentucky, Alabama, Arkansas, UConn, Houston, Kansas, Florida, Arizona, etc, didn't offer.

And he's going to get drafted top 5, top 3? I feel like asking "how does Illinois keep doing it?" is pretty fair here.
I agree with you both!

Wagler and QC are very different stories.

But they are both surprising in their own way. Wagler's story is definitely more unique, but QC, a guy who was ranked in the mid-teens just in July (247 composite) being now discussed seriously as a potential #1 pick - that's also pretty rare! So it's not surprising that people are surprised.

And like Gritty says, both very different situations point to our scouting being at least a major ingredient of the secret sauce. We seem to have more players who outperform expectations than just about anyone. It's true of our 3-stars but it's also true of our 5-stars.
 
#156      
Interesting tidbit related to QC's recruiting and rise. On this pod Adam Finkelstein reads (video should start at correct time) his scouting report of QC from 2025 Peach Jam:

 
#157      
#158      
You might be overthinking it. The original comment you responded to said:

Wagler last year. Coleman this year. How does Illinois keep finding these guys???

That post isn't saying that Wagler and Coleman have identical recruiting profiles. They obviously don't. Coleman started his ascent in high school, whereas Keaton's didn't begin until he walked onto campus.

But 15 months ago, QC was ranked outside the top 100 on every major recruiting service. When he committed to Illinois in March, 247, which had him ranked highest out of any service, had him at #34 in his class. That's a solid player, no doubt. Think Adam Miller, even Ayo. But that's not a lottery pick.

We were QC's best offer. His second best was Texas Tech. Duke, Kentucky, Alabama, Arkansas, UConn, Houston, Kansas, Florida, Arizona, etc, didn't offer.

And he's going to get drafted top 5, top 3? I feel like asking "how does Illinois keep doing it?" is pretty fair here.
I get it. And like I said, I want our staff to be getting more talent evaluation press and praise, not less.

I just also want Wagler to get his flowers for being a 1 of 1 in terms of a meteoric rise.

When Coleman enrolled at Illinois this summer he was widely understood within NBA scouting circles as a potential lottery pick. When Wagler enrolled last summer our staff knew his promise, but neither the Illinois side nor the Wagler side was even imagining what he was at that moment, let alone any outside scouts.

Of the team that just crushed Duke, Tomi is the only guy who was a direct Europe-to-Illinois recruit.

Wagler really is a story of visibility, and one that speaks pretty badly for the industry given his dominant high school career at a massive suburban high school in a hoops-crazy state. There is a lot you're missing if your whole field of vision is the big shoe brand AAU circuits and Keaton proved that.

But then, Ethan Brown was the MVP of the emergent New Balance circuit his senior summer.

The common thread is that the Illinois staff recognizes game feel within an NBA-style offensive structure better than anybody in college right now.
 
Last edited:
#159      
Vast majority? Literally 4 guys, two of whom came in as transfers from other NCAA programs (where they were definitely evaluated).

And anyone counting Stoj is a clown. Dude went to HS in California and played AAU ball for the Compton Magic. His recruitment and evaluation was no different than any other American kid.
Yeah, we have 2 true international kids that we recruited from overseas. Mirk and Tomi.

And this is coming from the director of basketball scouting at CBS/247.
 
#161      
Vast majority? Literally 4 guys, two of whom came in as transfers from other NCAA programs (where they were definitely evaluated).

And anyone counting Stoj is a clown. Dude went to HS in California and played AAU ball for the Compton Magic. His recruitment and evaluation was no different than any other American kid.
I know, 26% of our roster are international players, and so what anyway?
 
#163      
Vast majority? Literally 4 guys, two of whom came in as transfers from other NCAA programs (where they were definitely evaluated).

And anyone counting Stoj is a clown. Dude went to HS in California and played AAU ball for the Compton Magic. His recruitment and evaluation was no different than any other American kid.
And he was a McDAA. HM coaches and recruiting services knew who he was.

Further justification why I tuned out the national guys 20 years ago. They often only give lazy, surface level takes and don’t know what they are talking about.
 
#165      
lol.

I’m not sure “we weren’t active enough to evaluate players outside of the peach jam” is quite the rock solid reasoning he thinks it is.

That said, recruiting is hard. I’m not sure I’d agree with Brad saying “yall are crazy”, I think it’s more a reflection of how good he and his staff are. I think Brad would prefer take a light hearted jab at the media, then feel like he’s bragging - he’s pretty humble and would much prefer give players the credit than his scouting

What IS crazy though, is if you’re doubting players he brings in
 
Last edited:
#166      
He speaks exactly one truth there, which is that "evaluators" are nothing more than stenographers for the college coaches who actually know what they're scouting.

But again, ETHAN BROWN WAS THE LITERAL MVP OF A MAJOR AAU SHOE CIRCUIT


Willie Burnett III, Jonathan Sanderson and Marcis Ponder were Top 100 recruits with loads of high major offers who shared the all-circuit first team, but our guy, #205 in the class, was the MVP.
 
#169      
Just to keep piling on, Adam Finkelstein's #144 player in the class Zavier Zens was a high school teammate of the army platoon of Knueppel siblings at Wisconsin Lutheran, a nationally top-ranked high school program, and led the team over junior Kager Knueppel who is committed to Duke and as a total coincidence is therefore ranked #16 in the current class.
 
#171      
Bro, HUH!? Names two US players, then blames a lack of scouting on “too many internationals”. Makes no sense.

When Brad says, “you guys are nuts, you have no idea what you’re doing”, this is the exact guy he’s talking about:

View attachment 52849
Seriously. Of our season-to-date minutes distribution, 33% were transfers from other schools (so ignore these since everyone got to see them), 10% were signed from overseas (Tomi), and 57% were US high schoolers.

Mirk will obviously change that, so it might end up at 23% overseas and 44% US high schoolers.
 
#174      
He speaks exactly one truth there, which is that "evaluators" are nothing more than stenographers for the college coaches who actually know what they're scouting.

But again, ETHAN BROWN WAS THE LITERAL MVP OF A MAJOR AAU SHOE CIRCUIT


Willie Burnett III, Jonathan Sanderson and Marcis Ponder were Top 100 recruits with loads of high major offers who shared the all-circuit first team, but our guy, #205 in the class, was the MVP.
Was going to say the same thing. And by implication, I'm inclined to agree that other coaches also didn't know what they were doing when overlooking Wagler, and many also don't know what they're doing when going after the flashy stars who don't fit (or don't even end up being that good individually)
 
#175      
Seriously. Of our season-to-date minutes distribution, 33% were transfers from other schools (so ignore these since everyone got to see them), 10% were signed from overseas (Tomi), and 57% were US high schoolers.

Mirk will obviously change that, so it might end up at 23% overseas and 44% US high schoolers.
And to continue the pile on, Mirk played in the Nike Hoops summit which is now one of the more prestigious and high profile HS showcase events. You don’t get invited to the summit if you’re not on HM coaches’ radars. Also playing in the same game was none other than Dame Sarr.
 
Back