Everyone knows there are consequences. We don't know those consequences reliably enough to come to a consensus, and even if we did, there would be different opinions based on who is taking the risk, how much you value human life, etc..
IMO, the main thing to remember is there isn't a good answer when you have a pandemic that's killing large numbers of people, other than to get it under control. Unfortunately, we've gone the path of herd immunity, and by my estimates*, we're not quite there yet.
*I understand this is a controversial topic, and expect no one to take my opinion seriously. It depends on the R-naught, the rate of infection vs actual cases, cross-immunity, and other variables. The data I've given most weight says there are some states over the hump, and others (e.g.
Hawaii, new cases 7 day avg that are going hyperbolic). I tend find that data convincing, but I'm a non-expert. YMMV