Coaching Carousel (Football)

#131      

mhuml32

Cincinnati, OH
Fenelus --> Gibbs = clear upgrade
McDonald --> Stepp = push??
Buh --> McDaniel = clear downgrade (Buh firing really doesn't make sense with this being the alternative)

I would take McDonald over Stepp for a variety of reasons. Doesn’t take away from Stepp seeming like a good hire.
 
#134      
I would take McDonald over Stepp for a variety of reasons. Doesn’t take away from Stepp seeming like a good hire.
I don't know about that....I live in SC and watch every game of theirs. He has done a great job developing some receivers the past few years - Juice Wells and Xavier Legette in particular. Add in the fact he is a top recruiter and this seems like a very good hire
 
#136      

mhuml32

Cincinnati, OH
I don't know about that....I live in SC and watch every game of theirs. He has done a great job developing some receivers the past few years - Juice Wells and Xavier Legette in particular. Add in the fact he is a top recruiter and this seems like a very good hire


Totally agree with this …

This is an A level hire … IMO …

I said it was likely a good hire. Why is it always blasphemous to speak highly of a former coach?
 
#138      

mhuml32

Cincinnati, OH
How’s come?

McDonald proved to be a successful recruiter, had lots of strong State of Illinois connections, and developed the Illinois WR room into its best talent collection and performing unit in 15+ years. The bonus is he already did that at University of Illinois, he proved he could do that within the difficult environment of Illinois football. The market also supports my stance, as McDonald got a promotion and salary bump at a better program.

If Stepp maintains the success of the WR room that was established under McDonald, I would be thrilled. This hire checks some great boxes - he can recruit, he has experience, the development at his previous stop was good. Stepp could be really good at Illinois, but McDonald already was.
 
#141      

DeonThomas

South Carolina
General comment:

We have to face the fact that there are ~50 Division 1 schools that are upgrades over Illinois football. Then add to that number another 32 NFL franchises.

Coaches are inherently going to be enticed to leave if they have success here. And we should all consider it a good thing. Bring on the success!

Let's then use that success to continually improve our own coaching staff. It's an example of the world working as it should.

ILL !
 
#142      
I would take McDonald over Stepp for a variety of reasons. Doesn’t take away from Stepp seeming like a good hire.
honestly feel this is an upgrade in terms of development. I liked McDonald but was never thrilled with WR development. Feel like Stepp will really focus on this and hopefully develop more threats than just 1wr.
 
#143      
McDonald proved to be a successful recruiter, had lots of strong State of Illinois connections, and developed the Illinois WR room into its best talent collection and performing unit in 15+ years. The bonus is he already did that at University of Illinois, he proved he could do that within the difficult environment of Illinois football. The market also supports my stance, as McDonald got a promotion and salary bump at a better program.

If Stepp maintains the success of the WR room that was established under McDonald, I would be thrilled. This hire checks some great boxes - he can recruit, he has experience, the development at his previous stop was good. Stepp could be really good at Illinois, but McDonald already was.
How much of McDonald's success, or any WR coach for that matter, a function of how good your offensive co-ordinator is?
 
#144      
I liked McDonald but was never thrilled with WR development.

He took a lifelong QB and turned him into an NFL prospect
He took a relatively unathletic possession type guy and developed into a weapon his Sr year (and will get some NFL looks)
He took a borderline top 1000 recruit and turned him into one of the better WRs in the conf and likely our #1 next year
He took a chance on a lightly-recruited WR from the south and he showed some potential last year
Not to mention he recruited our best WR prospect in years

He had relatively little to ever work with here and did a great job as well as being the asst head coach
 
#145      
He took a lifelong QB and turned him into an NFL prospect
He took a relatively unathletic possession type guy and developed into a weapon his Sr year (and will get some NFL looks)
He took a borderline top 1000 recruit and turned him into one of the better WRs in the conf and likely our #1 next year
He took a chance on a lightly-recruited WR from the south and he showed some potential last year
Not to mention he recruited our best WR prospect in years

He had relatively little to ever work with here and did a great job as well as being the asst head coach
Only weapon was Juice. Not much else. just didn’t see much development. Just my opinion. Hoping Stepp can develop the group.
 
#146      

mhuml32

Cincinnati, OH
Only weapon was Juice. Not much else. just didn’t see much development. Just my opinion. Hoping Stepp can develop the group.

Pat might be a preseason all-B1G WR this year. Only one Illinois player had more receiving TDs than Bryant in the last 10 years. Casey Washington took major strides last year. Best chain mover on the team. He also was a solid blocker. This is also ignoring IW going from great athlete to one of the best WRs in CFB last year.
 
#147      

pruman91

Paducah, Ky
Last edited:
#148      
Pat might be a preseason all-B1G WR this year. Only one Illinois player had more receiving TDs than Bryant in the last 10 years. Casey Washington took major strides last year. Best chain mover on the team. He also was a solid blocker. This is also ignoring IW going from great athlete to one of the best WRs in CFB last year.
The inconsistencies plagued many in the wr room. Bryant dropped more balls than most and still struggles with route running. Washington should have improved considering age, but still too inconsistent. look forward to better development.