College Hoops Coaching Carousel

Status
Not open for further replies.
#651      

PizzaHutParkingLot

McPherson, KS
I think i'm seeing this different than most outsiders, so i want to offer a another scenario and wait for Indy to shoot me down.

I said in a Pre-Indybomb post
"Brad's sideline demeanor changed dramatically after Skyy left. There were no more back-from-commercial 'Look at Brad give it to them' segments. He yelled some, but he was different. He came out at halftime and sat on the bench. The coach-speak was there, but he usually wants us to believe him, and now he was just reciting the lines. ... I think that, while no coach could ever say it, NO ONE is more excited about this year being behind us than Brad Underwood."
At the time I attributed it to the not having player buy in, but the Indybomb puts it in a different perspective. I think Indy's info makes it plain that there is friction (at the very least) between Underwood and Whitman

Let's talk about the Indybomb first though.

I see Miller as a near fait accompli at this point. Not only did Indy come and spill a lot of beans, he (or she or they) stayed and answered questions and added details for hours! That just doesn't happen! It was awesome. (Thanks Indy!) Was it a psyop? If Indy does carry the imprimatur of the AD, then i think it was a psyop of the best kind. Lets look at what the Indybomb says to some different groups.

1: To Brad Underwood: Don't let the door hit ya.
2: To other ADs interviewing Brad Underwood: Don't overpay, there won't be a bidding war.
3: To Xavier's AD: Get your bag ready. Let's make this quick.
4: To our players: Don't put your name in the portal just yet.
5: To our fans: The jolt you will feel is not the floor dropping out, but the elevator starting to rise.
6: To EVERYONE: Josh Whitman is both the best boss you could hope to have and a stone cold killer.


Now Indy did say that there was still a chance that Underwood could be here next year, but assuming everything he says is true to the best of his knowledge (which i do), we have reached a point where the Athletic Department would like Underwood to leave. I think we can forgive him for looking at other gigs this year because it seems Whitman is encouraging him to. So how did we get here?

Underwood looking at jobs every year? Nah. It isn't endearing, but Josh is out here being the best boss he can be, he doesn't worry about that stuff. Our record / a disappointing tournament finish? Josh isn't sweating that. I think that Underwood's demeanor change marks the timing, and that the reason is... Skyy Clark.

Not Skyy Clark the individual though. Skyy Clark the idea. The highly rated player brought in with a generous NIL investment, with next to Zero ROI. Josh Whitman's basketball coach said 'I want that guy,' spent someone else's money on that guy, got that guy, and chased that guy away in half a season. I am pretty sure that there was mention of unhappy donors at some point (i don't remember if that was from Indy though), and i think the donor who covered Skyy's NIL would have had right to be upset.

We all know Underwood's style isn't for everyone - players and fans alike. That's never been a big deal - kids transfer out, so be it. But with NIL, when you scare off a kid, you risk scaring off a donor as well. If you were a donor who ponied up for Skyy Clark in 2023, how excited are you to be ponying up for his replacement in 2024? Whitman understands this well CANNOT run dry. CAN NOT!

For a coach with Underwood's style, you'd better know exactly who 'your guys' are when you are recruiting, because you can't afford to pay a kid like Skyy and be too aggro for them, but you also need the pool of 'your guys' to include enough high level players to take you to the next level, and to be lucky enough to win the recruiting battle to get 'your guy' to Illinois. This is stacking the deck against him. Most schools can spend their NIL money on the best available player, and end up with a lot more options.

I imagine the Clark situation highlighted this arithmetic for Whitman, Whitman shared those concerns with Brad, and I would wager that conversation went poorly. Very poorly. For the rest of the season Underwood poorly pantomimed positivity while we could see the team chucking their way to oblivion. "I wouldn't want to play us." "This team is built for March."

Underwood is eager to go, Whitman is ready when it happens, and Indy makes sure we all have our popcorn ready when the time comes.

(Note to insiders: if i am way off, feel free to correct me!)
Amazon Cleveland GIF by NFL On Prime Video
michael fassbender perfection GIF

I have nothing to add, except that this post was awesome (Can you do wrap ups of all the offseason insider bombs from now on?)
 
#654      
Regarding Skyy: Louisville will be his sixth school in six years. Seems like he “scares” a bit too easily.
True. But point remains how much money did we spend for him and have him quit mid season. I’m not sure all the reasons but like you said 6 schools seems like a trend and our staff got burned.

Regarding how BU acted on the sideline I think he also figured out it was not working with his current roster. Ayo Kofi Trent DMW played better after BU challenge them. I don’t think Mayer RJ Hawkins Epps was motivated by yelling
 
#657      
I just find Jackson more than a little bit sanctimonious and pompous. He’s got the wins. But had some of the best rosters...

He played in New York City. He won NBA titles there. Both of those things will give someone some... 'attitude' beginning right there. Then he racks up lots of hardware in the Second City and becomes a Big (Personal) Thing out of that. Then he goes to Tinseltown and snags even more hardware. (And yes, he had great players along the way on that journey).

But the point here is that having that level of success would put a strain on anybody's sense of being 'humble'. How would most of us handle that level of success in the same track of the three biggest roundball cities in the World? It's tempting to get a little... 'big-headed'.

But apart from all that is what Jackson accomplished with Jordan. He got Jordan to listen to him and buy in to his roundball approach and philosophy. Jordan had already been in the league for six years and all he could do is pile up great individual numbers. Jackson changed Jordan as a player and with his thinking about how to approach the game. And the Bulls became a monster.

And ‘reaching’ Jordan is something that I don’t think anyone else was going to do.

And one more thing. In his youth, Jackson grew up in a strict religious enviroment. It was in his nature to become a bit of a rebel and not 'be so humble'. He was kind of sick of humility by then.
 
#658      

pruman91

Paducah, Ky
I very much appreciate the kind words, but i'm not sure everyone else would agree with you. And even if they did, i barely have time to read the thread let alone contribute.
Great post...................Interesting thoughts and I have to admit , it was compelling and made me think.....We shall see how the drama unfurls and how close to the truth you got .....

I do have a question for anyone ....When skyy left the team did his access to NIL monies cease ??......OR , was that the reason he waited until we lost our game to Ark. b4 he publicly committed to L-ville .....Either way I have little to no respect for him and while
wishing no ill will , I hope he has zero production for the rest of his career......That's just how I roll....quitters are just that....QUITTERS
 
#659      

Dbell1981

Decatur, IL
Theo Epstein cannot fire Joe Maddon after he led the Cubs to their first World Series title in over a century. He just can't.

Adapt or die.

(I am not trying to say we need to adapt at this time; just that we can't use this excuse not to move on if it's plainly time.)
Terrible example. Cubs will stink for another 100 years! Go Cardinals
 
#661      

Dbell1981

Decatur, IL
1. According to fightingillini.com only 5 people didn’t: Joey Biggs, Zach hammer, Nicole Anderson, Adam fletcher, Paul schmidt
2. By what definition? Both players and coaches acknowledge a lack of control. There are fights during practice, multiple players transferring out mid-season, players refusing to enter games two years in a row.
3. Podz shouldve obviously been given playing time here in hindsight, and I just don’t believe Griffin and Miller left against their will.
Second and Chalmers or Obelix is that you?
 
#662      
Great post...................Interesting thoughts and I have to admit , it was compelling and made me think.....We shall see how the drama unfurls and how close to the truth you got .....

I do have a question for anyone ....When skyy left the team did his access to NIL monies cease ??......OR , was that the reason he waited until we lost our game to Ark. b4 he publicly committed to L-ville .....Either way I have little to no respect for him and while
wishing no ill will , I hope he has zero production for the rest of his career......That's just how I roll....quitters are just that....QUITTERS

He got all of his NIL payments. He burned us then he spurned us.
 
#663      
Great post...................Interesting thoughts and I have to admit , it was compelling and made me think.....We shall see how the drama unfurls and how close to the truth you got .....

I do have a question for anyone ....When skyy left the team did his access to NIL monies cease ??......OR , was that the reason he waited until we lost our game to Ark. b4 he publicly committed to L-ville .....Either way I have little to no respect for him and while
wishing no ill will , I hope he has zero production for the rest of his career......That's just how I roll....quitters are just that....QUITTERS
Skyy who? Did he play for the beloved? /s
 
#664      

pruman91

Paducah, Ky
He got all of his NIL payments. He burned us then he spurned us.
Thanks man...............I wish I could say what i really think of him , but I like coming here every day so I will just say it in the friendly confines of pruville....................your second sentence says it all for me...very defining.............

That really adds more credence to what Attention Def posted about the upset boosters idea.....hmmmmm..........
 
#666      

Illin618

I forgot the last i in my username
Southern IL
No No No if you live in Illinois you live in or near Chicago... Its a known fact if you tell someone you are from Illinois they presume you are from Chicago.

Oh and we are all Democrats
Best way for me to describe where I’m from is…

“I’m from Illinois”

*oh Chicago?*

“Nowhere near Chicago… southern Illinois”

*oh is that like Peoria or something??*

“Listen, I am basically from St. Louis just on the other side of the Mississippi”

😂😂😂
 
#667      

Ryllini

Lombard
Best way for me to describe where I’m from is…

“I’m from Illinois”

*oh Chicago?*

“Nowhere near Chicago… southern Illinois”

*oh is that like Peoria or something??*

“Listen, I am basically from St. Louis just on the other side of the Mississippi”

😂😂😂
Atleast we don't have to hold our palms out and point like they do in Michigan.
 
#668      

chiefini

Rockford, Illinois
I think i'm seeing this different than most outsiders, so i want to offer a another scenario and wait for Indy to shoot me down.

I said in a Pre-Indybomb post
"Brad's sideline demeanor changed dramatically after Skyy left. There were no more back-from-commercial 'Look at Brad give it to them' segments. He yelled some, but he was different. He came out at halftime and sat on the bench. The coach-speak was there, but he usually wants us to believe him, and now he was just reciting the lines. ... I think that, while no coach could ever say it, NO ONE is more excited about this year being behind us than Brad Underwood."
At the time I attributed it to the not having player buy in, but the Indybomb puts it in a different perspective. I think Indy's info makes it plain that there is friction (at the very least) between Underwood and Whitman

Let's talk about the Indybomb first though.


… So how did we get here?

Underwood looking at jobs every year? Nah. It isn't endearing, but Josh is out here being the best boss he can be, he doesn't worry about that stuff. Our record / a disappointing tournament finish? Josh isn't sweating that. I think that Underwood's demeanor change marks the timing, and that the reason is... Skyy Clark.

Not Skyy Clark the individual though. Skyy Clark the idea. The highly rated player brought in with a generous NIL investment, with next to Zero ROI. Josh Whitman's basketball coach said 'I want that guy,' spent someone else's money on that guy, got that guy, and chased that guy away in half a season. I am pretty sure that there was mention of unhappy donors at some point (i don't remember if that was from Indy though), and i think the donor who covered Skyy's NIL would have had right to be upset….

I imagine the Clark situation highlighted this arithmetic for Whitman, Whitman shared those concerns with Brad, and I would wager that conversation went poorly. Very poorly. For the rest of the season Underwood poorly pantomimed positivity while we could see the team chucking their way to oblivion…
Couple that with the Matthew Mayer “punch”/altercation and Underwood’s loss/lack of control and “culture,” Whitman had to be livid. Skyy Clark leaving, no matter how positively Underwood spun it, was a National negative for the program and university. The public shaming of Epps on National TV later and the Mayer Monster debacle couldn’t have helped, either. Your well-thought out theory, AttDef, seems very plausible…
 
#669      
He got all of his NIL payments. He burned us then he spurned us.
It’s a whole new world. I understand that it’s poor form to trash guys who are on the team and working hard, but playing poorly. And in the past, it was “they’re kids, they’re amateurs”. But at this point, Skyy Clark seems like an immature prima donna “professional” that effectively ripped off the Donating Illini with no remorse. I’m all for people calling that like they see it (but not sure if Dan will agree, and that’s cool, it’s his rules).
 
#670      
I think i'm seeing this different than most outsiders, so i want to offer a another scenario and wait for Indy to shoot me down.

I said in a Pre-Indybomb post
"Brad's sideline demeanor changed dramatically after Skyy left. There were no more back-from-commercial 'Look at Brad give it to them' segments. He yelled some, but he was different. He came out at halftime and sat on the bench. The coach-speak was there, but he usually wants us to believe him, and now he was just reciting the lines. ... I think that, while no coach could ever say it, NO ONE is more excited about this year being behind us than Brad Underwood."
At the time I attributed it to the not having player buy in, but the Indybomb puts it in a different perspective. I think Indy's info makes it plain that there is friction (at the very least) between Underwood and Whitman

Let's talk about the Indybomb first though.

I see Miller as a near fait accompli at this point. Not only did Indy come and spill a lot of beans, he (or she or they) stayed and answered questions and added details for hours! That just doesn't happen! It was awesome. (Thanks Indy!) Was it a psyop? If Indy does carry the imprimatur of the AD, then i think it was a psyop of the best kind. Lets look at what the Indybomb says to some different groups.

1: To Brad Underwood: Don't let the door hit ya.
2: To other ADs interviewing Brad Underwood: Don't overpay, there won't be a bidding war.
3: To Xavier's AD: Get your bag ready. Let's make this quick.
4: To our players: Don't put your name in the portal just yet.
5: To our fans: The jolt you will feel is not the floor dropping out, but the elevator starting to rise.
6: To EVERYONE: Josh Whitman is both the best boss you could hope to have and a stone cold killer.


Now Indy did say that there was still a chance that Underwood could be here next year, but assuming everything he says is true to the best of his knowledge (which i do), we have reached a point where the Athletic Department would like Underwood to leave. I think we can forgive him for looking at other gigs this year because it seems Whitman is encouraging him to. So how did we get here?

Underwood looking at jobs every year? Nah. It isn't endearing, but Josh is out here being the best boss he can be, he doesn't worry about that stuff. Our record / a disappointing tournament finish? Josh isn't sweating that. I think that Underwood's demeanor change marks the timing, and that the reason is... Skyy Clark.

Not Skyy Clark the individual though. Skyy Clark the idea. The highly rated player brought in with a generous NIL investment, with next to Zero ROI. Josh Whitman's basketball coach said 'I want that guy,' spent someone else's money on that guy, got that guy, and chased that guy away in half a season. I am pretty sure that there was mention of unhappy donors at some point (i don't remember if that was from Indy though), and i think the donor who covered Skyy's NIL would have had right to be upset.

We all know Underwood's style isn't for everyone - players and fans alike. That's never been a big deal - kids transfer out, so be it. But with NIL, when you scare off a kid, you risk scaring off a donor as well. If you were a donor who ponied up for Skyy Clark in 2023, how excited are you to be ponying up for his replacement in 2024? Whitman understands this well CANNOT run dry. CAN NOT!

For a coach with Underwood's style, you'd better know exactly who 'your guys' are when you are recruiting, because you can't afford to pay a kid like Skyy and be too aggro for them, but you also need the pool of 'your guys' to include enough high level players to take you to the next level, and to be lucky enough to win the recruiting battle to get 'your guy' to Illinois. This is stacking the deck against him. Most schools can spend their NIL money on the best available player, and end up with a lot more options.

I imagine the Clark situation highlighted this arithmetic for Whitman, Whitman shared those concerns with Brad, and I would wager that conversation went poorly. Very poorly. For the rest of the season Underwood poorly pantomimed positivity while we could see the team chucking their way to oblivion. "I wouldn't want to play us." "This team is built for March."

Underwood is eager to go, Whitman is ready when it happens, and Indy makes sure we all have our popcorn ready when the time comes.

(Note to insiders: if i am way off, feel free to correct me!)
Great read! You sure you’re not an insider?
 
#672      
Couple that with the Matthew Mayer “punch”/altercation and Underwood’s loss/lack of control and “culture,” Whitman had to be livid. Skyy Clark leaving, no matter how positively Underwood spun it, was a National negative for the program and university. The public shaming of Epps on National TV later and the Mayer Monster debacle couldn’t have helped, either. Your well-thought out theory, AttDef, seems very plausible…
And you didn’t even mention the “fart noise” he made during the embarrassing press do reence when he was asked about the leadership of TSJ.

It was not a great year for Brad.
 
#673      
Couple that with the Matthew Mayer “punch”/altercation and Underwood’s loss/lack of control and “culture,” Whitman had to be livid. Skyy Clark leaving, no matter how positively Underwood spun it, was a National negative for the program and university. The public shaming of Epps on National TV later and the Mayer Monster debacle couldn’t have helped, either. Your well-thought out theory, AttDef, seems very plausible…
Whitman wasn’t livid about Skyy leaving or “the punch”. Happens in every program.
 
#674      
I would think that if BU's looking/leaving didn't have legs, Whitman & BU would come out with a joint statement saying BU is our coach and everything else is just unfounded rumors--wouldn't that pretty much put things to bed (and decrease the number of pages on the coaching carousel)?
Pretty sure JW and BU don't conduct their business moves based on a message board thread. At least I hope not!!
 
#675      

chiefini

Rockford, Illinois
And you didn’t even mention the “fart noise” he made during the embarrassing press do reence when he was asked about the leadership of TSJ.

It was not a great year for Brad.
Agree. And I’ve been a total Underwood supporter who has appreciated how much he’s done so to bring this Illini program back to where it belongs. I’m hoping if he ends up staying, that his behavior this season is an outlier, and he gets his act together…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.