Seems as if this thread has died down a bit. Do we feel more comfortable that BU may come out of this okay? Looks as if, whatever happens to BU, it should not affect Illinois other than whatever happens to BU, if anything. Contrary to many people here, I am not as confident of the FBI's success in securing convictions or getting these people to trial or really getting much of anything accomplished. Lots of splashy headlines but in the end, not a lot will be accomplished. We have been hearing that this is just the tip of the iceberg and more will come out. Well, it's been a week and not a lot more has come out, has it? I could be wrong. And of course, it is still early but seems as if more would have surfaced by now. Sure some minor people will or may end up in jail or at the very least lose their careers (although, in a few years will probably turn up again somewhere). I don't have specific examples but seems that the FBI has botched as many cases or whatever as they have successfully concluded them, at least big time major cases such as this. But I can only say that after reading the newspapers for the last, oh, hundred years or so. Again, nothing specific pops into my mind. I firmly believe that Pitino will get off. He has the money to hire expensive good lawyers who will get him off. He may face some kind of NCAA action but that is about it. He will end up at a mid major some day and work his way back to a major school.
I think any D1 coach is still potentially at risk, until we get the word that Gatto (Adidas) and whomever from Nike have told all they know and the FBI has followed up on everything they plan on following up. And then we have to see what idiot thing the NCAA comes up with to save face.
So it's tough to answer your question. In terms of "was Underwood in imminent danger of being charged?" I'd have to probably go with no, unless Evans told them something and they just haven't acted on it yet.
But in a general "is Underwood completely out of danger for being implicated," I'd say he and (various estimates I've seen) from 20% to 80% of all D1 coaches are likely at some point coaching teams on which are players who are being paid by shoe companies, or coaching teams on which at least one assistant has taken money to set up a meeting.
So I do not think things dying down on this forum means that we're in the clear at all. I do agree that given Illinois' utter lack of 4 and 5 star recruiting under Groce that in all likelihood Groce was not actively participating in this pay-for-play system. I think in all likelihood Groce was running a clean program. Kudos and fair play to him.
But the bigger picture of who is going to be getting charged by the FBI is still wide open. They're only just now interviewing the original arrest subjects. Those people are only last 7 days giving their statements. It takes time to go corroborate those statements and if warranted issue more arrests do more interviews.
I would argue for the next 12 months at least, or until the FBI actually issues a statement that they're finished, we won't really know. And I would also argue that the NCAA could still do some crack-headed enforcement action based only on its own need to cover its !!! with regard to protecting its Storied Programs. I swear schools like Illinois - big enough to matter, but not big enough that anyone cares if they get accused - exist only so the NCAA can point at someone and say "See, we did something!"
So in that semi-conspiracy theory based on bitter experience as an Illini fan since the 70s... we're *never* quite always out of the woods. The minute a national scandal happens, they'll look around to see if the usual suspects are available. Illinois is one of those. We've had 3 major scandals in 40 years (2 football, 1 basketball) that I can remember. There will be people at the NCAA trying to pin as much of this on schools like Illinois as they can, so that they themselves can elude further scrutiny.
And Chicago will be dogpiling on like they always do as well. Already I have seen them attempt to tie Underwood "associations with Evans" to Illinois. If they ever find a shred of evidence that sticks, they will be promoting the story line non stop for months.
So on all 3 fronts, we're in no way out of the woods yet. Sorry.
Roast me. If I'm full of crap or too full of conspiracy theory, please take a moment and explain, because I'd like to let go of this opinion a bit as well.