Game Thread: Illinois at Michigan State

Status
Not open for further replies.
#203      
So why is every play not reviewed to make sure a call wasn’t missed? How can al personal foul be called from replay if it wasn’t called on the field? Can’t be correct.

It was called a personal foul, targeting is a personal foul.
 
#204      

sbillini

st petersburg, fl
Targeting has always been reviewable.

Yes. But by adding the late hit, they defacto reviewed the play for a late hit. I didn't know that was reviewable either (adding a late hit call when none was called initially).
 
#205      
Somebody stated are LB'S had good depth in the recruiting thread. I can say with confidence it doesn't have depth.
 
#206      
They ruled it no targeting which would mean no foul. You can't just throw a late hit flag in there. That's non reviewable last time I checked. Perhaps I'm outdated lol

Not quite. It was called a personal foul, targeting. They simply removed the targeting. They’ve been calling it like this since last season.
 
#208      

Deleted member 656517

D
Guest
Not quite. It was called a personal foul, targeting. They simply removed the targeting. They’ve been calling it like this since last season.
I guess I just didn't didn't like the wording from the ref, and the outcome of the game. I'm just letting out fumes lol
 
#210      

the national

the Front Range
They just can’t throw on a foul when reviewing for another foul. That’s garbage. Late hits are not reviewable.
 
#211      
Regardless I don’t think it was late either but whatever this games over anyway.

It was iffy but it’s not reviewable. The only reviewable portion of that play is whether or not the player is guilty of targeting and subject to dismissal. Luckily, they got that right.
 
#214      
Nice to see Brandon using the whole pocket. Hadn’t done that since the UConn game.
 
#216      

sbillini

st petersburg, fl
It was iffy but it’s not reviewable. The only reviewable portion of that play is whether or not the player is guilty of targeting and subject to dismissal. Luckily, they got that right.

Since this game isn't going anywhere, i'm gonna spend my time learning something. So are you saying they called two penalties on the play (late hit, targeting), and they reviewed and reversed the targeting? But since late hits are not reviewable, that stood as called? Or did they remove the targeting call and added the late hit during the review? It makes sense to me if it's the former, but just weird that they wouldn't initially call it both. If it's the latter (which is how i think many of us are interpreting it), that makes no sense.
 
#217      
Brandon owes Donny an apology. I know he’s scrambling but that’s a ball placed to get someone hurt
 
#219      
Navarro was defenseless there but in fairness it’s not like that defender threw a weak cross from the ground at the rear of a lineman who was stepping on his face.
 
#221      
Illini about to give up over 500 yards to offensive powerhouse, MSU!

Love Michigan States prison jumpsuits. Very classy.
 
#222      
Since this game isn't going anywhere, i'm gonna spend my time learning something. So are you saying they called two penalties on the play (late hit, targeting), and they reviewed and reversed the targeting? But since late hits are not reviewable, that stood as called? Or did they remove the targeting call and added the late hit during the review? It makes sense to me if it's the former, but just weird that they wouldn't initially call it both. If it's the latter (which is how i think many of us are interpreting it), that makes no sense.

Sorta. There’s only one penalty, a personal foul but the added measure the NCAA placed on these plays as a matter of player safety was the designation of targeting. The way it gets called is as “Personal Foul-Targeting”, which further subjects the player to potential dismissal from the game. The targeting I believe is an auto review but regardless of what that review reveals, it’s still a personal foul on the field.
 
#223      
Not sure why they don't throw every play...we don't get a rush so eventually someone will be open
 
#224      

the national

the Front Range
The hit on Navarro, the defender led with his head. It wasn’t helmet to helmet. But isn’t leading with the head called targeting?
 
#225      
Gotta give credit, that’s a great throw and route. That route is extremely difficult to complete but it’s the classic Cover 2/4 killer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.