Somewhat lucky circumstances with the Giants aside, what does Tommy DeVito have that Luke doesn't?
Mainly lucky circumstances, but also TDV as a pretty elite quick release/accuracy combo.
Add in being a vocal leader type and he's a classic good vibes local kid training camp practice squad guy, and then a series of crazy events made him a media star.
I was shocked he made a roster because of his genuinely minus arm strength, something I figured was disqualifying. It's definitely why he'll never be a starter for any length of time, there are just a lot of throws an NFL QB has to have that he doesn't.
Luke's arm talent is average, playable. But like TDV he's pretty ordinary from a height/length/bulk perspective, and his low release point and slingshotty delivery tends to make those measurables play down. He's very fast in the open field but not very fluid, pretty average from an escapability/athleticism perspective.
I'm honest enough to admit I was a Luke hater a year ago, he just did not take care of the ball well enough for a B1G QB, let alone an NFL one in 2023. He improved a ton. If he makes yet another leap in terms of his decision making, accuracy, and physicality, hey, anything is possible.