Illinois #10 in AP Poll

#1      

Dan

Admin
Welcome to the Polls Thread
 
#3      
Why would we take a big tumble, when we got beat at Texas Tech, who has won 102 of their last 103 nonconference home games without two starters. We looked awful in the first half, but cut it to a one- possession game and let three offensive rebounds sink us before they hit a three.
 
#6      
Not a bad loss by any means, but I'll guess 11 or 12. A lot of voters won't know or care that we were down 2 starters.
 
#7      
I would guess 7-8.
I agree with this, and that would be if things go “our way.” 9-11 being a fair tumble, as in they are respectful of our loss but punish us as well. Closer to 15 if they want to hurt us, anything beyond 15 and it’s harsh, but maybe the slap in the face our team needs.

The Sam Houston game prior to our pull-away, or the resulting defensive rating, might still hurt our ranking. But to be honest, we are not a finished product. We might not look like we can be a top 5 program at this moment, but we absolutely and objectively CAN be by February and March. Just gotta put in the work. Florida last year dropped nearly all marquee matchups and still ended up being a 1 seed.
 
#14      
#15      
still top 10 and right behind a team that beat us. 2nd highest 1 loss team. seems fair for now given that we have seemed somewhat disinterested in being a top ranked team thus far
 
#17      
still top 10 and right behind a team that beat us. 2nd highest 1 loss team. seems fair for now given that we have seemed somewhat disinterested in being a top ranked team thus far
Disinterested in being a ranked team because we’ve struggled a bit down 2 leaders while being led by a new back court?
 
#18      
This team right now shouldn't be better than 10. Probably worse.

There is a weird break between the pre-season poll which is measuring what people think will be the situation at the end of the year, and the polls as soon as the games start, which measure how good the team is "right now". Down our best player and with our #5 player out for the season, along with a heavy reliance on freshman that will hopefully get better over the course of the year spells to me a #10-15 ranking. It would be pretty silly to have all the rankers try to pro forma what every team would be if they were healthy rather than judging on how the team actually looks at any given time.

When Mirk comes back, and as the freshman (who are now getting more playing time with davis and mirk out) improve, and we'll be back up high by the end of the year. If we can win even one of the two tough preseason games left (Duke & Uconn) and win both of the early big ten games (which we've struggled on recently), we'll be in great shape, even if we are ranking 12-15.
 
#19      
10 is too low imo. Probably had to do it to get TT ahead of them. Anyways, doesn't matter as they have a chance to move back up by winning on Tuesday.
 
#20      
Disinterested in being a ranked team because we’ve struggled a bit down 2 leaders while being led by a new back court?
Clearly these freshmen aren’t serious about winning against a top 10 veteran team on the road while without two of their own leaders and best players. Kids and their video games these days.

(Heavy /s if it isn’t obvious… truly ridiculous take)
 
#22      
This team right now shouldn't be better than 10. Probably worse.

There is a weird break between the pre-season poll which is measuring what people think will be the situation at the end of the year, and the polls as soon as the games start, which measure how good the team is "right now". Down our best player and with our #5 player out for the season, along with a heavy reliance on freshman that will hopefully get better over the course of the year spells to me a #10-15 ranking. It would be pretty silly to have all the rankers try to pro forma what every team would be if they were healthy rather than judging on how the team actually looks at any given time.

When Mirk comes back, and as the freshman (who are now getting more playing time with davis and mirk out) improve, and we'll be back up high by the end of the year. If we can win even one of the two tough preseason games left (Duke & Uconn) and win both of the early big ten games (which we've struggled on recently), we'll be in great shape, even if we are ranking 12-15.
Who at all has ever said Jake is out for the season? All insiders have pointed to him making a comeback somewhere in the latter half of the season.

People did this too with Mirk. Insiders saying he’ll be back in November. “Oh well Mirk is done for the season. Might as well move on and never consider him ever again.” Sometimes I think I must be missing a message or two.

2 weeks and only 4 games into the season, people.
 
#23      
Not a bad loss by any means, but I'll guess 11 or 12. A lot of voters won't know or care that we were down 2 starters.
The problem is that it's not 2 starters for one game. It's for the foreseeable future. This is who we until until.......???? Without Mirk and Jake heading into January and we're playing this many freshmen with really no interior presence, we're borderline top 25.

If it were just a one off game, we probably don't drop 7 spots. If we get run out of the stadium tomorrow, then the questions become extremely real. If we lose to UCONN, we would have lost every marquee game in November/December. The game vs Mizzou carries absolutely no national relevance.

There have been very few updates on Mirk. I think a timeline of "sometime in 2027" is very possible. When you have to go back into the boot in a non weight bearing situation, that's a restart. This is a 6'9", 250+ lb man who puts a lot of stress on those feet, ankles and knees. The coaches can spin this however they want, but physiology is what it is.

When things were going well with the rehab, I was hoping he'd be a factor vs UCONN. Now, no way. We're closing in on two weeks away.
 
#24      
Illinois lost by 6 to a ranked team in a hostile environment, drops 7 spots.

Arkansas lost by 19 to a ranked team in a neutral environment, drops 1 spot.

What The Hell Wtf GIF
 
#25      
If it were just a one off game, we probably don't drop 7 spots. If we get run out of the stadium tomorrow, then the questions become extremely real. If we lose to UCONN, we would have lost every marquee game in November/December. The game vs Mizzou carries absolutely no national relevance.
Part of this is also because we have no "medium" difficulty games on the schedule until conference play. We have 6 cupcakes, 2 top 10 teams on the road and a semi-home game against another top 10 team. I understand playing tough teams in the noncon but it does make it hard when we start the season injured.
If our first stretch of the season was more like, for example, Wisconsin (4 cupcakes, unranked Seton Hall and either unranked NC State or Murray State at a Neutral site), we could very well be unbeaten going into conference play in a very different conversation.
It seems like we generally don't play mediocre teams in the noncon when we can help it. Usually if we play a power conference team in the noncon they're ranked, unless it's Missouri who we play every year. That means it can be hard for us to wrack up "decent, but not amazing" wins early.
 
Back