Illinois Football Recruiting Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
#257      
On the other hand, the last few years, we've only gone as far as our QB could take us. I'm not sure I'd trade a slightly better defense for a mediocre QB.
Now if Clayton or Boyd could handle the reins and be a top quarter B1G passer that's a different story. Trouble is we won't have any garbage time the rest of the season to find out.
 
#259      
I asked a question about NIL budgets a while back and people came back with how it is somewhat limited and monitored across the board and that was why so much of the Gies contribution went to infrastructure rather than players. There have been recent articles from the Athletic showing how the big programs are spending double what we spend on their rosters. With that in mind... Why was a donation of that magnitude not put towards the roster this year? It's clear we could have used it... I love Bret - a higher quality roster under him would be a true contender.
 
#260      
On the other hand, the last few years, we've only gone as far as our QB could take us. I'm not sure I'd trade a slightly better defense for a mediocre QB.
Now if Clayton or Boyd could handle the reins and be a top quarter B1G passer that's a different story. Trouble is we won't have any garbage time the rest of the season to find out.

It’s hard to count on a qb who’s never been on the field. Obviously they see them in practice but it’s risky. It would be great for the program if we needed to bring in a transfer to start
 
#261      
If we want to compete we will need to be around 25-30m NIL wise to be in the top half of the Big Ten next year and that will be inclusive of a new QB. Hopefully we can atleast get to 7 wins to say that we continued momentum through a year that was expected to be closer to rebuilding year.
Aligned with the later conversation about DL prices and the overall rise in the market, I do not have faith that the numbers here would equate to a top-half NIL budget in 2027...we are at 24+ this year already and not competitive on the defensive side of the ball.
 
#262      
Aligned with the later conversation about DL prices and the overall rise in the market, I do not have faith that the numbers here would equate to a top-half NIL budget in 2027...we are at 24+ this year already and not competitive on the defensive side of the ball.
In every year of the NIL era the price level in January was unimaginable the prior October.

It does have to hit a wall at some point, but it's pure guesswork when that arrives.

My personal heuristic would be to just watch the S&P 500, that's where all this cash is coming from.

The next recession is going to be a thousand year flood for the whole American sports industry.
 
#263      
What's the likelihood we go Carson Boyd as our starter, save the NIL and put it towards places we need it more?
Slim.

Illinois is going to the portal for a QB regardless. Zero percent chance they go into the season with 4 QB's who have taken only a few college snaps.

How much will they pay? It's the one (and only) portal position that has paid off every year so do they change that and go a different route? Doubtful IMO.

The only caveat is if Hauser gets injured and one of the back ups has to step up and plays reasonably well.
 
#264      
#265      
What's the likelihood we go Carson Boyd as our starter, save the NIL and put it towards places we need it more?

Even if the plan was to make one of the internal options the starter, I'm not even sure it will be Boyd.
 
#266      
If true, this is a major change from what insiders were saying in late summer.
Is it? A change toward Boyd or away from him?

Even if the plan was to make one of the internal options the starter, I'm not even sure it will be Boyd.
No way, Boyd has been treated completely differently from prior prep recruits. He has the buy-in internally.
 
#267      
If true, this is a major change from what insiders were saying in late summer.
I don’t think Boyd has taken the jump the staff thought he would. Bret’s comments about it depending on the situation of who would be the back up in a game were pretty telling. Also hard to argue the results we’ve had with proven transfers
 
#270      
Illinois is going to the portal for a QB regardless. Zero percent chance they go into the season with 4 QB's who have taken only a few college snaps.
Have any other programs started a guy w/o significant college snaps? Would it be so unprecedented?
 
#271      
Have any other programs started a guy w/o significant college snaps? Would it be so unprecedented?
Of course, lots of teams every year.

But that's not what's brought success to Illinois and Bielema. Altmyer didn't have a lot of experience his first year and that's didn't as well as planned. They also had John Paddock a very experience QB.

That's different than:

Carson Boyd
Michael Clayton
Dane Eisenmenger
Sladen Shack

I don't see any way they don't pick up an experienced portal QB. How much they're willing to spend and/or do they expect that QB to start? We shall see.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back