Illinois Hoops Recruiting Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
#252      
I absolutely hate being on this list.
Jason Sudeikis Yes GIF by Apple TV+

Username checks out
 
#253      
I hypothesize the fans on this board who’s fandom lived through prime of the Henson years associate their fandom more closely with the coach more than recent fans. It makes sense. Henson was a HOF legend who had a lot of success as the players came and went to the point his name is on the court.

I suspect those posters wanted Weber to be like Henson and continued to defend him long past it was clear he wasn’t. I suspect the same thing is happening with Brad and some posters holding onto the hope that over the next 10 years he’ll cement his legacy.

My eyes see a ship that’s already sailed, and it’s just a matter of time before there is a separation. I do not envision a future where Brad retires as the Illini coach.

The Ayo recruitment was supposed to open the flood gates - and it did - BU recruited 11 freshman 4-stars in the last 4 years.

The problem is 6 of those 4 star recruits transferred out. So, BU recruited 2 4-star transfers (Mayer and Shannon) to back fill.

Now we are in another season needing to backfill from failure to develop the HS recruits, and BU has failed to fill the most critical gap.

What happens next year?

Shannon, Coleman, Harmon, Guerrero, Domask will be gone.

The team will be Dainja, Goode, Harris, Rodgers, Hansberry, and DGL, and chances are 1 or 2 of those guys will transfer. We have 1 signed recruit - Morez.

BU is going to need to add 6-9 players next offseason in addition to Morez? And he couldn’t even land a single PG this year?

BU is only in this situation because he failed to develop 50% of his 4 star recruits so he started recruiting players in the portal that other coaches developed for him, and now he’s struggling to do that too. So over the next season or two he’ll suddenly become good at what he’s failed to do so far?
Zzzzzzzzzzz

Must be tough spending every waking moment manufacturing rationales to trash Underwood.

Tell us what you do for a living?
Be interested to know.
 
#256      
I think right now that BU getting his act together is our best chance at a championship. Stability matters. But him getting his act together is the important caveat for me. There really is no culture, despite the coach others proclaiming such. We don't seem to have a consistent philosophy on either side of the ball. I'm willing to see him sort this out before I'm calling for his head.

There are very few coaches that I think are worth the risk of firing BU. Sean Miller isn't one in my opinion.

I'm also optimistic about the season ahead, although I can definitely see scenarios where we end up on the bubble.

Brad has burnt some bridges … No getting around it … He has recruited some really good players but outside of Ayo and Kofi he has not kept any … And Kofi only stayed for one rea$on … Let’s just keep it 💯 on that …

At the end of the day, as a HC you can’t lose the boosters and that’s the road Brad is heading down … Josh will ALWAYS side with the boosters and that’s just how it goes … Especially when we haven’t touched a 2nd weekend …

Stability doesn’t mean jack anymore … These kids are pros now … They leave every year anyways … There is no culture … You need a guy who can COACH and a guy who can really, really get along with the boosters so he can recruit … Sean Miller does both of those things at an elite level … Muss does as well … Tang does as well … All would be upgrades …

Oats will be getting the next blue blood job that opens between UNC and Kansas … He isn’t coming here … Wouldn’t even consider it …

Now … I’ve got a sleepover to get to … 🙄

… GMAB

Season 2 Trailer GIF by Amazon Prime Video
 
Last edited:
#257      
Brad has burnt some bridges … No getting around it … He has recruited some really good players but outside of Ayo and Kofi he has not kept any … And Kofi only stayed for one rea$on … Let’s just keep it 💯 on that …

At the end of the day, as a HC you can’t lose the boosters and that’s the road Brad is heading down … Josh will ALWAYS side with the boosters and that’s just how it goes … Especially when we haven’t touched a 2nd weekend …

Stability doesn’t mean jack anymore … These kids are pros now … They leave every year anyways … There is no culture … You need a guy who can COACH and a guy who can really, really get along with the boosters so he can recruit … Sean Miller does both of those things at an elite level … Muss does as well … Tang does as well … All would be upgrades …

Oats will be getting the next blue blood job that opens between UNC and Kansas … He isn’t coming here … Wouldn’t even consider it …

Now … I’ve got a sleepover to get to … 🙄

… GMAB

Season 2 Trailer GIF by Amazon Prime Video
jiggity GIF
 
#258      
There seem to be two schools of thought emerging here:

1) "A coach shouldn't be let go until he has objectively sunk a program." This approach led to the enormous mess that Brad inherited.

2) "A coach should be let go before he has had a chance to sink a program." This approach led to Tim Beckman.

In my opinion, and as others have said I think, I don't care when you let a guy go as long as the next hire is the right hire. But preferably you can cut ties before your program hits rock bottom.

*This is not an endorsement for firing Brad.
I agree that you shouldn't have to let a coach bottom out or sink a program.

I personally think Underwood has done enough to get 2 more seasons barring him not crashing and burning this year.

However, if a guy like Oats, Muss, or Miller was actually available and he doesn't make a run this year then I think you have to seriously consider it. The only way you make that change though is if you know you have a guaranteed proven successor in place.
 
#261      
Brad has burnt some bridges … No getting around it … He has recruited some really good players but outside of Ayo and Kofi he has not kept any … And Kofi only stayed for one rea$on … Let’s just keep it 💯 on that …

At the end of the day, as a HC you can’t lose the boosters and that’s the road Brad is heading down … Josh will ALWAYS side with the boosters and that’s just how it goes … Especially when we haven’t touched a 2nd weekend …

Stability doesn’t mean jack anymore … These kids are pros now … They leave every year anyways … There is no culture … You need a guy who can COACH and a guy who can really, really get along with the boosters so he can recruit … Sean Miller does both of those things at an elite level … Muss does as well … Tang does as well … All would be upgrades …

Oats will be getting the next blue blood job that opens between UNC and Kansas … He isn’t coming here … Wouldn’t even consider it …

Now … I’ve got a sleepover to get to … 🙄

… GMAB

Season 2 Trailer GIF by Amazon Prime Video
don't deny it

Blake Shelton Nbc GIF by The Voice
 
#262      
The team will be Dainja, Goode, Harris, Rodgers, Hansberry, and DGL, and chances are 1 or 2 of those guys will transfer. We have 1 signed recruit - Morez.

BU is going to need to add 6-9 players next offseason in addition to Morez? And he couldn’t even land a single PG this year?
He still added Domask, Harmon, and Guerrier this year without a PG.

His biggest issue has been lack of development moreso than guys transferring. The only guy to transfer out that hurts is Podz and it was perfectly understandable why he would leave. I can't blame Brad for that.

If the young guys keep developing Dainja, Hansberry, and Morez is a solid interior build plus Goode and Rodgers on the wing then Harris and DGL at guard.

That's 7 contributors right there. Teams don't roll that deep so youre realistically only looking for 3 transfers. They will also add some more freshman alongside Morez. Adding 3 contributors isn't a super difficult task since he added two last year in Shannon and Mayer and then already has 3 this year.
 
#265      
Wow

all of this ugly talk about BU and disgruntled boosters and drunk players. .

Makes me kinda long for the "why couldn't we keep Podz?" discusions...

On 2d thought....
 
#266      
I’ve been waiting for the disillusioned alumni donors to start showing up since NIL was introduced. The idea that one can buy a title or even sweet 16 given all the complexities 18-22 year old spoiled amateur athletes bring to the table is proving absurd. It is difficult enough in the pro leagues (Mets….). To say nothing of injuries, refs, or just the likelihood of getting a bad matchup in a single elimination tournament. This golden age for the players will be ending. Not sure what it will be replaced with, but if I had to guess, much more structured, back loaded deals, scaled to measurable factors.
.
 
#268      
Stability doesn’t mean jack anymore … These kids are pros now … They leave every year anyways … There is no culture … You need a guy who can COACH and a guy who can really, really get along with the boosters so he can recruit … Sean Miller does both of those things at an elite level … Muss does as well … Tang does as well … All would be upgrades …
Are all 3 legit options? It seems like the concern many have here is that if we were to move on from BU we wouldn’t be able to land a capable replacement. I’d be happy with all 3 you listed but are they legit options?
 
#269      
He still added Domask, Harmon, and Guerrier this year without a PG.

His biggest issue has been lack of development moreso than guys transferring. The only guy to transfer out that hurts is Podz and it was perfectly understandable why he would leave. I can't blame Brad for that.

If the young guys keep developing Dainja, Hansberry, and Morez is a solid interior build plus Goode and Rodgers on the wing then Harris and DGL at guard.

That's 7 contributors right there. Teams don't roll that deep so youre realistically only looking for 3 transfers. They will also add some more freshman alongside Morez. Adding 3 contributors isn't a super difficult task since he added two last year in Shannon and Mayer and then already has 3 this year.
I agree with all this… but at a program level is that where you want to be in year 8?
 
#270      
What happens next year?

The team will be Dainja, Goode, Harris, Rodgers, Hansberry, and DGL, and chances are 1 or 2 of those guys will transfer. We have 1 signed recruit - Morez.

BU is going to need to add 6-9 players next offseason in addition to Morez? And he couldn’t even land a single PG this year?
If we have those seven, six of which will have another year of experience, and Hansberry and DGL are anywhere near as good as their reputation/recruiting rank, then I expect a 6-8 seed in March. I'm not seeing a major issue. If 2 of them transfer out, despite being in line for big minutes, then yes, there is a culture issue.
 
#271      
I agree with all this… but at a program level is that where you want to be in year 8?
No but college basketball ebbs and flows for every program even the blue bloods. Teams have up and down years based on personnel.

I think this years team is incredibly deep even without a PG addition. They might not be as good next year but who knows. The transfer portal has kind of spoiled people into not relying on the unknown but college basketball is built on unheralded recruits developing.

Ty could become a stud, Goode could be a knockdown 3 pt shooter in the mold of a Ben Brust then maybe one or both of DGL become dynamic point guards and Hansberry and Johnson could team up to be an incredibly dynamic inside. Also the sky is the limit if Harris can develop some offensive skills.

If next year's team is DGL/Moretti, Goode/Harris, Rodgers, Hansberry, Morez/Dainja. That is 8 deep already and 7 of them are basically top 100 guys(yes I know Harris and DGL weren't quite top 100). Retain those guys add a veteran guard, forward, and big and that's a talented roster.
 
#272      
The one thing that gets me is the excuses I hear. We got manhandled by Loyola, we never led, and people always go to the excuse that Loyola was underseeded but leave out the fact that in the next round they loss to 12 seed Oregon St

Then the next year we were lucky to get by Chattanooga and then got dominated by Houston who yes may have been under seeded but it's the NCAA tourney just show up and play

Then of course against Arkansas we didn't even show up to play when all we heard from Brad was "This team is built for March"

That's 4 really ugly games in the tourney
 
Status
Not open for further replies.