I know winning is the key benchmark, but just to play devil's advocate here; in one of our "middling" years of 2024-2025, we're set to finish 17th in Kenpom, which is essentially in the top 5% of all of college basketball. Still not great, but IMO not worth the 5-alarm fire sentiment some are showing here.
In terms of continuity, I don't think next year can be completely written off as suboptimal yet. If we return Boswell, Ivisic, DGL (sounds like its not likely), Humrichhouse, and Jake Davis, this would be 52% continuity, around 20% above average. Take out DGL, this is 44.6%. If you add Ty back in (on the off chance he stays), this is another 11% back in (although this would be an astrick). Even if you only keep Bam and Tomi, this is 27% continuity, which is 6% below average, but this is coming off a year where you're sending 2 players to the draft.
All I'm saying is if we're being conservative and looking at the data objectively, our continuity will definitely be better than last year, and at worst case suboptimal but best case as of now still well above NCAA average.