I thought the eligibility the NCAA gave out was some what arbitrary. I remember a lot of folks thinking Petro would be classed a Junior but he ended up a Sophomore IIRC.
I’m obviously extremely bias considering how our team has been constructed, but i think the only rules on eligibility I care about are career earnings in pro leagues and age limits.
There are legal issues with both but I don’t want guys who’ve made something like 500k and are 26 to be playing 18 year olds in college.
I also HATE the “I was drafted, but I wasn’t good enough to make the NBA so I’m coming back to college” crowd. That feels like an easy loophole to close. I will say if you go undrafted, sign in the g league, and don’t play a minute of NBA basketball, I’m fine with you coming back, but playing in the NBA and/or getting drafted should eliminate your college eligibility zero exceptions.