I remember seeing a ton of comments on here about how Oregon was a bad team and how was it was a shame that we got beat by an inferior team. I believe it was due to their kenpom ranking at the time. That Oregon team ending up 2nd in the PAC 12 and winning a game in the tournament. Winning that game may have been enough to make the dance, despite losing to Nebraska and getting destroyed by Michigan.
That leads to my point:
We have no idea how good these teams will actually be the end of the season but they can make a tremendous impact. In the 2014-15 season, we had 4 top 50 wins and one sub 100 loss and we were still pretty close to making the dance. Right now, we already two wins against teams that might end up in the top 50. A win here might make it 3. Even if VCU and NC State end up being mediocre, it would look really good to have wins against them and BYU in non conference play when we could have easily just scheduled sub 200 teams. It's great when Mizzou is one of the worst teams that we'll play this season.
There are poorly informed posters for every game --I don't think that kind of anecdote takes away from the usefulness of analytical tools, especially when you consider any sample of 1 game is nearly useless/highly variable.
Since that info is still available, I took a look at KenPom 2014. Oregon was 28th in the nation. Illinois was 52nd. Interestingly, his efficiency margin has them about 6 points better. As far as 'at the time', they lost to 2 ranked teams early in the season, so they may well have been lower. OTOH, we'd done exactly the same, lost to 2 ranked teams.
Anyway, as far as I can tell, it's the best info we have --projecting teams at the end of the season seems like voodoo, with the possible exception of Michigan State, which has a long history of biting off more than they can chew early, and using it to great affect later in the season.
If your point is that we don't know where they will trend, I agree completely. Some of the early games can look a lot different come March. I just wish we these discussions were about what seed we deserve, rather than how many more good wins we'll need to get on the good side of the bubble.
BYU is very close to us in the metrics I tend to look at. Should be a good game. I like the little bit of momentum we've built, and have really enjoyed seeing some toughness from Tracy and especially Black. If Kipper comes in with a chip on his shoulder, I'm hoping he can give us some offense for defense looks late in game, which can be a big deal. Even if he just brings in some toughness off the bench, this team can really use it.