The years we made playoff are in italics. The years we won division are bolded and italicized. The years we finished below .500 are in red.
2014 - 12th
2015 - 12th
2016 - 8th
2017 - 10th
2018 - 9th
2019 - 7th
2020 - 11th
2021 - 9th
2022 - 13th
2023 - 16th
2024 - 14th
2025 - 19th
2026 (as of today) - 24th
As you can see, back in 2014/2015 payroll was outside the top ten. The team still did fine. But you look at those years and wonder what those teams could have been with another impact bat, because the pitching to go all the way was there. Investment bumped slightly back up to hover just into the top 10. For the years 2014-2022, a fairly competitive period, they were outside the top ten for four out of nine seasons.
When Covid hits, you see our payroll rank suffer. Keep in mind, Covid did not only hit St. Louis, or hit St. Louis disproportionately. But the teams were still competitive, even as other teams are passing us in payroll. The 2022 team was good. We won 93 games, won the division. Playoffs exposed some weaknesses, but there was a competitive team there. And we had the second highest attendance in the entire MLB, second only to the Dodgers.
Instead of upping investment, ownership cried poor, allowed more teams to pass us by, ending up with in the bottom half of the league for payroll for 2023. All the while at the same time, as we now know, putting the front office on a more restrictive budget that required deep cuts into the development system. The end result? First losing season since 2007.
These are the people we are expecting to jack this payroll back into the top ten (currently approx $250 million - meaning an investment of an additional $150 million would get us there) when the moment is right? They won't do it. They'll claim years of bad attendance numbers (because fans don't pay to see a bad team in the middle of a rebuild) means they don't have the resources to do it.