2017 Coaching Carousel

Status
Not open for further replies.
#3,326      
Dave Wischnowsky ‏@wischlist 58m58 minutes ago
If Josh Whitman taps the NBA for the next #Illini basketball coach, one potential name to watch is Stephen Silas of the Charlotte Hornets.
I think this is all related to Internet speculation. Nothing more. Nothing less. Lots of names bandied about, but I don't think anyone knows anything ATM. I doubt Whitman is tipping his hand at this point.
 
#3,327      
Regarding NBA names, the only one (including Hoiberg) that has been mentioned that has really interested me is Monty Williams. Hoiberg is a decent candidate, but I can't shake the belief that he won't be able to recruit Chicago and a lot of the state after how terrible his NBA tenure was, at least until he's established winning here, and you need IL talent for that.
 
#3,329      
Calling Lovie Smith high-risk is being hyperbolic, especially when the initial comment pertained to Jerrance Howard as a HC canddiate. Not really a fair comparison. The biggest question/risk with Lovie was recruiting, and maybe if his defensive concepts would translate, but to call him high risk is certainly unfair.

Calling Jerrance high-risk is entirely accurate. Hiring assistants with no head coaching experience is high risk, and we have no history of doing that. I don't think we've ever made really, really big leaps of faith on our hires to the football/hoops posts, I have no issues with Obelix's statement, especially in this context.



Besides J Howard being high risk, does it bother anyone else that JH has been poaching Illini recruits ever since he left? I know it's his job, but it's like he would wait until we were onto a player, then swoop in and pull out the Kansas is WAY better than Illinois card.....


Something about that really frosts my cookies!!
 
#3,330      
Regarding NBA names, the only one (including Hoiberg) that has been mentioned that has really interested me is Monty Williams. Hoiberg is a decent candidate, but I can't shake the belief that he won't be able to recruit Chicago and a lot of the state after how terrible his NBA tenure was, at least until he's established winning here, and you need IL talent for that.

The mess of his NBA tenure won't hurt Hoiberg's ability to recruit in Chicago whatsoever. Having been the coach of the Bulls never hurts. What hurts is that Hoiberg doesn't like recruiting high school kids and if his Iowa State tenure is any indication he will pursue avenues around doing that.

The competition in the transfer market has heated up like crazy since Hoiberg started dipping into that. Illinois might not be able to get Jucos in like Hoiberg could at Iowa State. All reasons for concern. But he's an excellent coach, would that make up for it?

I suspect we won't get to find out. Hoiberg is a non-starter for us until the Bulls fire him, and I'll eat my hat if Jerry Reinsdorf pays a coach $15 million to go away. Especially before the end of the season.
 
#3,331      
Josh Whitman was.

John Whitman was certainly young, but definitely had AD experience. He was not on A+ list of names, but was not an assistant AD. JW had served as the AD at University of Wisconsin-La Crosse for 4 years and at Washington University for another 2 years. That's the equivalent of a mid-major hire with some HC experience.

Actually, the 2 previous AD's (before MT) where a lot riskier. John Mackovic had zero AD experience and really did not do much as an AD, other than drawing an additional salary to justify the expense, and even our own Ron Guenther had zero head AD experience other than serving as assistant to Neale Stoner.
 
#3,332      
What about Ben Jacobson from Northern Iowa? Not sure about his recruiting skills but he is a good coach for sure. I know they are down this year but two years before that he was a combined 54-17 and 27-9 in conference. He seems to always get the most out of his talent too unlike Groce. Any takers?
 
#3,333      
Besides J Howard being high risk, does it bother anyone else that JH has been poaching Illini recruits ever since he left? I know it's his job, but it's like he would wait until we were onto a player, then swoop in and pull out the Kansas is WAY better than Illinois card.....


Something about that really frosts my cookies!!

lol i cant stop chuckling like the town drunk. but honestly if the big boys don't want the players, neither do I.

I like Silas, Keatts, and Monty as candidates. I particularly like Williams' association with Team USA.
 
#3,334      
John Whitman was certainly young, but definitely had AD experience. He was not on A+ list of names, but was not an assistant AD. JW had served as the AD at University of Wisconsin-La Crosse for 4 years and at Washington University for another 2 years. That's the equivalent of a mid-major hire with some HC experience.

That's the equivalent of a DIII hire, an analogy made somewhat easier by the fact that those are DIII schools.

Josh Whitman was the Jerrance Howard of the AD search process. He was also the person who stood out as the right guy after being carefully vetted.

I am all for Jerrance being involved in our search process, at the very least because it would help and alum advance his own career just by interviewing and getting feedback and being a part of it. If he's the Josh Whitman of basketball coaches, great. Based on what I've heard and read, my suspicion is that that isn't the case. I put my trust in Whitman on that question.
 
#3,335      
What about Ben Jacobson from Northern Iowa? Not sure about his recruiting skills but he is a good coach for sure. I know they are down this year but two years before that he was a combined 54-17 and 27-9 in conference. He seems to always get the most out of his talent too unlike Groce. Any takers?

I think he'd be a great choice. Lo and behold after I left them for dead UNI is peeling themselves up off the mat.
 
#3,336      
If we're going to start pitching current assistants that could transition to being a HC at a P5 program, I'd wouldn't mind having someone call Dane Fife over at MSU.

Not the direction I want to see the Illini go -- nor the direction I think they will go -- but pretty high on my list if they went that route would be Dennis Gates at FSU. Great recruiter, works with FSU's guards, was a skill development coach in the NBA, and was an associate head coach at NIU. Oh, yeah, he also graduated from Whitney Young.
 
#3,337      
Not the direction I want to see the Illini go -- nor the direction I think they will go -- but pretty high on my list if they went that route would be Dennis Gates at FSU. Great recruiter, works with FSU's guards, was a skill development coach in the NBA, and was an associate head coach at NIU. Oh, yeah, he also graduated from Whitney Young.

Love Dennis Gates. I was hoping we could land him as an associate head coach under the new staff. He's a really intelligent guy as he finished his degree at Cal in 3 years.
 
#3,339      
Besides J Howard being high risk, does it bother anyone else that JH has been poaching Illini recruits ever since he left? I know it's his job, but it's like he would wait until we were onto a player, then swoop in and pull out the Kansas is WAY better than Illinois card.....

Jerrance works for KU and so does Self. They are expected to do the best for the school they work for. That is exactly what we expect our coaches to do, including Groce and any future coaches.

Kansas recruits top players from Illinois. Guess what? That's what every other major program does, especially big name programs. Kansas does not recruit many sleepers, so unless a player is highly ranked, or projected to be highly ranked, or starts getting into POY or Mr. Basketball discussions, they will not receive much interest. They need not recruit sleepers early in the process.

Some posters make it sound that we are doing poorly, yet we have that super recruiting radar that Kansas and other schools depend on, our HC and assistants are killing it on the recruiting trail, and all other head coaches, including Bill Self and Jerrance are following our every move to steal recruits from almighty Illinois.
 
#3,340      
Trying to figure out if I would want this person as a coach....

With the Warriors, he concentrated on the development of perimeter players as well as game preparation and managing the team's offensive and defensive playbook. One of these perimeter players included two time MVP Stephen Curry.
 
#3,341      

mattcoldagelli

The Transfer Portal with Do Not Contact Tag
If all you can get is a project HC....might as well continue this project with one more recruiting class. Shake up the Asst. tree and see if that helps x's and o's?

Home run hire or bust. Then Groce will know without any whispering that it's win or else next year. Then swing for the HC fences again? I don't know, i'm at a loss.

source.gif
 
#3,342      
Trying to figure out if I would want this person as a coach....

With the Warriors, he concentrated on the development of perimeter players as well as game preparation and managing the team's offensive and defensive playbook. One of these perimeter players included two time MVP Stephen Curry.

I'd hire Dell Curry first. He has had more to do developing Steph Curry and his skills than any other coach. :D
 
#3,343      
I think he'd be a great choice. Lo and behold after I left them for dead UNI is peeling themselves up off the mat.

I hadn't checked lately, was going to do an update for the spreadsheet next week for 2016-17 (update record/conf record/recruiting), he really has gotten that ship righted, wow. If they can knock off ISU on Wednesday, that'd be a heck of a turnaround.
 
#3,346      
Besides J Howard being high risk, does it bother anyone else that JH has been poaching Illini recruits ever since he left? I know it's his job, but it's like he would wait until we were onto a player, then swoop in and pull out the Kansas is WAY better than Illinois card.....


Something about that really frosts my cookies!!

It's annoying but he has to recruit to his strengths and that is the Illinois area. If he's out negatively recruiting and bad mouthing Illinois, then that is a different topic. I don't know that is happening but I wonder since he is a Self guy and a Weber guy and things didn't end with either of them on great notes relationship-wise. In addition, Howard wanted to stay on at Illinois and was never really considered for the head coaching job despite being named interim when Weber got fired. Then Groce came in and didn't retain him. I'm not saying it's happening but there would be more than one reason he has an axe to grind.
 
#3,347      

The Pontiff

Chicago, IL
If we hire a decent coach, not a Bill Self, not a superstar, but basically a median-level coach in our expected range of outcomes, and Frazier and Tilmon decide to go elsewhere, we will very possibly be better next year than this year and will very likely be in the tournament in Year 2.

There would be no recruiting class, none, in any coaching transition in which we should anticipate a raft of 3-stars that no other Big Ten schools wanted. We will be filling our scholarships with quality players who fill holes in the roster fit what the new coach wants immediately.

This board needs to calibrate itself to that reality.

There are situations where making a change at head coach means you have to go backwards to go forwards. This is not one of those situations. We're in the market for someone to make our existing roster play closer to its potential, which is not a high bar at the moment.
Funny, I was starting to pull the data that showed this very thing. Quite often, the new guy pulls in some very highly-rated prospects right away, often because of spots vacated (think Orris at Illinois.) Howland, Wojo, Smart, Pearl, CMartin and Alford are some coaches that come to mind who had excellent hauls within 1-2 years of being on the job. A new coaching staff is like that new car smell - all fresh and full of promise.
 
#3,350      
It's annoying but he has to recruit to his strengths and that is the Illinois area. If he's out negatively recruiting and bad mouthing Illinois, then that is a different topic. I don't know that is happening but I wonder since he is a Self guy and a Weber guy and things didn't end with either of them on great notes relationship-wise. In addition, Howard wanted to stay on at Illinois and was never really considered for the head coaching job despite being named interim when Weber got fired. Then Groce came in and didn't retain him. I'm not saying it's happening but there would be more than one reason he has an axe to grind.

I know Jerrance and he is very active on the recruiting trail, but you can ask any coach and he will tell you how positively he still talks about UI. He was the heart and soul of the teams he played for, despite not getting playing time. He is still very close with ex-teammates and players he coached and really likes to interact with Illini fans at AAU events.

Jerrance was not a "Self guy" or "Weber guy." He has coached under both and is appreciative of their help in their career, but he has always been an "Illinois guy." We have had better players, but I have honestly never met anyone who loved UI more than Jerrance. The entire UI experience.

As far as recruits, it is laughable. Some posters try to make it sound that KU regularly steals our valued "sleepers" but the truth is that KU just recruits the top Illinois players like most other schools do. In five years, KU has stole a total of ONE (1) recruit from UI, Cliff Alexander, who miraculously happened to be a top-5 recruit nationwide. KU has always recruited top-players in the state of Illinois, even before Jerrance, and will continue long after Jerrance is gone.

Maybe we should be more mad at Cuonzo for stealing Moore.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.