I liked the way that Robert Rosenthal laid it out on TV: "Illinois went with the NFL coach (2x), the recruiter, and the program builder* (asterisk for any coach hired by Mike Thomas)...nothing worked". So if we go down that theme, what other "category" is left. 1) Young Talented Coach 2) the redemption coach 3) the top school coach, but on their way out coach 4) Successful Power 5 coach already...any others?
Not that I think Josh thinks this way necessarily, but I think he would put his job in jeopardy if he chooses either the young talented coach or redemption coach. I don't think it necessarily means doom for him, but if it ends in scandal it could be a stain. However, I like the guy and think he does right by those he hires and the university, so I don't think he necessarily gets the Axe. I think the redemption coach is one that will give us the greatest chance to get and achieve success. No already Successful Power 5 coach gives us a serious look. I don't want someone who may be at risk because they aren't performing at their school...even if it is a top program and their expectations are crazy...my expectations are crazy too, so what makes me want that? The Young Coach is a tough one. On one hand, you have someone that is exciting, brings energy, could be a big hit...on the other, if it pans out, they will always be a flight risk, the chances of panning out are lower, and you need to develop a program/consistency...tough call.
I just hope whoever it is, we'll be excited about it just as we were with BU and Lovie TBH.