Week 1 Games

#330      
and as a reminder,

The Standard: "Clear and Obvious Video Evidence"

Under NCAA Rule 12-6-1-c, the overarching standard requires clear and obvious video evidence (historically and practically referred to as indisputable video evidence) to reverse a ruling.

Presumption of Correctness: The review process starts with the assumption that the call on the field was right.

Beyond All Doubt: The video provided to the replay official must convince them beyond a reasonable doubt that the call was incorrect.

Inconclusive Evidence = Call Stands: If the camera angles are obstructed, blurred, or missing a definitive frame—even if the replay official has a strong hunch the call was wrong—the on-field ruling must stand.
 
#335      
When the football crosses the back of the end zone and is ruled incomplete was there one second left? or is it even though the ball crosses the end line does it have to be touches to end the play. Whe a qb throws the ball out of bounce to stop the clock when is the exact moment the clock?
 
#340      
 
#343      
The B1G has released a statement:


If I understand correctly, they’re saying the refs used direct camera on the stadium clock to make their decision, not the tv clock. But it’s confusing because below that it says all clocks are synced before the game. What am I missing?
You're missing that the B1G has a vested interest in Michigan winning and the game is referreed by B1G refs. This was a monumental screw up that does more damage to the game than Lane Kiffin being some weird little villain, imo.

Some will argue "oh there's some special clock that tells the actual time." Ok... why don't any of us get to actually see it?
 
#344      
You're missing that the B1G has a vested interest in Michigan winning and the game is referreed by B1G refs. This was a monumental screw up that does more damage to the game than Lane Kiffin being some weird little villain, imo.

Some will argue "oh there's some special clock that tells the actual time." Ok... why don't any of us get to actually see it?
Of course, if the call is incorrect, I want the call to be overturned. I’m just trying to understand what the B1G is claiming. It sounds like they’re saying the stadium clock and the game clock show two different things. They're off by a fraction of a second. So on TV, the game was over, but in the stadium, there was still one second left. I wonder how common that is? And why isn’t the game clock on tv synced to the stadium clock?
 
#345      
Probably the worst look for the big ten conference in my life time. 1. Phantom second added. 2. Michigan fans storming the field after their team cheated against a MAC school at home. 3. Big ten football twitter ignoring the B.S. call and acting like Michigan pulled off a miracle, giving them unwarranted flowers at a cringy level. Just an embarrassing look for our conference.
 
Back