There are so many things to dissect here it’s hard to know where to start. For now, the number 1 issue for me is:
Recruiting and talent evaluations - this is the primary area of concern for me. We saw Cignetti bring in a bunch of lower level players up and they were studs. No big budget, no p4 pitch and that dude got nfl players to 2 lower school than IL (Indiana one of the few that would qualify for such a statement prior to his arrival). He identified them and locked them down, then coached them up.
The level of talent and speed is so poor on IL’a roster right now, they likely wouldn’t compete even a level down at the moment. The team speed is horrific, the skill positions are awful. When Dixon is your best player in O, that’s bad. It’s not that he’s bad, he’s a 3rd wr option on a CFP team, but not a true 1.
And when you have Krutz as a regular player on D, that’s bad. He’s like water boy level on an CFP team. And he’s cornerstone of this defense.
Bottom line, BB has utterly failed at talent eval outside of the QB position. He’s wiffed on every DC not named Ryan Walters and he think his O line is back in the Wisconsin glory days when they aren’t even half that.
This team is light years behind in talent and recruiting and it’s not all NIL related.
Find a team that is playoff bound and try to enjoy the ride for the season. Cause the dream of IL one day being a regular CPF participant just may never happen TBH.