But is it that much different that Weber taking Self recruits to the championship game? and then 7 more years of declining basketball because of recruiting.
I believe the question/statement is that Groce with someone else's recruits (Underwood's) might be able to get more out of this team. Not that Groce can build/recruit a better team, Illinois tried that with no success.
I will always say that Weber did not really recruit as poorly as people thought. He just had a hard time getting guys to buy in. He had soft teams and guys who wouldn't listen. He had behavioral problems and a general lack of respect. Eye rolling on the bench but he didn't recruit bad. He missed out on the big fish and had a load of guys that didn't work out the way they were supposed to. Whether that was due to coaching or not, I don't know.
DJ Richardson, Brandon Paul, Tyler Griffey and Joseph Bertrand were all in the same class and that was a Top 10 recruiting class.
In another class, he got Myke Henry, Mike Shaw, Egwu and Tracy Abrams. Another highly ranked class. Henry and Shaw didn't work out but all those guys were Top 100 recruits.
Another class of Myers Leonard, Crandall Head and Jereme Richmond. 2 of those guys didn't work out but were rated highly.
Demetri McCamey, Mike Tisdale and Mike Davis all came in the same class. That wasn't a highly rated class- McCamey was the only Top 100 guy but they were all contributors for sure.
The knock was really that he never got the most highly rated guy or the major recruits in Illinois other than Richmond. They went to Kansas, Duke, Indiana, Ohio State instead.
There were some stinker classes along the way too I admit. Weber seemed to get worse at recruitng
By the end, yes, recruiting was awful. That class of Jalen James and Michael Orris was not going to cut it. But on the whole, Weber got some guys. They just didn't win much.