Coaching Carousel (Basketball)

Status
Not open for further replies.
#226      
LMAO I wasn't trying to knock Underwood, they just get riled up quickly. I was just simply showing(in response to somebody saying he cant coach) that Tang has had a similar amount of ranked wins, gotten to the elite 8, and won a coach of the year. I think we can all agree that the writing was on the wall there. But let's not completely dog the guy. But of course, people want to take it personally.
I would take Underwood over Tang, I just get tired of people acting like any coach besides Brad isn't that good. Think I saw early season someone mentioned Todd Golden who just won a national title is nothing special
 
#227      
😆🤣😂🤪
Tang this will be 3rd year in row KSU has missed NCAA. they are 1-11 in conference this year.
He took zero responsibility - threw his team under bus and said they would not be back next year.
Some people pressure makes diamonds. Others it just makes coal dust.
I don’t think he’s a terrible coach overall, but that press conference said much more about him and handling pressure than it did about his players.
 
#228      
That is his record the last 3 years: 45-47

How long will you continue to give him credit for the season where he had the benefit of his predecessor's players? Much longer than their AD, I suppose, and this is the "Bruce Weber defense" that another person mentioned.

If you don't have a problem with him being fired then you're agreeing his performance was poor.
KSU was 34-58 the 3 years before Tang. He didnt exactly benefit from a smoking hot program like Weber did when Self left. But you're right, they werent HIS players and maybe thats where his issue is. Not actually coaching the game, but roster construction. Its his first head coaching gig and we've seen good coaches just for whatever reason struggle at certain places and bounce back.

My biggest issue was him saying " most of these players aren't coming back next year". To me thats a bull!!!! thing to say when the season isn't over yet. Dont quit on your guys.
 
#230      
News Flash. That's his job.
Yea no duh. Its his first head coaching job in a rapidly changing environment. Even Jay Wright, Tony Bennett, and coaches from other sports didnt wanna deal with it. Nobody is disputing whether they can coach.
 
#231      
For one, what defines elite?

But second, that's not what being a good coach is. A volatile and inconsistent team occasionally will beat elite teams, and then lose to really bad teams. Is that what any program wants out of their coach? A good coach is consistent, and a good team wins the lion's share of the games it should win. Would we be happy with Bielema if our football team had beaten Indiana and OSU, then lost every single other game and gone 2-10?

What you're describing as a deep dive into the numbers is actually the opposite. You're taking the highs of his tenure, and ignoring the lows (which are often only separated by a week or two).
Here's the thing. If other people want to only focus on the negative as reasons he cant coach, I'll throw in some positives why he can. Its only fair to the guy.
 
#232      
Man… KSU’s AD is an idiot!

Athletics director Gene Taylor confirmed to The Mercury Monday that when he met with Tang Sunday morning, he offered Tang a choice: coach the rest of the season and then resign, or else be terminated immediately for cause. If Tang chose the former, there would be some kind of financial package offered to him in lieu of a buyout, at an undetermined amount that would be substantially less than the full buyout.

“We never gave him a specific number,” Taylor said.


Now… IANAL, but it seems to me that even Lionel Hutz could make the case that, if you’re firing someone for cause, you don’t allow them to stay on til the end of the year. And if you DO go that route, you don’t publicly admit that’s what you’re doing.

I really am glad we gave Josh at the helm.
 
#233      
There's nothing irrational about laying out the whole picture with Tang. He was an associate head coach for a national champion and won BIG 12 coach of the year and got his team to the elite 8. This year was a disaster for him, but id say its more rational than not to push back on the people insinuating he isn't a good coach.
Wayne Tinkle got his team to an Elite Eight. As an Oregon State fan, I appreciate the job he did that season, but one year doesn’t make you a great or even a particularly good coach. Last time K-State won only one conference game was 1943-44 when it was the Big 6. It’s the whole resume that matters.
 
#235      
What has Underwood done to show he is going to lead us to the national title let alone the final 4. All I see is regular season success and then a whole lot disappointment come tourney time.

Getting absolutely outcoached by Porter Moser where we never lead as a #1 seed in 2nd rd

Being a missed block away from losing to Chattanooga , then getting handled by Houston

Not showing up vs Arkansas

Finally getting to the elite 8 then giving up a 30-0 run

Losing to Kentucky where we led for 26 seconds?
Do you think Matt Painter is a good coach?
 
#236      
Wayne Tinkle got his team to an Elite Eight. As an Oregon State fan, I appreciate the job he did that season, but one year doesn’t make you a great or even a particularly good coach. Last time K-State won only one conference game was 1943-44 when it was the Big 6. It’s the whole resume that matters.
I agree... the WHOLE resume. Correct. The good and the bad. Wayne Tinkle is also 30 games under .500 in a far inferior league though. Not to crap on him too much, I dont know how much help get gets at Oregon St.
 
#239      
1771273301022.png
 
#241      
What has Underwood done to show he is going to lead us to the national title let alone the final 4. All I see is regular season success and then a whole lot disappointment come tourney time.

Getting absolutely outcoached by Porter Moser where we never lead as a #1 seed in 2nd rd

Being a missed block away from losing to Chattanooga , then getting handled by Houston

Not showing up vs Arkansas

Finally getting to the elite 8 then giving up a 30-0 run

Losing to Kentucky where we led for 26 seconds?
Brace Yourself Here We Go GIF by MOODMAN
 
#242      
The point i made was in response to someone insinuating he cant coach. Brad Underwood is the easiest to compare him to because he is who we are most familiar with. So to me, if we can acknowledge Brad is one of the better program builders in the country, I think looking at the numbers a little deeper shows that Tang can coach with the best of them as hes beaten elite teams every year. Now, BUILDING and MAINTAINING a program is what hes failed to do. Thats the huge separator between him and the elite coaches. Brad has built a culture here and youre either in or youre out. This being Tang's first job, I hope he gets a second chance and fixes his mistake there. Or maybe he just doesnt have it. He seems like a good man.
Tang was terrible this year
 
#243      
Wayne Tinkle got his team to an Elite Eight. As an Oregon State fan, I appreciate the job he did that season, but one year doesn’t make you a great or even a particularly good coach. Last time K-State won only one conference game was 1943-44 when it was the Big 6. It’s the whole resume that matters.
Bill Hodges is the ultimate example of this. He took Indiana State to the National Championship game in his first season as a head coach. How could you ever get a hotter start than that?

Next three seasons he had a Tang-like trajectory, going 2-14 in conference his last season. Resigned/fired, despite still having an overall winning record. A lot like Tang.

Couldn't get a D-I head coaching job, and after some time as an assistant at Long Beach State, he ended up at NAIA Georgia State, and did well enough to get another D-1 chance with Mercer. Classic redemption arc right?

In 6 seasons with Mercer he went 62-107, did not make a single tournament, and never won more than 15 games.

The plus side, he retired with a winning Tournament record (3-1, all from that first season) so I guess he's better than BU?
 
#245      
Bill Hodges is the ultimate example of this. He took Indiana State to the National Championship game in his first season as a head coach. How could you ever get a hotter start than that?

Next three seasons he had a Tang-like trajectory, going 2-14 in conference his last season. Resigned/fired, despite still having an overall winning record. A lot like Tang.

Couldn't get a D-I head coaching job, and after some time as an assistant at Long Beach State, he ended up at NAIA Georgia State, and did well enough to get another D-1 chance with Mercer. Classic redemption arc right?

In 6 seasons with Mercer he went 62-107, did not make a single tournament, and never won more than 15 games.

The plus side, he retired with a winning Tournament record (3-1, all from that first season) so I guess he's better than BU?
I mean he did have Larry Bird....
 
Last edited:
#246      
I wonder how Coleman Hawkins would compare Jerome Tang to Brad Underwood? That would be an interesting take since he had experiences with both. I think Tang struck lightning in a bottle in his first season and once he recruited his own group, he just couldn't sustain any of that momentum from the first season. It seems like he is a players' coach from the outside looking in but it's possible he just didn't have the intangibles to coach at this high of a level. Maybe, he would've been better served starting out at a lower level like the AAC or MWC or A-10. Maybe just too big of a jump too soon.

I thought his comments were a bit excessive, clearly showing his frustrations with how the season was going but he recruited them and the responsibility lies solely with him. If he didn't vet their competitive toughness and ability to overcome resiliency, then that is all on him. He also didn't recruit a lot of winning players so that says something as well. I think Haggerty and maybe Nate Johnson(Akron) were the only guys he brought in that came from programs with winning going on. So, I think it speaks to his inability to recruit the right type of guys. He brought in headcases like Dug McDaniel and Naequan Tomlin in past seasons so that speaks volumes that he might not be the best judge of character and maybe was going for potential over character in some cases

How many times has Coleman been back to K State ?

There’s your answer …

You’re right on Tang lightning in a bottle … Nowell playing out of his mind and Tang dancing was the only thing he ever did …

Tang was the bag man at Baylor when they had it rolling and isn’t a good enough coach to do the whole new roster every year …
 
Last edited:
#247      
Tyler has been a great offensive coach. However that is only one aspect of the job. The head coach is a CEO and must maintain alumni relations in order to maintain funding and then budget that to build a team. He has to hire a staff that can work together with his leadership. I believe it is easier to hire the x and o technicians than it is to manage the other things. Tyler may have those abilities but they certainly are not on his resume at this point.
 
#248      
How many times has Coleman been back to K State ?

There’s your answer …

You’re right on Tang lightning in a bottle … Nowell playing out of his mind and Tang dancing was the only thing he ever did …

Tang was the bag man at Baylor when they had it rolling and isn’t a good enough coach to do the whole new roster every year …
Thanks! This answers what I was assuming.
 
#249      
There's nothing irrational about laying out the whole picture with Tang. He was an associate head coach for a national champion and won BIG 12 coach of the year and got his team to the elite 8. This year was a disaster for him, but id say its more rational than not to push back on the people insinuating he isn't a good coach.
Quin Snyder made an Elite 8. I don’t quite think that’s the flex you think it is.
 
#250      
Man… KSU’s AD is an idiot!

Athletics director Gene Taylor confirmed to The Mercury Monday that when he met with Tang Sunday morning, he offered Tang a choice: coach the rest of the season and then resign, or else be terminated immediately for cause. If Tang chose the former, there would be some kind of financial package offered to him in lieu of a buyout, at an undetermined amount that would be substantially less than the full buyout.

“We never gave him a specific number,” Taylor said.


Now… IANAL, but it seems to me that even Lionel Hutz could make the case that, if you’re firing someone for cause, you don’t allow them to stay on til the end of the year. And if you DO go that route, you don’t publicly admit that’s what you’re doing.

I really am glad we gave Josh at the helm.

100%
IANAL but I agree this looks so skeevy as to invite action beyond the regular damages from terminating the contract. Rich people's problems so not really interested from that standpoint. Still, the AD thinking they can create leverage through those tactics seems like it invites a counter-suit.

This just cements in my mind how messy the contracts are in college sports. Schools want to offer contracts with fat guarantees to attract coaches, but then don't want to pay them the guaranteed part when the change their minds.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back