Coaching Carousel (Football)

Status
Not open for further replies.
#2      
Beamer might be safe at SC - they fired his OC Mike Shula


Youre Out The Big Bang Theory GIF by CBS
 
#5      
I think Franklin and Kelly will land somewhere if they want to
 
#9      
Wisconsin still has an announcement forthcoming by month's end, don't they?
 
#10      
I retrospect it appears Auburn should have kept Gus Malzahn. Harsin/Freeze was a wasted 5 years
if the Arky St job opens up, Gus might be going up against Hugh for that spot . two former HC’s looking to call the shots in Jonesboro again.

if I was either guys atty, I’d advise against buying a house there , at least for a couple years
 
#17      
Let's say LSU, Florida, Auburn come up with the 25 million needed to buyout Bret AND he takes an 11 million dollar a year pay day and heads south....

Who do we think is Josh Whitman's first call?

Is it someone who previously coached here as an assistant (Golesh). Someone you missed out on previously (Campbell or Leupold).

I do not want this to happen, but knowing JW won't be left empty handed....I do find it intriguing.
 
#18      
Excellent coach, but Penn State would be crazy after the Joe Pa / Sandusky scandal.


Actually any B1G coaching opening.
 
#20      
If I am PERSONALLY a coach and had my pick of this list (not ranking smaller programs I know nothing about)...

Florida ... It literally shocks me how people act like UF is a clear cut below LSU in a lot of conversations I've seen. They're the favored team in a massive state that has more high school talent than you could ever even offer, the fan support is great, the money is there and the tradition is there. It's one of those jobs like Illinois Basketball (in my biased opinion!) where the quality of the JOB is even higher than the quality of that program's tradition.
LSU ... I might have put them #1 before learning about the weird politics (heh heh) with the governor's office and that there is no AD, lol. However, all of the "built-in" pieces are obviously there, from fan support, tradition, facilities, recruiting footprint, etc.
Penn State ... The top three are all good, but I think PSU fans will fire anyone they have to until they luck into becoming on par with OSU and Michigan ... I am not getting in line!
Virginia Tech ... If they could offer top notch NIL in spite of being outside of the Power Two, I might even move them up further. Some folks are surprised to find out they're the preferred team in much of the DC Area (at least VA side) and the vast majority of that large state, and the expectations wouldn't be delusional.
Arkansas ... Fans seem to expect to break into that upper tier of the SEC, and there is just zero evidence historically that they should feel that way. NIL is a plus, but I personally think this job is a sort of "trap," lol.
Auburn ... Good spot, but my impression is that the expectations don't match reality.
Oklahoma State ... Assuming they still have some NIL money to spend with the right regime in place. Fan support and loyalty is a huge plus.
UCLA ... Somehow underrated with how much everyone hates on it, but the athletic department in general seems like a mess.
Stanford ... Academic restrictions plus outside of the Power Two.
Oregon State ... Sucks to say, but they're getting left behind. :(
 
#21      
If I am PERSONALLY a coach and had my pick of this list (not ranking smaller programs I know nothing about)...

Florida ... It literally shocks me how people act like UF is a clear cut below LSU in a lot of conversations I've seen. They're the favored team in a massive state that has more high school talent than you could ever even offer, the fan support is great, the money is there and the tradition is there. It's one of those jobs like Illinois Basketball (in my biased opinion!) where the quality of the JOB is even higher than the quality of that program's tradition.
LSU ... I might have put them #1 before learning about the weird politics (heh heh) with the governor's office and that there is no AD, lol. However, all of the "built-in" pieces are

Interesting comparison, but I disagree.

Is Florida the favored team in their state? I might agree with you but it's not definitive, to the point where I would not call it a strength.
Is LSU the favored team in their state? Unequivocally.

The talent comparison is interesting. Let's compare their success to attract that top in-state talent:

UF Commits in Top 200 In-State Talent
2025: 5 (out of 22)
2024: 2 (out of 23)
2023: 5 (out of 43!)
2022: 1 (out of 22)
2021: 3 (out of 24)
Total: 16 out of 134 (11.9%)

LSU Commits in Top 200 In-State Talent
2025: 5 (out of 9)
2024: 6 (out of 6)
2023: 2 (out of 6)
2022: 5 (out of 12)
2021: 6 (out of 8)
Total: 24 out of 41 (58.5%)

Not surprised that State of Florida produces a lot more talent! But LSU dominates their state to the point where they get a lot more top-200 in-state talent than Florida.
 
#22      
Interesting comparison, but I disagree.

Is Florida the favored team in their state? I might agree with you but it's not definitive, to the point where I would not call it a strength.
Is LSU the favored team in their state? Unequivocally.

The talent comparison is interesting. Let's compare their success to attract that top in-state talent:

UF Commits in Top 200 In-State Talent
2025: 5 (out of 22)
2024: 2 (out of 23)
2023: 5 (out of 43!)
2022: 1 (out of 22)
2021: 3 (out of 24)
Total: 16 out of 134 (11.9%)

LSU Commits in Top 200 In-State Talent
2025: 5 (out of 9)
2024: 6 (out of 6)
2023: 2 (out of 6)
2022: 5 (out of 12)
2021: 6 (out of 8)
Total: 24 out of 41 (58.5%)

Not surprised that State of Florida produces a lot more talent! But LSU dominates their state to the point where they get a lot more top-200 in-state talent than Florida.
And LSU doesn't have to compete with intrastate schools like Florida State and Miami, not to mention USF
 
#23      
Fitz is unproven in portal-nil era. He would be interesting hire for non power.

Vtech
OK state
Wisc
Ark
Ucla
Stanford

If you are ok with past hazing he won at NW. Not many can say that.
 
#24      
Fitz is unproven in portal-nil era. He would be interesting hire for non power.

Vtech
OK state
Wisc
Ark
Ucla
Stanford

If you are ok with past hazing he won at NW. Not many can say that.
I would argue the point that he "won" at Northworstern . . He is almost by definition 'average' as a coach if all one looks at only the W/L's. His 17 years there he had 7 winning season, including three 10 win seasons. His career winning percentage is .521, with an overall record of 110-101, and his bowl game record is .500 (5-5). What I believe he should get significant credit for is doing what he did at Northworstern, who boasts a 566-706-40 all time record. He's an all time great at NW . . .
 
#25      
Beamer to Va Tech has had a lot of buzz lately …

South Carolina certainly won’t be going all out to retain him either …
I’m convinced we broke them.

FWIW I was chatting yesterday with a colleague at work I haven't seen since Sept. He's a S. Carolina alum. His dad lives near Columbia and has had season tickets for many decades. His take is that SC's woes this season center on its OL, which has been a consistent hot mess. He noted that Sellers is extremely mobile at QB but can't be forced to be so on every single play. I haven't watched them at all except for the opener v. VT in Atlanta, in which they sputtered but won.

My colleague believes that Beamer's woes this season aren't his fault. He also said that his dad (~ 80 years old) is ready to give up his season ticket because of the annual player turnover via the portal and NIL. He's tired of the Forrest Gump box of chocolates (salted, in this case, with the occasional turd) that USC ball has become.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back