Illinois #10 in AP Poll

#51      
I think the Illini and puke swap places .....us at # 5 and puke at # 10 ...........

You're probably right, and we know that the AP is slow, but I can hope you're underestimating the exposure of this win. The Houston and Arizona upsets don't have the decibels of a blasting at Cameron Indoor. Teams that will likely deserve to be above Illinois come Monday:

Kansas (soon)
Houston
Texas Tech

With that said..
Florida and Uconn don't actually deserve it, but they'll probably be given free seats in the five.
Virginia might stick.
TT will be worthy but doesn't have the analytics (and isn't playing enough ball) to win votes
I could see Arizona consistently getting high ballots and nip our heels.
Tennessee, even MSU? Don't think so, thanks to Illinois leaving no doubt.
Texas? Nah. Vandy? No.

MSU better not be in any discussion, and Duke will be below them.. right?
UCLA? They'll be 6-0! ... Hell no.
St. John's? Lol, okay, I can stop.
 
#52      
Who do they put at #1? Not saying it should be us, but VA as next team to move up without a loss this week? Certainly not the best team in the nation. TX, UCLA, Houston? All might have a case but would mean a big jump up. I don't think FL, MSU, or UConn get penalized too much but you surely can't reward a team that lost with a #1 ranking. I don't know who will land at #1 but think IL will be rewarded with a top 5 ranking for the most impressive win of the week. Think IL, FL, MSU, UConn, and maybe Houston are the top 5 teams but don't think the rankings will reflect that.
 
#53      
So funny reading this stuff after we have won a huge game. AP ranking is just junk now, metrics are what matters. There we are top 5 no matter which one you look at. Also, Sam Houston is a really good team they will end up winning their conference it’s not like they just suck. BU schedules the way we always wanted. You get some “buy” games and 5 tough non conference games, just so happens all of those are either on the road (which I am good with) or neutral. We will get Dork at home next year. UConn at the UC is great for Chicago fans, and I (selfishly living in Florida) love this playing games in Nashville also.
 
#56      
UCLA beat Fullerton by four in a game that came down to the final 10 seconds. Do the voters drop them a few spots or does winning - no matter over who - trump all?
UCLA won't be punished too much for a close win, but considering they were only around 100 pts ahead of Illini in AP poll, I have to think Illini jump them.

More interested in what happens to Texas Tech. They were only 17 pts ahead of Illini and played a cupcake yesterday (only game of week). I suspect Illini will jump them, even with the head to head loss.

Duke is the darling child to many in the press, so the complete destruction of them at Cameron has really gone wild in the media. That likely moves the Illini up substantially.
 
#58      
^^This rankingby 21Champaign St.^^ might be about right but think FL stays in top 5. Probably over TX. Realize this is all pretty worthless at this stage of the season but an interesting exercise given all the losses this week.
 
#60      
Since halftime against TTU, we are +35 in three halves against top 10 competition.

The outlier seems to be the first half of TTU where we kept trying to run offense that didn't work, which led to turnovers and easy points for them.

We should return to the top 5, if all is fair. I think TTU, while good, is going to fall back as the season goes on.

Florida, Houston, Uconn, Virginia, TTU should all be ahead of us, for now. Probably Texas sits ahead of us too.
 
#61      

Virginia might creep into AP#1, due to losses by the 3 at the top, and while they beat #12 (at the time) Arkansas,
Arkansas just lost again at home to Indiana and will likely drop out of the top 25 next week
So imho Virginia just hasn't played anybody worthy enough to earn them #1; just sayin'

FWIW, current BPI's:
1 - (guess who, c'mon guess!! - hint: see link above)
22 Virginia
36 Indiana
37 Arkansas
 
#62      

Virginia might creep into AP#1, due to losses by the 3 at the top, and while they beat #12 (at the time) Arkansas,
Arkansas just lost again at home to Indiana and will likely drop out of the top 25 next week
So imho Virginia just hasn't played anybody worthy enough to earn them #1; just sayin'

FWIW, current BPI's:
1 - (guess who, c'mon guess!! - hint: see link above)
22 Virginia
36 Indiana
37 Arkansas
Yeah Virginia and a few in the top 10 won’t really play any one of value for a while. I think many will creep up due to just not be “punished” for not losing. And I know voters don’t have teams leap frog forward nearly as quickly as they have them leap frog backwards, but I think trouncing Duke at Cameron (something no one has done in years) is about as much a statement as anything, and hope we get back into the top 5.
 
#63      
As of right now, Virginia looks like a power conference version of last year's Miami OH- they're undefeated, are #3/4 in resume ranks like SOR/WAB, but their efficiency ranks put them around #10-15 depending on how much you include pre-season expectations. So do betting odds.

I recommend ignoring media rankings at least until (if not forever) the early undefeated teams get tested

Edit: here are current betting odds at Fanduel and Caesars (I'm not sure if the other books' odds were updated where I got them):
1795107484058.png
 
Last edited:
#65      
As of right now, Virginia looks like a power conference version of last year's Miami OH- they're undefeated, are #3/4 in resume ranks like SOR/WAB, but their efficiency ranks put them around #10-15 depending on how much you include pre-season expectations. So do betting odds.

I recommend ignoring media rankings at least until (if not forever) the early undefeated teams get tested

Edit: here are current betting odds at Fanduel and Caesars (I'm not sure if the other books' odds were updated where I got them):
View attachment 52819
If these were stocks, Duke would be a great short sale!
 
#67      
Ark - loosiers game was @ Madison Square Garden , not @ Ark ...........
 
#69      
Which makes me happy to see that there are so many high quality basketball games in the month of November. All of those games were ranked on ranked matchups.

There have really been many intriguing basketball games in this month.
That’s the nice thing about the quad system. No downside in playing high end comp if you’re a good team.
 
#70      
Which makes me happy to see that there are so many high quality basketball games in the month of November. All of those games were ranked on ranked matchups.

There have really been many intriguing basketball games in this month.
Totally. If I had a quibble I wish more of those games were played on campus, but the scheduling is way better and more entertaining than it was in the 00's.

Credit is due to the NCAA, hard as that is for us to admit. The revised tournament selection methodology with the quads and whatnot has had a three-pronged positive effect:

- Better teams make the tournament
- The selection process is clearer and less random
- Scheduling big time games is rewarded because winning helps you much more than losing hurts you

Now, mid majors take a different view of some of this stuff because they can't get big games easily, and I am sympathetic to that, but all in all it's very positive. The RPI was flim-flam, good riddance.
 
#71      
That’s the nice thing about the quad system. No downside in playing high end comp if you’re a good team.
I'd go a step further and say it's the efficiency rankings. The quads still favor teams who play against #15-40 (based on location) rather than #1-5.

The efficiency rankings take away any incentive to prefer good/bad opponents (unless you think you're uniquely better against good/bad teams), and all else equal, top teams want to get experience playing top opponents.

I think WAB technically favors playing against teams halfway between yourself and a bubble team, but more than that favors teams who get "lucky" in W/L compared to their efficiency ranks.
 
Back