Illinois Hoops Recruiting Thread (August 2018)

Status
Not open for further replies.
#726      
His offer list is solid. I weight that more than stars, personally.
Can't argue with that but that doesn't mean that he's a top recruit. I don't know too much about the kid but his stats weren't that impressive. Seems like another project. He's definitely got enough size to be a high caliber big though. I doubt he's a plan A guy but maybe the staff is learning from past mistakes.
 
#727      
It does sting losing Shannon, but as bad as they've been, DePaul does have a decent sell at this point. City school, brand new arena. And even though they are a door mat, Big East is probably equal to or a better basketball conference than the BIG right now. I could see the appeal of trying to rebuild a team in that conference, in a major market, in brand new arena, esp. if it was my home city.
Uh, not in any way shape, form, or fashion, unless you consider one team carrying the entire conference, which Villanova has so ably done. But the rest of the conference . . . . not so much. Tables show conference final rankings, regular season, AP poll.

Screen Shot 2018-08-13 at 10.30.59 PM.pngScreen Shot 2018-08-06 at 9.19.31 AM.png
 
#728      

sacraig

The desert
There was never a deal, that's the deal. What in the world does "right of first refusal for building a relationship" even mean? We get to refuse to allow players to build relationships with other schools? We get to build a relationship with the players? What a deal that would be, MIF LETTING US TALK TO THEIR PLAYERS. wow.

It doesn't mean anything. It's just people making word soup out of commonly-spouted phrases on the boards.

In all likelihood, the non-conspiracy, non-pipedream version of what is going on is that hiring Coleman, among other things, helped repair what was a broken relationship with MIF. Really, they don't choose where their players go, but they do act as gatekeepers and advisors, so being in their good graces is still a big deal. It is still on our staff to build a successful relationship with recruits and close the deal.
 
#729      

Tacomallini

Washington State
I'm not all that broken up about Shannon. Would have been a nice get but we're in decent shape on the wing.

What would make me happy is the following:

1. Sign two quality bigs in the fall
2. Improve upon last year's performance
3. Show improvement as the season progresses
4. Show greater comprehension and sharpness running the Underwood system, particularly on offense
5. At some point make a staff change or two to add experienced teachers of the Underwood system
and most importantly
6. KEEP ALL THE PRODUCTIVE GUYS FOR THE YEAR AFTER

If we can do those things I'll have done a 180, because as of today I remain utterly resolute in my conviction that Underwood has real deal coaching chops (unlike his predecessor) and is a great fit for the job and the right man to lead us going forward.

What gets me disdainful is the utterly preposterous, logically swiss cheese excuse making on here. The house is on fire. Things have been going terribly. Credit will come when credit is deserved.
I liked this post before reading the last paragraph. I agree with everything else.
 
#730      

Dbell1981

Decatur, IL
I'm not all that broken up about Shannon. Would have been a nice get but we're in decent shape on the wing.

What would make me happy is the following:

1. Sign two quality bigs in the fall
2. Improve upon last year's performance
3. Show improvement as the season progresses
4. Show greater comprehension and sharpness running the Underwood system, particularly on offense
5. At some point make a staff change or two to add experienced teachers of the Underwood system
and most importantly
6. KEEP ALL THE PRODUCTIVE GUYS FOR THE YEAR AFTER

If we can do those things I'll have done a 180, because as of today I remain utterly resolute in my conviction that Underwood has real deal coaching chops (unlike his predecessor) and is a great fit for the job and the right man to lead us going forward.

What gets me disdainful is the utterly preposterous, logically swiss cheese excuse making on here. The house is on fire. Things have been going terribly. Credit will come when credit is deserved.
House is not on fire. I'm starting to believe you were related to Mark Smith.
 
#731      

Deleted member 643761

D
Guest
What gets me disdainful is the utterly preposterous, logically swiss cheese excuse making on here. The house is on fire. Things have been going terribly. Credit will come when credit is deserved.

Well, you should direct your disdain to the people on the board making excuses and not to the staff then.
 
#734      

Joel Goodson

respect my decision™
It doesn't mean anything. It's just people making word soup out of commonly-spouted phrases on the boards.

In all likelihood, the non-conspiracy, non-pipedream version of what is going on is that hiring Coleman, among other things, helped repair what was a broken relationship with MIF. Really, they don't choose where their players go, but they do act as gatekeepers and advisors, so being in their good graces is still a big deal. It is still on our staff to build a successful relationship with recruits and close the deal.

This post should automatically pop up whenever someone refers to the MIF pipeline. Make it happen, Dan! :D
 
#736      

Dbell1981

Decatur, IL
Everyone knows the train started to derail when Weber couldn't recruit consistently. Then we thought we hired a younger coach that could get it done but he got out coached and out recruited. We gave him plenty of time before we wrote him off(I did anyways)so why not give these coaches we have now a chance before we burn them down while they are trying to rebuild the dumpster fire Mike Thomas made. The fact that he inherited a team the polar opposite of what he likes and had to secure the recruits that were already on board from the previous staff doesn't help the rebuild. Of course a lot of the players don't fit the mold so he has to start clean. The guys still here are obviously committed to what the coach demands while the others chose to go elsewhere because they don't share the same philosophy. Everything combined is how we got here. We shouldnt EXPECT to close out any top recruits until we start winning more. Now that we have just 1 player from the previous coaching staff old bad habits and negative/conflicting philosophies should wither away this year. I'm willing to bet the guys that transferred out were not helping the team chemistry if they didn't fit the mold/style that was demanded. Once we get a whole roster of players recruited by this staff and this class of Ayo, Jones, Kane, Griffin, Giorgi, and Higgs are upperclassmen you guys can dog this staff all you want. Until then all this criticism is completely unwarranted considering where they started. I have a feeling by then your mouths will be too full of crow to speak for months. Go ILLINI!
 
#737      

Ryllini

Lombard
There was never a deal, that's the deal. What in the world does "right of first refusal for building a relationship" even mean? We get to refuse to allow players to build relationships with other schools? We get to build a relationship with the players? What a deal that would be, MIF LETTING US TALK TO THEIR PLAYERS. wow.


You are right and that is what I said, there is no pipeline. Right of first refusal is the advisors and gate keepers will let us in, but the rest is up to the staff and players UI is interested in. My understanding, that has not always been the case.
 
#738      

Deleted member 654622

D
Guest
You throw these opinions out as fact, but you never, ever back them up with verifiable facts, articles, quotes from actual prospects, or parents. If you choose to believe the O'briens, the wormers go right ahead. They think they have something to gain by stirring up hit seeking articles. What do you have to gain by being constantly negative? Attention? It is like you are trying way to hard to make something out of every little thing, which might be of consequence, or not. Other than constantly looking for the worst possible scenario, and letting everyone know how terrible our staff is, you serve absolutely, no purpose. Provide no verifiable information. I think everyone here is quite capable of imagining the worst possible outcome without it being delivered by you multiple times daily.
 
#739      
Don't believe we can judge BUs recruiting until we see the results of this season. Pieces look good on clips and he has a base of 2 sr., 1 Jr., and 2 sophs to build on (assuming Adonis can play). If he can't elevate to Groces level of wins with this team then we should be discouraged. Believe a class of Timme, Jones, or Cockburn would be a success at that point. Will not be satisfied with a below 9th place BIG finish.
 
#740      

mattcoldagelli

The Transfer Portal
ever back them up with verifiable facts, articles, quotes from actual prospects, or parents. If you choose to believe the O'briens, the wormers go right ahead. They think they have something to gain by stirring up hit seeking articles.

“You aren’t backing up your facts with any articles, but also I do not believe any articles because they are ‘hit-seeking’ please just somebody tell me things that I want to hear and don’t have to think about.”
 
#741      
Seems to be two main camps. Those who are optimistic and think BU and co. are moving in the right direction and that there's light at the end of the tunnel. And those who are not encouraged by what they've seen thus far. While everyone has their own individual opinions with some facts thrown in now and again, ultimately, it's just what people believe versus what others believe. Is the goal here to try and convince others to agree with your view, or is it to try and make others feel bad because they don't agree with you? Because correct me if I'm wrong, but this is just a forum for Illini sports fans. Are there any posters who can actually make an impact to the current situation, such as firing BU, controlling which recruits get official visits, etc.? Lastly, my guess is that anyone who is actually involved with the current coaching staff most likely doesn't read this forum. I could be wrong though!

Shouldn't the real goal of posting on this forum be simply contributing to a discussion about Illini sports where folks learn new things?
 
#742      

Deleted member 654622

D
Guest
I must be in the minority on this board. My initial thought was BU was going to have to come in and establish a winning culture (above .500) with average players. Then he would have the ability to get a better caliber recruit. The team would take a step forward. Recruiting would take a step forward. This would take 3 years at least. Does it suck, yes. But you cannot develop a winning culture in one year.
Yes keep going after big time recruits. It keeps Illinois relevant at least a little to keep seeing them in top 10s. When we become a legit team, we will get legit recruits.
But I must be crazy
 
#743      

Deleted member 654622

D
Guest
Seems to be two main camps. Those who are optimistic and think BU and co. are moving in the right direction and that there's light at the end of the tunnel. And those who are not encouraged by what they've seen thus far. While everyone has their own individual opinions with some facts thrown in now and again, ultimately, it's just what people believe versus what others believe. Is the goal here to try and convince others to agree with your view, or is it to try and make others feel bad because they don't agree with you? Because correct me if I'm wrong, but this is just a forum for Illini sports fans. Are there any posters who can actually make an impact to the current situation, such as firing BU, controlling which recruits get official visits, etc.? Lastly, my guess is that anyone who is actually involved with the current coaching staff most likely doesn't read this forum. I could be wrong though!

Shouldn't the real goal of posting on this forum be simply contributing to a discussion about Illini sports where folks learn new things?
Uhhhh I just come here to post pointless gifs
 
#744      
I must be in the minority on this board. My initial thought was BU was going to have to come in and establish a winning culture (above .500)...This would take 3 years at least.

You are in a minority on this board, as you can see by perusing people's thoughts here: https://www.illinoisloyalty.com/Forum/threads/official-2017-18-season-prediction-thread.24045/

(Just glancing through that thread it didn't appear that you personally made a prediction, I was hoping to catch you lol ;))

You will also be in a minority on this board for this coming season when the same thread comes back around.

Where you are in the comfortable majority on this board is in the conviction that when a new coach is hired, the correct attitude is to display a lobotomized contentedness about absolutely anything that occurs for three to four years, and at that point to turn to vituperative scorn and demands that that coach be fired.

Where I apparently represent a minority on this board is lacking this belief that the word "rebuild" is some magical spell which totally eliminates any ability to analyze any signposts toward future success. It's like a smoke bomb, throw the word "rebuild" out there and all of a sudden all is shrouded in mystery and no truth can be gleaned until the smoke clears. And I think that's wrong. I think you see the progress all along the way.

I have great respect for those who say "we hustled and didn't quit last year, it was better basketball than I've watched in years" in response. I just don't agree.
 
Last edited:
#745      
Seems to be two main camps. Those who are optimistic and think BU and co. are moving in the right direction and that there's light at the end of the tunnel. And those who are not encouraged by what they've seen thus far.

These are not mutually exclusive. There are some, myself included, who are in both camps.
 
#746      
We as a fan base rationalize that recruits can become legends by choosing UI over bigger offers and returning their state school back to glory but can't fathom the same concept happening against us vs. DePaul.


That's a good point. Kudos to DePaul for bringing in this type of talent, as their program has been down for years. I guess there may be some appeal to playing in Chicago, and having games locally televised for family and friends. However, playing in the Big 10, along with national exposure of the Big 10 Network, as well as, having nationally televised games on the major networks and ESPN in a brand new State Farm Center would in my mind be preferable. The ease of having family and friends attend Chicago games vs the drive to Champaign is of course a plus in DePaul's favor. I guess it all boils down to what the young man is comfortable with.
 
#747      
You are in a minority on this board, as you can see by perusing people's thoughts here: https://www.illinoisloyalty.com/Forum/threads/official-2017-18-season-prediction-thread.24045/

(Just glancing through that thread it didn't appear that you personally made a prediction, I was hoping to catch you lol ;))

You will also be in a minority on this board for this coming season when the same thread comes back around.

Where you are in the comfortable majority on this board is in the conviction that when a new coach is hired, the correct attitude is to display a lobotomized contentedness about absolutely anything that occurs for three to four years, and at that point to turn to vituperative scorn and demands that that coach be fired.

Where I apparently represent a minority on this board lacking this belief that the word "rebuild" is some magical spell which totally eliminates any ability to analyze any signposts toward future success. It's like a smoke bomb, throw the word "rebuild" out there and all of a sudden all is shrouded in mystery and no truth can be gleaned until the smoke clears. And I think that's wrong. I think you see the progress all along the way.

I have great respect for those who say "we hustled and didn't quit last year, it was better basketball than I've watched in years" in response. I just don't agree.

I’d argue that the majority of the board actually don’t post.
 
#750      

TyinLex

Kentucky
You are in a minority on this board, as you can see by perusing people's thoughts here: https://www.illinoisloyalty.com/Forum/threads/official-2017-18-season-prediction-thread.24045/

(Just glancing through that thread it didn't appear that you personally made a prediction, I was hoping to catch you lol ;))

You will also be in a minority on this board for this coming season when the same thread comes back around.

Where you are in the comfortable majority on this board is in the conviction that when a new coach is hired, the correct attitude is to display a lobotomized contentedness about absolutely anything that occurs for three to four years, and at that point to turn to vituperative scorn and demands that that coach be fired.

Where I apparently represent a minority on this board is lacking this belief that the word "rebuild" is some magical spell which totally eliminates any ability to analyze any signposts toward future success. It's like a smoke bomb, throw the word "rebuild" out there and all of a sudden all is shrouded in mystery and no truth can be gleaned until the smoke clears. And I think that's wrong. I think you see the progress all along the way.

I have great respect for those who say "we hustled and didn't quit last year, it was better basketball than I've watched in years" in response. I just don't agree.

Put. The. Keyboard. Away. Thank you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.