Illinois Hoops Recruiting Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
#427      
Dior Johnson doesn’t excite me for some reason. Do we really need 3 freshman point guards? I don’t want to recruit over Epps

Wouldn’t be recruiting over Epps … Dior, Skyy, RJ, TSJ, and Mayer. Brad has said multiple times he could start 5 wings, 5 guards. It don’t matter 🤷🏻‍♂️

Bring Epps off the bench as 6th man and nothing changes by adding Dior except style of play and some guys lower on the bench get their minutes cut. The best players always find a way on the court, and if they’re scared of competition (@ Pete Nance) then they shouldn’t be playing for Brad or the U of I anyways. This is an elite basketball program, playing time is earned here. You want guaranteed PT then you go to IU 😂

If Brad thinks he can work with the kid and the kid is willing to buy in. I like the potential and if he transfers after a year … so be it … so does everyone else 🤷🏻‍♂️ We will just reload again.

Not saying Dior is a done deal … Just that it is a possibility
 
#428      
Just think aloud, to understand

Why would that be a problem? IF he remains on the team then (hopefully) it will be because he is a *great* teammate. And, if he decides to enter the portal, then we are where we are. Win-win for both I would think. It is not that we NEED him, no urgency.

And, frankly, one year of Fletch, *I would think* would only benefit the kid, not to speak of other benefits he would have.

No, it isn’t “we are where we are”. Playing time, personalities, guys that have been told it’s their show and then bringing someone else in, the lost year of development for someone else… Having a kid come in as a freshman and transfer after a year is a lose lose for everyone
 
#431      
Wouldn’t be recruiting over Epps … Dior, Skyy, RJ, TSJ, and Mayer. Brad has said multiple times he could start 5 wings, 5 guards. It don’t matter 🤷🏻‍♂️

Bring Epps off the bench as 6th man and nothing changes by adding Dior except style of play and some guys lower on the bench get their minutes cut. The best players always find a way on the court, and if they’re scared of competition (@ Pete Nance) then they shouldn’t be playing for Brad or the U of I anyways. This is an elite basketball program, playing time is earned here. You want guaranteed PT then you go to IU 😂

If Brad thinks he can work with the kid and the kid is willing to buy in. I like the potential and if he transfers after a year … so be it … so does everyone else 🤷🏻‍♂️ We will just reload again.

Not saying Dior is a done deal … Just that it is a possibility
This is why I laugh at the people here saying RJ is guaranteed his. HE has to earn it this summer just like whoever else decided they want to step up.
 
#432      

Joel Goodson

respect my decision™
Not saying Dior is a done deal … Just that it is a possibility

Remember that time when Underwood thought he could finesse the un-finessable? (which he didn't know until the 11th hour). Just really hope this doesn't blow up in our collective face. The skill is undeniable and tantalizing, but there's more red flags than a bullfight.
 
#433      

Epsilon

M tipping over
Pdx
Remember that time when Underwood thought he could finesse the un-finessable? (which he didn't know until the 11th hour). Just really hope this doesn't blow up in our collective face. The skill is undeniable and tantalizing, but there's more red flags than a bullfight.
danger GIF
 
#434      

IlliniKat91

Chicago, IL
well he attended 10 high schools. He apparently is not interested in working through any level of adversity.

Because parents have nothing to do with where their kids live and attend school.

I understand your concern, but I've seen kids go to a school a semester and be fine. They literally don't have a choice if their parents' jobs require them to relocate often.

This is the kind of hand wringing that the staff earns big bucks to do. I trust this staff to handle business since they've proven time and time again that they can.
 
#435      
Yall will always find a way to look at the negative, even after everything BU has done. Brad is getting paid millions to figure out if a players fits, you're not. So let's pump the brakes on judging a kid before he even commits to play for us.

Also, I'm sorry not everyone has their life figured out at 14-18 years old like some of you apparent prodigies did.
 
#437      
Wouldn’t be recruiting over Epps … Dior, Skyy, RJ, TSJ, and Mayer. Brad has said multiple times he could start 5 wings, 5 guards. It don’t matter 🤷🏻‍♂️

Bring Epps off the bench as 6th man and nothing changes by adding Dior except style of play and some guys lower on the bench get their minutes cut. The best players always find a way on the court, and if they’re scared of competition (@ Pete Nance) then they shouldn’t be playing for Brad or the U of I anyways. This is an elite basketball program, playing time is earned here. You want guaranteed PT then you go to IU 😂

If Brad thinks he can work with the kid and the kid is willing to buy in. I like the potential and if he transfers after a year … so be it … so does everyone else 🤷🏻‍♂️ We will just reload again.

Not saying Dior is a done deal … Just that it is a possibility
Also college is a guards game. KU's best teams started two lead guards. You can't undervalue playmakers at the collegiate level.
 
#438      
Yall will always find a way to look at the negative, even after everything BU has done. Brad is getting paid millions to figure out if a players fits, you're not. So let's pump the brakes on judging a kid before he even commits to play for us.

Also, I'm sorry not everyone has their life figured out at 14-18 years old like some of you apparent prodigies did.
This is a message board not a cult. If you think the staff is 100% correct on every move, then you're simply wrong.

We come here to discuss Illini hoops not sit around to talk about how amazing the staff is. I think if you expect Matthew Mayer, who is more a 2 than a 4, to guard big ten bigs, you're asking for trouble. I think if you bring in a redundant piece, even if very talented, you run the risk of causing real trouble. I don't think the risk is worth the reward. I don't think you can blindly trust the staff to hit another homerun next year in the portal. Remember Shannon very well could have been an opponent if classes hadn't been an issue, and we still have a need at the 5 that looks like it will remain unfilled at the moment.

Others think differently. Discussing those differing views is literally the point of the board.
 
#441      
I don't think this lineup works, at all. No rebounds, no rings!

I love Coach's work, but he says a lot of stuff. Not all of it computes.

Agreed. It’s almost as silly as the guys that suggest a super tall lineup with no guards (IMO size fantasies or a just a simplistic notion that taller automatically equates to more wins)

You need to fade most of what BU says. He’s certainly a good coach, but he throws a lot of !!!! out there that’s not gonna happen.

Skyy or Epps will almost always be on the court (and sometimes both together). And one of Hawk or Dain will be on the court most of the time.
 
Last edited:
#442      
Dior Johnson is a very obvious take, you'd be nuts to think otherwise. We're worried about bringing in a top 40 guy because a top 70 guy might have to battle for minutes more? Huh? Trust Underwood to vet out if the multiple high schools thing is a concern or not at all.
 
#445      
Just for kicks and giggles, insert the name Ramey into the mix of this discussion rather than Dior. How would that change things then in our lineup or would it? Would it make it better, worse, or no change?
 
#446      

drsmitty74

Rochester
Maybe, just maybe some in here are getting hung up about having too many wings and guards and not enough "bigs", because of what we have been accustomed to the last couple years. We were blessed to have had Kofi in the middle. Most teams dont have that, thus, I think a Dainj, CoHawk and Mayer will be fine even if we dont add another big. I'm thinking Ty could give us a spell there as well (think DMFW). Give me all the athletic freaks we can get. It's what today's game has evolved in to.

Just my 2 cents.
 
#447      
I'll trust underwood with whatever he decides on this kid. But my gut is that it would add almost nothing. I think Epps tops him because he fits BU's model. Everyday guy. The difference between those two can't be great enough to justify the risk. We're looking at a top 10 team. If we were adding a known veteran I'd feel different than with an immature freshman.
 
#448      
Stole the words out of my mouth. If you believe Ant Wright, we went after the first guy to commit between Ramey and Malachi Smith. Same with Nance. When he took his time in the predraft, we went after Mayer and got him ... and were ecstatic.

Now some may argue that we went after those two senior guards for veteran play, but it might not be just that. You need true ball handling guards to constantly push the pace. There is room for substitution as we are going to put our opponents on their heels. We're playing a totally different style of ball this year. Dior is a talent too good to pass up. He is 6' 3", can finish well, defends, shoots, and rebounds.

Just remember that Houston did pretty well with one 6' 10" guy last year. Rest were 6' 8" or under. Their best guy was only 6' 5".
 
Last edited:
#449      

Joel Goodson

respect my decision™
Just for kicks and giggles, insert the name Ramey into the mix of this discussion rather than Dior. How would that change things then in our lineup or would it? Would it make it better, worse, or no change?

Ramey's not a fit. As indicated by his finalists, he's not willing to accept a 20 mpg role.

Johnson is a different conundrum. Really talented, but not exactly the experienced, steady hand we're seeking. Then there's the stability factor.
 
#450      
Maybe, just maybe some in here are getting hung up about having too many wings and guards and not enough "bigs", because of what we have been accustomed to the last couple years. We were blessed to have had Kofi in the middle. Most teams dont have that, thus, I think a Dainj, CoHawk and Mayer will be fine even if we dont add another big. I'm thinking Ty could give us a spell there as well (think DMFW). Give me all the athletic freaks we can get. It's what today's game has evolved in to.

Just my 2 cents.
For me it's not about the position and size mix. It's about maturity. The only way to make the 22-23 team appreciably better is by adding veteran and experienced talent.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.