Spencer did play his 5 games at the end of the season, which is counter to what the rulebook on medical redshirts says. Domask played in more games than are allowed under the rulebook, regardless of any possible definition of the length of that SIU season, tweeted rumors to the contrary being flatly and obviously incorrect as ten seconds of googling indicate.
But neither matters.
The operative fact is that the NCAA has repeatedly made clear that no eligibility can be given back for 2020-21 because no eligibility was expended.
You know who really got screwed by this? Ivy League players. The Ivy League canceled their entire season due to Covid, the teams shut down, no games, no practices, Ivy League basketball did not exist.
A star UNC women's player who transferred from Princeton sought a waiver to give her back that season that was lost based on the league's decision. She was denied
In her lone season with UNC, Littlefield averaged 8.8 points per game while starting all 32 contests at point guard.
chapelboro.com
St. John's has two former Ivy League players in the same position. They are also seeking waivers like Domask currently
Both players missed the 2020-21 seasons due to the Ivy League season cancellation
www.rumbleinthegarden.com
"Both players’ waiver applications are unlikely to be accepted"
Feel free to dislike the NCAA's rationale here. But it is absolutely objective and clear and has been applied in a resolutely consistent manner, which will continue in Domask's case.