For the sake of argument we do have an open roster spot correct?
Illinois Hoops Recruiting Thread
- Status
Yup. Every year. And every fan base does it. I don’t get the fascination.
1m4tr
Cliffmas
How familiar are you with his game? On that list of people who are now eligible, he may be the least concerning player for an opposing team. Weak weak player.
I'm not sure about fascination. I see it as rabid optimism. It's also seen in greatly overrating our talent, especially freshmen.
Hope springs eternal.
(BYU has been rumored)
lstewart53x3
- Scottsdale, Arizona
Honestly, who’s been greatly overrated this offseason?
— We’re a projected top 5 team by every metric.
— Mirk is a projected 1st Team All American by Vegas. He’s 4th in player of the year odds.
— Vaaks, Andrej, and Tomi are projected top 100 players in college basketball.
— The only freshman in the projected starting lineup is a consensus 5 star, top 15 recruit who was possibly the best player on Team USA this summer and all we need is from him is to be our 5th(?) best player.
— So if by “overrating our freshman”, you mean, we hope one of our freshman can come off the bench as our *9th* man and provide 5-10 minutes and 1-2 points each game, then yes, we’re overrating our freshman.
Half the time, I see more belief in this team by national media than I do on this board.
Guys -- there's been WAY, WAY more posts expressing concern about our depth rather than optimism.
The post that started this conversation is LITERALLY the first of that kind, in the entire offseason. (I'm honestly not ruling it out from being a troll comment, because they probably knew everyone is so ready to oppose the "deepest team ever" argument at all times)
Last edited:
Seems like just about every eligibility case is winnable at this point.
Yeah, this year actually reality finally is as good as expectations. Most years that isn't the case.
The lack of title syndrome leads to massive pessimism. This won’t change until we cut the final nets down in early April some fortunate year (if ever).
ChiefGritty
- Chicago, IL
This is just no way to run a railroad man.
"Third World" is the adjective that springs to mind.
RJ Godfrey to Arizona. Let it begin.
It’s funny how different everyone’s memories are of things like this, I suppose.
Last year we moped over Morez transferring, losing out on Dix/Conwell/Cluade/Jackson/etcetera.
Season before we were doomed all summer after losing out on Storr and the assistant coaching change that led to 5 players (who everyone loved) transferring out.
Then the year before that was the RayJ Dennis summer which needs no further commentary.
Those 3 seasons all ended in tournament appearances, with an Elite 8 and a Final 4.
As far as reality being in line with expectations, I think someone had a graphic that we’ve been finishing above our preseason ranking pretty regularly.
Last edited:
We were talking about player evaluations.
Right, me too. I listed a bunch of players that the board evaluated during the past 3 offseasons.
Seems like we might not be very good at it.
Last edited:
Right, me too. I listed a bunch of players that the board evaluated during the past 3 offseasons.
Seems like we might not be very good at it.
I agree.
With Domask and Keaton Wagler alone, I don’t think literally a single person overvalued them.
If anything most “undervaluations” we’ve had probably just stems from others vastly overachieving and taking usage from those we had “higher” individual expectations on
RabidDawgClassic
- Los Angeles, CA
Right, me too. I listed a bunch of players that the board evaluated during the past 3 offseasons.
Seems like we might not be very good at it.
Don't think we were heavily involved with any of the final 3. It was Dix / Sarr / Sellers who we missed on, but then proceeded to land Petro / Mirk / Stoj.
That was Storr / Egor Demin / even David Jones.
- Status