Nebraska 20, Illinois 7 Postgame

#226      
On offense, it is schemes. We have the backfield and receivers, but most of what Lunney runs I call the WTF offense. There is a lack of talent at right tackle, but that deficiency could be schemed around most of the time. We could improve from a train wreck to something better. Perhaps the LIttle Engine That Could.

On defense it is likely just young talent and the unfortunate injury to Bailey. Our defense looked so much better when he was out there. I understand Walters is learning to be the DC, but I believe those who think we give him this year and we'll see a better product next year. The D does seem to improve weekly.

So, I know I am exceedingly upset because we could be a middling team that made a minor bowl this year and set ourselves up for a better season next year. But that isn't happening.

I'm concerned that Indiana's offense will be on a better footing when we play them and we'll lose the game as a result. Conventional wisdom is you don't change a coordinator in the middle of the season, but I think conventional wisdom is wrong. Indiana made the correct call and it is a call that should be made whether or not the Head Coach is on the hot seat. You show the players you care when you take decisive action to correct an obvious problem.

Anyway, that is my humble opinion, Navy_illini. But, the rant is helpful. I am so upset for the team and players that it is nice to express it.
I was thinking similar. I think we have the talent on offense. Line is questionable but the correct play calls could mitigate and the transfer portal long term
 
#231      
That's not how things work, or how they should work, using my experiences across numerous corporations. Things are bad for 6 weeks, so you fire everyone? There is a huge cost to that. If things aren't going well you meet to discuss. If that doesn't work, you reconvene and try to work it out again. When things aren't working it can take a while to grind through and make change. Six weeks is not a long time.

It's lots of churn when you swap out leaders without the new leader having an obvious immediate fix, plus it sets the example that have a bad six weeks and you are out. Not the way to attract people to come work for you in a tough situation if you have that short a lease.

I'm not suggesting what the outcome should be, but Bret is following the right process.
6 weeks is the equivalent of 6 months. Season is 12 weeks
 
#232      
A lot of people have criticized the 4th down set on the first series. I kind of like it though. All they had to do was have the receiver in motion go right to left instead of left to right. Then have Altmyer fake a handoff to the left side of the line and scamper to the right corner. The tight end keeps the DL on the right side from getting outside and the fullback comes up to block the next defender who would come up. The defender on our receiver on the right would have to make a choice to stay with the receiver running an in route to the left, or leave the receiver to stop Altmyer from getting to the right corner of the end zone. Burn that cornerback for whichever decision he makes. Makes a lot more sense than trying to prove for a third time that we cannot gain a yard between the tackles.
 
#233      
That's not how things work, or how they should work, using my experiences across numerous corporations. Things are bad for 6 weeks, so you fire everyone? There is a huge cost to that. If things aren't going well you meet to discuss. If that doesn't work, you reconvene and try to work it out again. When things aren't working it can take a while to grind through and make change. Six weeks is not a long time.

It's lots of churn when you swap out leaders without the new leader having an obvious immediate fix, plus it sets the example that have a bad six weeks and you are out. Not the way to attract people to come work for you in a tough situation if you have that short a lease.

I'm not suggesting what the outcome should be, but Bret is following the right process.
I agree with some of what you say but our issues with the oc has been going on a lot longer than six weeks. Lunney was not good last year but it was not as noticeable because of the outstanding play of Chase and Tommy.
 
#234      
Yes. It's hard to come in at the end. Start him to get some rhythm going. We have nothing to lose. Let's see what he can do for a full game if we are going to lose anyway.
It’s almost to the point they’re playing to prepare for next year. Don’t you think it would be wise to give the younger QB’s time if they were to pull Luke? I’m not in favor of that as the Oline/play calling is the problem. More work should have been done in the portal in hindsight.
 
#235      
I’m sorry, but that performance last night was well beyond a “bad game”; that was utterly inexcusable. You’re probably right that he’s been the most consistent of the bunch, but that in itself is a huge problem! He’s going to be a good player, he’s just too green right now.
Well he was far away from our only or biggest reason for losing yesterday. Not trying to say he even played half well. The reason question is if we even have anyone worth trying instead and I really think the answer is a resounding no. And that is squarely on the staff
 
#236      
This team is struggling but so is the fandom. We acted like after one year we were going to compete for the Big Ten Championship and even get into the College playoffs! If you don't believe that go back to last years and some of this year's threads. We lost to many talented and high productive players after last year and we were fooling ourselves to think we going to be better than last year. I think there's a few issues, 1) we are impatient and need to let Bret continue to build and I do think Lunney is not getting the best out of the talent we do have. 2) I believe Bret has learned a lot from his past experiences and has the ability to steady the ship and make progress. I agree it's hard to watch, especially with what we hoped could have been a quick turnaround, but I do believe we're still in a foundation building mode. We have a new quarterback that has only started 7 games and is running around trying not to get killed way too often. Talk of firing Bret and Josh being on the Hot Seat is a little dramatic. But we are Illini fans and it's not easy! 😂 Go ILLINI
 
#237      
This team is struggling but so is the fandom. We acted like after one year we were going to compete for the Big Ten Championship and even get into the College playoffs! If you don't believe that go back to last years and some of this year's threads. We lost to many talented and high productive players after last year and we were fooling ourselves to think we going to be better than last year. I think there's a few issues, 1) we are impatient and need to let Bret continue to build and I do think Lunney is not getting the best out of the talent we do have. 2) I believe Bret has learned a lot from his past experiences and has the ability to steady the ship and make progress. I agree it's hard to watch, especially with what we hoped could have been a quick turnaround, but I do believe we're still in a foundation building mode. We have a new quarterback that has only started 7 games and is running around trying not to get killed way too often. Talk of firing Bret and Josh being on the Hot Seat is a little dramatic. But we are Illini fans and it's not easy! 😂 Go ILLINI
You aren't going to convince me this is different from the movie I've already seen 100 times with Illinois football, but I agree any talk of firing Bret is premature
 
#238      
This game can only be described as:

IMG_0086.jpeg
 
#239      
I know Barry is going to get the brunt of the blame for this team but was the Charlie Bullen hire one of the worst assistant coaches hires? It’s like Coleman and Jacas forgot how to play football and that’s with Newton getting doubled every play!!!!!
I dont know if it can all be on Bullen because you can't overlook the contributions of other players that helped open up things for guys like Jacas and the DL last year. Case in point: Calvin Avery. Sure, he may not have achieved superstardom, but he was a seasoned veteran player with tremendous size that wasn't a pushover.
 
#240      
Just to change the topic a bit, what’s with the 20-something guys strutting out at halftime like they’re the clever ones? Give me a break. And I’ll put the students in that group too. “I’ll walk out to show them players!”

Yeah, right.

Damn, the players aren’t causing this. Whether it’s a lack of talent or physical ability, or a lack of preparation by the coaches, or deficiencies in play calling, I won’t believe the players aren’t giving their all. I don’t believe there’s an athlete out there who doesn’t give it their all, if nothing else to not be humiliated.

Abandoning them when the going gets toughest saus more about you than them. We stayed to the end, and there were more, far more Nebraska fans in Memorial Stadium, all of them chanting “GO BIG RED!”

Embarrassing? Nebraska was mocking Illinois fans who left, if not more so, than the empty seats in the home and student sections.
 
#241      

illinipioneer

Richmond, VA
Just to change the topic a bit, what’s with the 20-something guys strutting out at halftime like they’re the clever ones? Give me a break. And I’ll put the students in that group too. “I’ll walk out to show them players!”

Yeah, right.

Damn, the players aren’t causing this. Whether it’s a lack of talent or physical ability, or a lack of preparation by the coaches, or deficiencies in play calling, I won’t believe the players aren’t giving their all. I don’t believe there’s an athlete out there who doesn’t give it their all, if nothing else to not be humiliated.

Abandoning them when the going gets toughest saus more about you than them. We stayed to the end, and there were more, far more Nebraska fans in Memorial Stadium, all of them chanting “GO BIG RED!”

Embarrassing? Nebraska was mocking Illinois fans who left, if not more so, than the empty seats in the home and student sections.
I agree, was there for the first time in over 10 years and was surrounded by Huskers (which was expected they travel well) but any attempt to get the Illini around me to get an ILL going was pathetic. I know we didn’t have much to root for but it was a bit disappointing, but I suppose there’s a reason we fans are so dispondent
 
#242      
Just to change the topic a bit, what’s with the 20-something guys strutting out at halftime like they’re the clever ones? Give me a break. And I’ll put the students in that group too. “I’ll walk out to show them players!”

Yeah, right.

Damn, the players aren’t causing this. Whether it’s a lack of talent or physical ability, or a lack of preparation by the coaches, or deficiencies in play calling, I won’t believe the players aren’t giving their all. I don’t believe there’s an athlete out there who doesn’t give it their all, if nothing else to not be humiliated.

Abandoning them when the going gets toughest saus more about you than them. We stayed to the end, and there were more, far more Nebraska fans in Memorial Stadium, all of them chanting “GO BIG RED!”

Embarrassing? Nebraska was mocking Illinois fans who left, if not more so, than the empty seats in the home and student sections.
Maybe they just decided they had better, more enjoyable ways to spend the remainder of of the evening. Good for you on “taking one for the team” by suffering through the entire embarrassing game.
 
#243      
Are we watching the Arkansas Bret Bielema or the one from Wisconsin? It takes talent for sure, but it's pretty important to utilize the talent you have and that is not happening from the coaches or the players themselves. The OL should be able to help the runner get 1/2 yard, but they didn't, twice. That is unbelievable!!!!
 
#245      
As frustrated as we all are….the coaching staff is even more frustrated. I can assure you that some of your theories on here are hilarious. Bret didn’t forget how to coach(he’s leading the same team meetings he did last year talking about the same stuff about being smart football players and situational football), Bart isn’t doing anything different(coaching/teaching wise) than he did the past 2 years. You can tell kids/show kids what to do and how to do it until you’re blue in the face and sometimes it just doesn’t matter. Walters, Patterson and Kane weren’t god last year. We had 7 NFL guys on the roster last year that were all veteran college guys. Sydney knew every play that was coming at us last year. Made sure everyone was lined up correctly it really was impressive. But back to the meeting….very intense and emotional, self reflection from everyone. They want to figure this out more than anyone. Yes Barry still has a job(for now). Schematic changes were deeply discussed. This team is badly missing senior leadership imo….Sydney, Chase and Palcho ain’t walking through that door. Coaches can lead but player leadership is a helluva lot more effective.,
Seems to me that you’re saying, at least in regards to the OL, that the players Bret and Bart recruited aren’t listening and/or can’t get it done. That’s very concerning.
 
Last edited:
#246      
This team is struggling but so is the fandom. We acted like after one year we were going to compete for the Big Ten Championship and even get into the College playoffs! If you don't believe that go back to last years and some of this year's threads. We lost to many talented and high productive players after last year and we were fooling ourselves to think we going to be better than last year. I think there's a few issues, 1) we are impatient and need to let Bret continue to build and I do think Lunney is not getting the best out of the talent we do have. 2) I believe Bret has learned a lot from his past experiences and has the ability to steady the ship and make progress. I agree it's hard to watch, especially with what we hoped could have been a quick turnaround, but I do believe we're still in a foundation building mode. We have a new quarterback that has only started 7 games and is running around trying not to get killed way too often. Talk of firing Bret and Josh being on the Hot Seat is a little dramatic. But we are Illini fans and it's not easy! 😂 Go ILLINI
Firing anybody is not the answer. This has never been a long-term easy job. If coaches in modern times have been successful they have either moved on or in order to try and sustain success, then they fell into the violation mode. Josh W. is a outstanding AD for Illinois. BB is a wonderful coach. He is really pursuing recruiting ILL. as no one else has. Due to graduations and injuries this has turned into a younger team. Experience is needed in the O-line. A good O-line helps the Defense rest, opens holes for the backs to run through, provides the quarterback time to throw, while giving the receivers time to run good routes. Experience brings consistent play. BB in press meetings said that this would be a scrappy team, meaning I think that they would not dominate their opponents, but would hang in there and compete. The defense is growing better I think. The offense needs the Oline to keep improving.
 
#247      

Illini92and96

Austin, TX
I agree with some of what you say but our issues with the oc has been going on a lot longer than six weeks. Lunney was not good last year but it was not as noticeable because of the outstanding play of Chase and Tommy.
I don't disagree and think the offense has been !!!. I hope/expect Bert put Lunney on notice yesterday. If he can't make material progress, we'll have a new OC next fall
 
#248      

Illini92and96

Austin, TX
6 weeks is the equivalent of 6 months. Season is 12 weeks
Ok. A company has its highest profits in 15 years and everyone is excited that they finally found the right leadership. Things turn south and they fire the leaders six month later? Nah, they reassess and adjust. Maybe even put people on notice. You don't do a 180 six months after relatively tremendous success. If Bret's worth anything as a leader he'll get this team to try something new ASAP.

Brad changed away from the awful press defense schema and it worked out well. Hopefully we can make a similar pivot in football.
 
#249      
One of the worst college football games I’ve ever seen.

Seen on a Husker fan blog today: “In all my years of watching college football, that was the worst game ( by both teams ) I have ever seen. I hesitate to even call it a game... “

See, Illini Nation and Husker Nation can find common ground after all!

If both fan bases can agree that this is about the worst things can get... that bodes well for the future... doesn't it? Things must get better, right?

(No, things could still get worse. But this is finding the 'positive spin'... and looking for the nice piece of candy down in the bottom of Charlie Brown's Halloween bag filled with rocks.)
 
#250      

Illini2010-11

Sugar Grove
Well, we're on the football board talking about the football program, and I was responding to someone that claimed that Whitman should not be on the hot seat because it could get much worse - like it was under Mike Thomas. And I pointed out that, factually, Josh Whitman's football program in year 8 has worse on field results than the football program under Mike Thomas
Mood What GIF by NBC

It was absolutely worse under Mike Thomas. He hired Tim Beckman and look how that turned out! You can't compare the actual records of Whitman to Thomas because they came into much different scenarios. The program was not in shambles when Thomas took over, but it was a dumpster fire when Josh came in to try to clean up the mess and scandals of the Thomas administration.

Both football and basketball tanked under Thomas. And without the Beckman scandal, I doubt Thomas would have been fired, so he wasn't run off because he was an outsider. So yes, it was completely worse under Thomas across the board.
 
Last edited: