As for the "eye test" you need to have your eyes checked.
I can proudly say that I have seen every Illini basketball game that has been televised on cable/sattelite since they started. When I lived in the Chicago area I attended 6-10 games per year. My first Illini game was Jan 29, 1967 at Chicago Stadium.
I went to 6 games in the '89 season and more than that in 2005. I have been able to meet a couple members of the '89 team and several players from '07 - '12.
So let's be clear, the '89 team only had 7 players. Same with the 2005 team. 1989 team was better than the '05 team, but that's only because college basketball overall was better in '89. The '89 group had speed, athleticism and tenacity. They could also shoot 3s when they had to and they shot them better than the '05 team and better than the 2026 team. The '89 team had the best defense we have ever had.
But the '89 team did not have depth, they didn't rebound as well as this team, they didn't shoot foul shots as well as this team and they turned the ball over far more than the 2025 and 2005 team. One other ENORMOUS Difference between the 2025 team and the other 2. Every one of the players we put on the floor can shoot 3 point shots and therefore have to be guarded. That completely changes what this team can do offensively on each possession.
BTW those are facts and my eyes are fine. This team can play inside and out and completely change their offensive set depending on the match ups they get. Neither the '05 or the '89 team could do that and that is why they lost the games they lost.
When this team has Kylan Boswell on the floor and uses 8 - 9 players, they are at times the best team Illinois has ever had. They can play lock - down defense with Boswell, Stojakovic, Mirkovic able to play serious MTM and the Ivisic bothers both able to block shots. The difference here is that the 2026 team doesn't play lock down defense for 40 minutes. That's a mystery to me.