Pretty big "if" there.His prospect rep was all defense so if he's actually able to hang around as a league average or slightly above hitter, then he's definitely the better option than Crooks long term. But a 22 year old catcher who put up a 116 wRC+ in his first taste of the majors is definitely exciting.
Whoever the catcher ends up being gets supplanted by Rainiel Rodriguez at some point anyway, if he's able to stick at catcher (they had him playing a good amount of 1B in AA this year, he's no C defensive whiz). That's the one with HOF odds between the two (but like... 5% vs. 1%).
If Bernal keeps hitting like this (also a big if!), being able to slide Rainel over to 1B is actually great. Longevity is easier at that position and if Rainel ends up being the batter we hope, then 1B will keep him in the lineup more consistently. For example, Yadi got to 140+ games only 2 times in his career and topped out at 147. Meanwhile Albert got to 160+ games 3 times, 150+ 12 times, and 140+ 16 times.