Yeah the youth and inexperience excuse should buy Underwood a few more years, fortunately for him the program has bottomed out, cuz that excuse wouldn't be tolerated at places like Kentucky, Duke, Michigan State, etc.
Well it wouldn't be tolerated at those places because the level of recruits he would be getting as freshman are borderline NBA level. If our team is "young" the next couple years, I understand. That is a valid excuse at our program level. When it wont be an excuse is if we have to replace three or four non-senior starters/contributors year in and year out (and we replace them with either freshman or transfers). I'm fine with attrition, even at the high level we saw this year, but that comes with the stipulation that the team can't forever be in rebuild mode or snatching the last top 300 recruit in march every year.
I struggle with thinking whether or not criticism (of BU's recruiting technique) is wrong at this point. I think its wrong to come to conclusions about how this team will shape up to be or that anything he's done so far will become a trend. But I think its justified to be skeptical of actions he's taken so far. he's got a few more cycles before I say what he's doing it wrong, but I question a lot of his actions. In the end, he could recruit kids soley from Panama, replace all thirteen roster guys, and only play four men on the court, winning is all I want to see.