2017 Coaching Carousel

Status
Not open for further replies.
#1,451      
You literally just described that that team was more than the sum of their parts, which was the whole point...

Right before I clicked submit I read it to myself and said "I"m not sure if I'm arguing here or confirming what he said, but what the hell...I'll click submit anyway."

tonight's game cant get here fast enough.
 
#1,452      

radiodj

Houston
This thread is depressing (specifically a team being more than the sum of their parts) . I'm sitting hear reading about of some of the lesser Bruce Weber years and thinking to myself, "You know, it wasn't that terrible."

Yeah, for as bad as some of those years were; these past few have been undeniably worse.
 
#1,453      

schnaurt

Phoenix, AZ
This thread is depressing (specifically a team being more than the sum of their parts) . I'm sitting hear reading about of some of the lesser Bruce Weber years and thinking to myself, "You know, it wasn't that terrible."

We were all hoping the end of that season (Nebraska game for me personally) was the low point of the millenium for Illini bball. The 2012-2013 season did a lot to make us think we were trending upwards but at this point, I think we would all agree that season was an anomally.
 
#1,454      
This thread is depressing (specifically a team being more than the sum of their parts) . I'm sitting hear reading about of some of the lesser Bruce Weber years and thinking to myself, "You know, it wasn't that terrible."

It WAS that terrible. And it's even more terrible now. We don't have to accept this. In fact, acceptance of this is the only think that will keep it happening.

People act like just firing a bunch of coaches until you get what you want is morally wrong somehow, because firing people isn't nice and the narrative of delusional fans who don't know their program's place is one that everybody loves.

And maybe it is morally wrong, but it certainly works. Teams find their level as they churn though coaches. And for teams who are playing below their level, you either break through and hire Jim Harbaugh or your public humiliation sixth-choice disaster turns out to be Pete Carroll. I don't mean to compare Illinois Basketball with Michigan or USC Football, but Illinois' natural resources in terms of fan interest, facilities, recruiting base, press coverage, successful history all indicate that in an average year, all else being equal, we should be better than schools that don't have as much going for them like Iowa or Wisconsin or Ohio State. The only thing that can break that reality is us accepting that it is not reality.

You shouldn't just fire your coach after every bad year, things only become clear over longer time horizons than that. But if you're the all time top team in the Big Ten in winning percentage (did you know that? I just found that out by looking it up, I expected to be 2nd or 3rd), who went to the tournament 21 times in 25 years (and one of those misses was because the NCAA banned us) until very recently, and who has a brand new arena, and you're sitting there having missed the tournament four times in a row, you should be confident, not frightened or ashamed to think "we can and will do better under different leadership."

Have some pride folks!
 
#1,455      
Get rid of any hypotheticals and assume we lose Tilmon and Frazier.

TJL, JCL, DJW, Black, and Finke is plenty of top-line talent to make some noise in the Big Ten and comfortably make the tournament.

That's the difference a good coach makes. And that's all besides any talent he would surely add on and/or retain.

I don't think we even remember what it looks like to have an Illini team be more than the sum of their parts anymore. Demetri McCamey, Chester Frazier, Trent Meacham, Mike Davis and Mike Tisdale were the warhorse starting five for a 5 seed that finished 2nd in the Big Ten. Calvin Brock and Dominique Keller were basically our only contributors off the bench. That's a thing that really happened in real life, and with a just okay coach.

If I were a supervillain I'd round up all of you claiming our players don't have the talent to be winning difference-makers in the Big Ten and force you to watch our overtime win against a Top 10 Purdue team in Mackey that year like that dude in Clockwork Orange.

Robbie Hummel, E'Twaun Moore, JaJuan Johnson, you know that team. They got beaten (twice!) by the Bad News Bears of the Weber era.

Proof that Bruce Weber was a really good coach. Good thing we ran him out of town!
 
#1,456      
Is this love fest for Weber a real thing? Or am I missing something.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G920A using Tapatalk
 
#1,458      

radiodj

Houston
Is this love fest for Weber a real thing? Or am I missing something.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G920A using Tapatalk

I don't know about a "love-fest," but just admitting that the program is worse now than when he was fired.
 
#1,459      
Yes, and I don't see it happening personally. If we had stronger booster support, sure. The BIG gives us a lot of guaranteed money, so you'd really have to have a strong fanbase to justify what I'll call, the anti-Guenther approach.

Without seeing actual revenue numbers, I think you can easily justify $2-3 mil for a coach here, and we're pretty certain Thomas was going to push above that for the right guy (which incidentally, how does Shaka Smart look today?). So I'll guess we're going to be looking at young guys we can bring in for $1 - $1.5, plus a few select guys that are already at that level or higher that we can drop another mil on. Anyone we're going to want to pilfer is going to be someone a school will defend, so you need enough ammo to win a bidding war. A guy making $3 mil already is not gonna happen IMO.

Personally, I'd be surprised if the next coach makes less than 2 million, and I'm hard pressed to not say less than 2.5. Whitman understands the passion of the fanbase for the hoops program, and I think he'll be able to find at least that much from donors/B10 money. 5 million won't happen, IMO, but we're going to commit more than we have for Groce.

Groce won early with players that quit on Weber. I think due to Weber's negativity.

Groce missed on a lot of top recruits and has looked mediocre as a result. I would have let him go a year ago based on his recruiting. Now his class looks like one of our best. I'm in for seeing if he can finally get it going.

If the struggles weren't due to more than just talent, I/we wouldn't be having this conversation, IMO. But the reality is he hasn't really EXCELLED in any area.
 
#1,461      
I don't know about a "love-fest," but just admitting that the program is worse now than when he was fired.

That's because Weber set the program in a downward spiral that was hard to reverse. Granted Groce has been unable to reverse the downward trend but once you become irrelevant it is much harder to return to prominence. The task will be immense for the new coach (whoever that may be) and without being able to attract major talent, I think many posters' assertions that we can do it with lesser talent but great X's and O's will remain just a dream. JMO.
 
#1,462      
That's because Weber set the program in a downward spiral that was hard to reverse. Granted Groce has been unable to reverse the downward trend but once you become irrelevant it is much harder to return to prominence. The task will be immense for the new coach (whoever that may be) and without being able to attract major talent, I think many posters' assertions that we can do it with lesser talent but great X's and O's will remain just a dream. JMO.

It REALLY isn't that hard to fall backwards into moderate success. Tim freaking Beckman practically got kidnapped by a bowl game.

I may embarass myself with this, but watch the game tonight. Michigan isn't going to take yes for an answer, I can feel it. Whole seasons like that happen in college sports all the time.

We've made it look so, so much harder than it is over the last decade.
 
#1,463      
It REALLY isn't that hard to fall backwards into moderate success. Tim freaking Beckman practically got kidnapped by a bowl game.

Tim Beckman found "moderate success"? If you consider getting an invitation to non-name, don't-care-bowl moderate success then Zook and Turner need to be enshrined into the Illinois' Superhero Hall of Fame for going to a Rose Bowl and Sugar Bowl. Unless that is what we are talking here about for basketball.
 
#1,464      
Calipari is a good coach, having the #1 recruiting class annually, ESPECIALLY in college hoops, doesn't entitle you to the success he has had at numerous stops. He falls into the mold of "good coach, elite recruiter" that all schools are striving for. Great recruiting will boost a coach over the top, but you still need to have a firm knowledge of x's and o's to succeed regardless.

Said better than I could have.

I don't think some can separate their hatred of the guy from the results he achieves. Just keeping all those 5 stars happy and moving as a team is excellent coaching.
 
#1,465      
A name I don't believe has been mentioned. Danny Manning?

He is currently coaching for Wake Forest and has yet to experience a lot of success but he is rebuilding the program and has pulled in solid recruiting classes each of the last 3 years. Before WF, he took Tulsa to the tournament. He has a history of recruiting and coaching Chicago kids while he was an assistant at Kansas from 2003-2012. He is a relatively well-known name as he was a former number 1 pick.

I think he would be attainable because he is currently coaching in the very competitive ACC at a school that will always be tough to recruit to because he is surrounded by Duke, UNC, and NC State. He is really good friends from coaching with Bill Self and knows how good Illinois can be and what it takes to succeed at UI.
 
#1,467      
Where are we at on Ben Jacobson now that this year's team appears to be a disaster area?

If he is below .500 in conference for the first time in his career, that would take a bit of the shine off the resume.
 
#1,469      
Kermit Davis is a bit underrated. He cut his teeth under Tim Floyd and John Brady, so you'd figure he'd know his way around the fever swamps of recruiting. Middle Tennessee has been dominant across two different conferences in recent years and they have claimed some impressive Power Five scalps. Auburn, Ole Miss twice, Vandy, UCLA, and of course Michigan State last year in the tournament.

I don't know if he's the perfect fit for our job, but you could very well see LSU, Ole Miss and Mizzou all open in the SEC this offseason, I think he'd be a fine hire for one of those jobs.
 
#1,474      
Where are we at on Ben Jacobson now that this year's team appears to be a disaster area?

If he is below .500 in conference for the first time in his career, that would take a bit of the shine off the resume.

I've never been a big fan of Jacobson. That being said, if you think that what he does translates to Illinois, I would overlook one bad season. Of course, what is the proper way to move forward and what you can sell to fans are often two very different paths.
 
#1,475      

mattcoldagelli

The Transfer Portal with Do Not Contact Tag
Unfashionable to coach in Khakis? :eek:

giphy.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies.