Illinois Hoops Recruiting Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
#452      
For as much as Weber is ragged on on here, it's like people think it's a given that just because you inherit some good underclassmen you're going to go on an extended tourney run to the Championship game and be two final seconds shots away from a perfect season... In fact, if you really want to get down to brass tacks, Bill Self, for all he's heralded on here, probably inherited an even better team from Lon Kruger than the one Weber inherited from Self and "only" took them to an Elite 8 in three seasons. Plus, Weber actually had to "re-recruit" Deron and Dee as Self tried taking both to Kansas with him on the way out the door.

And just some food for thought, if Weber inherited the Ayo, Kofi, and Trent team, how far do we have that team going? Sweet 16? Final Four? National Championship? There were many things Weber was not, but he was one hell of an x's and o's and tourney ball coach.

Was Weber kept as coach for longer than he should have been? Sure. But it's just odd to me that he gets treated by fans worse than Groce does, or hell, worse than even Tim Beckman on here, which quite frankly should be impossible. It's almost like on his way out of town he ran over a bunch of people's dogs. It has been over 10 years- I think we can put it to rest and just enjoy the positive memories. Because if we don't it's just us, Jereme Richmond, and the Jamar Smith car accident in our heads, and that's no way to get through life.
I don't think that is true.
 
#453      
For as much as Weber is ragged on on here, it's like people think it's a given that just because you inherit some good underclassmen you're going to go on an extended tourney run to the Championship game and be two final seconds shots away from a perfect season... In fact, if you really want to get down to brass tacks, Bill Self, for all he's heralded on here, probably inherited an even better team from Lon Kruger than the one Weber inherited from Self and "only" took them to an Elite 8 in three seasons. Plus, Weber actually had to "re-recruit" Deron and Dee as Self tried taking both to Kansas with him on the way out the door.

And just some food for thought, if Weber inherited the Ayo, Kofi, and Trent team, how far do we have that team going? Sweet 16? Final Four? National Championship? There were many things Weber was not, but he was one hell of an x's and o's and tourney ball coach.

Was Weber kept as coach for longer than he should have been? Sure. But it's just odd to me that he gets treated by fans worse than Groce does, or hell, worse than even Tim Beckman on here, which quite frankly should be impossible. It's almost like on his way out of town he ran over a bunch of people's dogs. It has been over 10 years- I think we can put it to rest and just enjoy the positive memories. Because if we don't it's just us, Jereme Richmond, and the Jamar Smith car accident in our heads, and that's no way to get through life.
You are right. Weber did exceedingly well for one year given a team that perfectly matched his system. Then he burnt the whole thing down until Underwood got Ayo and Kofi. He wasn't good at assembling a staff and he chased recruiting rankings instead of recruiting his system.
 
#454      

pruman91

Paducah, Ky
I don't think that is true.
A lot of why bubbles gets grief here is him ragging on his players in the media and talking out of his arse...........As far as his X's and O's acumen , I remember a lot of last second shots from deep to avoid the shot clock and his constant hollering at the players to move.......

2005 was a magical year and he deserves credit , but that was his high point as the Illini coach.......He never got on a roll recruiting after that year......But , he did coach a 37-2 National Championship Runner up team , so there is that.....I was NOT sad he got the boot....
 
#455      
You are right. Weber did exceedingly well for one year given a team that perfectly matched his system. Then he burnt the whole thing down until Underwood got Ayo and Kofi. He wasn't good at assembling a staff and he chased recruiting rankings instead of recruiting his system.
In fairness to Weber, IDKWTI and Sampscum killed him. We could have had Gordon and Derrick Rose. We could have had E'Twan Moore, but scumbags lied. Though he was responsible for selecting Billy Cole over Robbie Hummel. That was also killer.
 
#457      
Be careful what you wish for. An immediate fire under those circumstances means that Dainja, Goode, Rodgers, Harris, Hansberry and our potential 5 star Morez Johnson all could be transferring and with Shannon, Hawkins, Harmon, Domask and Guerrier all graduating we effectively could be starting from scratch. In a world of NIL and transfers, that might not be as big a problem than in the past for a new head coach like Indy's Sean Miller, but there are no guarantees that any of our current players or assistant coaches would come back nor that we would ever see Morez in the Orange and Blue. There is something to be said about continuity in a program/coaching staff and I am hoping to see our current underclassmen play and develop together for the next few years. If Brad can't succeed in the Tournament with this group and a handful of targeted transfers over the next few years, then he will be gone. But a first round exit next year shouldn't be enough for that to happen.
Players leaving and graduating is almost a certainty. And I am one who cringes at the thought of Sean Miller coaching the Illini. Simply amazing the things people will say on a message board.

I have seen a legendary coach whose players loved to play for him fired for some reasons that a parent took from nothing and made into an egregious sin. It is not pretty nor does it take much thought...and any thought of so doing does not generally get much mulling over or critical thought...especially on a message board.

Without much ado, my choice is to enjoy watching this group of talented...and hopefully team oriented...players grow, hopefully together...while allowing Whitman to do HIS job.
 
#461      

USAFILLINI

Florida
Players leaving and graduating is almost a certainty. And I am one who cringes at the thought of Sean Miller coaching the Illini. Simply amazing the things people will say on a message board.

I have seen a legendary coach whose players loved to play for him fired for some reasons that a parent took from nothing and made into an egregious sin. It is not pretty nor does it take much thought...and any thought of so doing does not generally get much mulling over or critical thought...especially on a message board.

Without much ado, my choice is to enjoy watching this group of talented...and hopefully team oriented...players grow, hopefully together...while allowing Whitman to do HIS job.
His job will be locking down Sean Miller :LOL:
 
#462      
Weber gets treated worse only because, as a collective, we prefer to forget about Groce and Beckman.
Weber gets treated worse (unfairly I agree but am guilty myself sometimes) because we saw his heights, and witnessed his / our full fall. Groce and Beckman never got there at all.
 
#463      

skyIdub

Winged Warrior
This team has 3-4 All Big Ten players. Ain’t missing the tourney.
reporter-shocked.gif
 
#466      
You’re right…it was far from a given. BW did a whale of a job on that run with the 2005 run…and that doesn’t just happen by chance.

As you know it’s also far from a given Bruce would have excelled with the 2021 team. If l had to guess, the first thing he would have tried to do was plug in his motion offense. The upside is there would of likely been more purposeful motion…(especially more than the 2022 team) but would it have been quick hitting enough for that lineup?

Openings materializing late in the
possession probably wouldn’t have been ideal for a team that could get turnover-happy at times. The less scout-able, unpredictable nature of the motion is awesome but I just feel like that team needs more structure than that. JMO

Since we’re getting crazy…to be honest with you. I would have rather seen what would of happened had Lon had the 2021. I think Lon was probably the best at adjusting his offense to fit his personnel AND making in-game adjustments as anyone we’ve ever had. Again. JMO

Bruce Weber’s tenure was a mixed bag. That’s all you can say…one of the best stretches followed by arguably the worst stretch.(Like seriously…objectively bad…see 21ChampaignSt’s research) He was very much a nice guy. But he comes off as a whiner and an oddball to a lot of people. (So I hear.) Yes it’s snarky and probably a little unkind..but I think that’s the reality.

Yes, he could outcoach John Groce or Billy Gillespie on his worst day blindfolded
while in a Jarling’s-induced, semi comatose state.
Bruce nor John Groce ever had an Orlando Atigua or Tim Anderson, even Chester Frazier. May have made a big difference. Add Fletch to those teams also.
 
#467      
I hope not as facts support that as a serious downgrade. But if Whitman and Illini fans agree that Miller is the savior, they deserve him. The University of Illinois can and should do much better.
Like who, the last three coaches we plucked were mid-majors plus one Oklahoma State year with Brad. With Josh, however, and our NIL stash the next hire will be much more seasoned and established. Jmo

As for Sean Miller cheating, we need to get off our high horse. This is no longer about the prestige of our academic institution, it’s business and dollars! Are USC and UCLA coming in because they want to rub shoulders with institutions with high academic standing? Yeah, right.. $$$$$$
 
#468      

lstewart53x3

Scottsdale, Arizona
Bruce nor John Groce ever had an Orlando Atigua or Tim Anderson, even Chester Frazier. May have made a big difference. Add Fletch to those teams also.
Part of being a good head coach is the ability to attract and lead a stable of good assistant coaches. Underwoods‘s already had to rebuild a second staff from scratch. The two staff’s he’s assembled are both superior to what Groce and Weber could put together.
 
#469      
Of course this is true. But all three were very good college players who were able to bring that actual experience to coaching.
There was a huge difference in how very good. Howard, by far the worst coach, was by far the very "goodest" player. He had a 19 year NBA career. Painter was a distant second; a rotation level B1G player. Izzo, the best coach, was the worst player -- a D-2 star.

It's like there is an inverse relationship between athletic talent and coaching skill. Note that clubhouse pros at golf courses are not the necessarily the best golfers, but are good teachers.

John Beilein was another pretty good college coach. He played his college ball at the Wheeling College powerhouse.

You can downplay it, but Tyler Underwood had more actual experience playing college basketball than Bruce Weber. As much as I dislike Weber, he was a fairly capable coach.

 
#470      
Every position?
Even if Ty Rodgers is not a true point guard, Dravyn Gibbs-Lawhorn and Niccolo Moretti are good players.

DGL is a stud athlete with skills. Moretti can handle, pass, and shoot. The only question is whether they are good enough defensively as freshmen.

Justin Harmon is an athletic combo guard with plenty of experience.
 
#473      
Part of being a good head coach is the ability to attract and lead a stable of good assistant coaches. Underwoods‘s already had to rebuild a second staff from scratch. The two staff’s he’s assembled are both superior to what Groce and Weber could put together.
it's a lot easier to attract coaches when you've got a lot more money to play with. Part of the reason the standard for success has risen is because the investment in the program has risen.
 
#474      
It's like there is an inverse relationship between athletic talent and coaching skill. Note that clubhouse pros at golf courses are not the necessarily the best golfers, but are good teachers.
The reason why is explained pretty well in 'Revenge of the Nerds.'
 
#475      
You are right. Weber did exceedingly well for one year given a team that perfectly matched his system. Then he burnt the whole thing down until Underwood got Ayo and Kofi. He wasn't good at assembling a staff and he chased recruiting rankings instead of recruiting his system.
I really don't want to rehash 15 years of the same argument on here as I know full well some fans liked Weber, and some hated him and blame him for burning down what was a golden era for us. And I think people for sure are entitled to their opinions there, I'm just sort of sick of seeing this continue to go on when we're already so far removed and it's not like he purposefully or maliciously destroyed the program.

But since we're still here, let's see who Weber left Groce just to check how badly Illinois basketball was destroyed when he left:
Sr BP3: 2x 3rd team all-B10, had a cup of coffee in the NBA, 4star recruit (#126)
Sr DJ Richardson: 3rd team all-B10, B10 freshman of the year, 4star recruit (#115)
Jr Tracy Abrams: 4star Top 100 recruit (#67)
So Nnanna Egwu: B10 all-defense, 4star Top 100 recruit (#70)
So Mychael Henry: 4star Top 100 recruit (#60), had a cup of coffee in the NBA
HS Sr recruit Malcolm Hill: 2x 2nd team all-B10, had a cup of coffee in the NBA, 4star Top 100 recruit (#69)

Weber left Groce with 4 all-conference players, 4 Top 100 players, and 6 4stars. That's certainly not leaving the cupboards bare in my opinion. And I do understand that folks are still angry with Weber to this day for taking a Top 10 team and turning it into a bubble team, but it still seems more than a bit much to me, as there are so so many people to blame for our falloff than just him. Also, I'm not trying to rag on you or anything, it's just that I'm so done with the Weber snarkiness in general. It just never really sat right to me to constantly beat a man up for 15+ years because he failed to live up to everyone's expectations. At some point we just have to let this one go.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.