Illinois Hoops Recruiting Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
#76      
From this list the worst top 100 player is either Shaw, DJ Williams or Spears. I don't count transfer 100's like Omar Payne, but he was ranked to high. Kofi was really a top 15 recruit, was well undervalued. Kofi is the most most dominant big man at Illinois and not even close. Adam Miller and Skyy Clark and couple others were ranked to high (Mcbride as well). None were anywhere as good as Ayo. Most top 100 players were good at Illinois.
And then how do you rank a kid like Abrams in terms of how his career turned out? I hate to say one of the worst because I loved his game, but man he had the absolute worst luck when it came to his body.

I also wouldn’t overlook Crandall Head on your list of worst. DJ Williams got a cup of coffee in the NBA.
 
#77      
And then how do you rank a kid like Abrams in terms of how his career turned out? I hate to say one of the worst because I loved his game, but man he had the absolute worst luck when it came to his body.

I also wouldn’t overlook Crandall Head on your list of worst. DJ Williams got a cup of coffee in the NBA.
Dj Williams did?? I don't remember that.
 
#78      
Dain isn't a bad player and definitely has value but with limited scholarships and minutes plus Hansberry and Johnson I wouldn't be upset if he ended up leaving.

I just don't think that back to basket slow the game down type of big you really want unless their an absurdly good passer or a physical freak like Kofi.

You don't even really need a ton of skilled bigs a guy that can simply set screens and roll to the basket is plenty effective on offense.
Hmmm. Dain is a GOOD player. Not a star, but if you think Amani and Morez will be ahead of him...awesome, BUT you won't find a better backup big!
 
#79      
From this list the worst top 100 player is either Shaw, DJ Williams or Spears. I don't count transfer 100's like Omar Payne, but he was ranked to high. Kofi was really a top 15 recruit, was well undervalued. Kofi is the most most dominant big man at Illinois and not even close. Adam Miller and Skyy Clark and couple others were ranked to high (Mcbride as well). None were anywhere as good as Ayo. Most top 100 players were good at Illinois.
It's not as simple as just looking at the top 100. There are years where there is just a ton of talent and some guys that would be top 25 end up top 40 and vice versa.

Look at Deron at #48, a top 5 Illini all time I think most would agree with. Well not only did he have the #12 player on his team he had to share the spotlight with, but the PGs in that class rated higher than him were Raymond Felton, Daniel Horton, Anthony Roberson, Dee Brown, Sean Dockery, Gerry McNamara, Allan Ray (combo), John Gilchrist, and Jarret Jack. There are an awful lot of All Americans on that list.

Ayo was the same way lot of guys ranked ahead of him also currently in the NBA. Whereas other years not as strong and some guys are maybe ranked a little higher than they otherwise would be.

For the rankings don't matter crowd, who are the guys not on that list, that have been Illini greats (or at least very goods)? Mike Davis? though his recruitment was very weird.
 
Last edited:
#80      
And then how do you rank a kid like Abrams in terms of how his career turned out? I hate to say one of the worst because I loved his game, but man he had the absolute worst luck when it came to his body.

I also wouldn’t overlook Crandall Head on your list of worst. DJ Williams got a cup of coffee in the NBA.
Did he really? Can't seem to find anything on that. Always thought he had the measurables but couldn't put it all together.
 
#82      

Loyalillini10

Urbana, IL
Yea let's just push out a guy that has the ability to score, rebound, is a decent rim protector, and can pass just because we don't like post ups anymore 🙄

Games aren't just run and gun up and down the court, there's a ton of half court action and you always need guys who can score in different ways and take advantage of matchups. There were a couple times against EIU where Dain got the ball and I already knew he was going to score. That kind of high efficiency is valuable.
Look, you and I have been on here long enough to know that our fanbase isn't exactly rational. Dain isn't very flashy, but he gets boards on both ends of the court, blocks shots, has a solid post-up game and a capable turnaround jumper from 10-12 feet. I don't know, I guess that isn't enough...
 
#83      
It's not as simple as just looking at the top 100. There are years where there is just a ton of talent and some guys that would be top 25 end up top 40 and vice versa.

Look at Deron at #48, a top 5 Illini all time I think most would agree with. Well not only did he have the #12 player on his team he had to share the spotlight with, but the PGs in that class rated higher than him were Raymond Felton, Daniel Horton, Anthony Roberson, Dee Brown, Sean Dockery, Gerry McNamara, Allan Ray (combo), John Gilchrist, and Jarret Jack. There are an awful lot of All Americans on that list.

Ayo was the same way lot of guys ranked ahead of him also currently in the NBA. Whereas other years not as strong and some guys are maybe ranked a little higher than they otherwise would be.

For the rankings don't matter crowd, who are the guys not on that list, that have been Illini greats (or at least very goods)? Mike Davis? though his recruitment was very weird.
Agreed. There are misses, but if I think of my Top 5 Illini during this time period, three of the Top 5 are numbers 1, 2, and 3 on that list (Dee, Cook, Frank). The other two (Ayo and Deron) are in the top half of the list (top 50 guys). And my next two (Kofi and BP3) are also in the top half.

So if the 7 best Illini of the last 25 years came from roughly the top 50 ranks, it’s probably pretty important to recruit there.

FWIW, Trent is probably next on my list (above Malcolm), so there are certainly +100 diamonds out there in the rough. #GiorgiBAmazing
 
#84      
I don't think this has been posted yet but it is so amazing. Forgive me if I am over sharing this great interview with Morez. So excited for him and the the team!
Really impressive interview. Morez really seems to have it all..maturity, intelligence, and work ethic to go along with his undeniable talent. Very excited to see him in O&B!
 
#85      
It's not as simple as just looking at the top 100. There are years where there is just a ton of talent and some guys that would be top 25 end up top 40 and vice versa.

Look at Deron at #48, a top 5 Illini all time I think most would agree with. Well not only did he have the #12 player on his team he had to share the spotlight with, but the PGs in that class rated higher than him were Raymond Felton, Daniel Horton, Anthony Roberson, Dee Brown, Sean Dockery, Gerry McNamara, Allan Ray (combo), John Gilchrist, and Jarret Jack. There are an awful lot of All Americans on that list.
Was Chris Paul also in that class or a year above or below.
 
#88      

GrayGhost77

Centennial, CO
Look, you and I have been on here long enough to know that our fanbase isn't exactly rational. Dain isn't very flashy, but he gets boards on both ends of the court, blocks shots, has a solid post-up game and a capable turnaround jumper from 10-12 feet. I don't know, I guess that isn't enough...
Dain was hands down easily our most efficient inside scorer last year. He was also #1 in rebounds and blocks on a per-minute basis.
 
#89      

blackdog

Champaign
Dain was hands down easily our most efficient inside scorer last year. He was also #1 in rebounds and blocks on a per-minute basis.

85gt47.jpg
 

Attachments

  • 85gt47.jpg
    85gt47.jpg
    78.4 KB · Views: 66
#90      
Agreed. There are misses, but if I think of my Top 5 Illini during this time period, three of the Top 5 are numbers 1, 2, and 3 on that list (Dee, Cook, Frank). The other two (Ayo and Deron) are in the top half of the list (top 50 guys). And my next two (Kofi and BP3) are also in the top half.

So if the 7 best Illini of the last 25 years came from roughly the top 50 ranks, it’s probably pretty important to recruit there.

FWIW, Trent is probably next on my list (above Malcolm), so there are certainly +100 diamonds out there in the rough. #GiorgiBAmazing
Yeah, I think sometimes people mix up possibility with probability or likelihood. There is fairly clear correlation between how highly a recruit is ranked and their college performance, especially once you get into the Top 50 and even more so in the Top 25. There are going to be many players who don't meet those lofty ranking expectations (hello Jereme Richmond), and there are going to be many who perform much better than their ranking (hey Trent), but overall, a higher ranked recruit is more likely to outperform a low ranked recruit. Doesn’t mean they will, but it is more likely.
 
#91      
It's not as simple as just looking at the top 100. There are years where there is just a ton of talent and some guys that would be top 25 end up top 40 and vice versa.

Look at Deron at #48, a top 5 Illini all time I think most would agree with. Well not only did he have the #12 player on his team he had to share the spotlight with, but the PGs in that class rated higher than him were Raymond Felton, Daniel Horton, Anthony Roberson, Dee Brown, Sean Dockery, Gerry McNamara, Allan Ray (combo), John Gilchrist, and Jarret Jack. There are an awful lot of All Americans on that list.

Ayo was the same way lot of guys ranked ahead of him also currently in the NBA. Whereas other years not as strong and some guys are maybe ranked a little higher than they otherwise would be.

For the rankings don't matter crowd, who are the guys not on that list, that have been Illini greats (or at least very goods)? Mike Davis? though his recruitment was very weird.
I'm not a rankings don't matter at all person, but the names that popped into my head that aren't on that list in no particular order:

Mike Davis
Trent Frazier
Robert Archibald
Chester Frazier
Mike Tisdale

And 1 major sigh:
Jamar Smith
 
#92      
I like Dain but he goes to fast for his own good at times. He was our most efficient scorer because 90% of his shots are at the rim. He relies on his spin move too much and often times he looks off balance and awkward when he is finishing his shot causing him to miss more of those than he should. They need to get him to make sure he stays under control while making those moves so he gets an and 1 situation instead of two missed free throws. He's got the size there is no reason why he can't also develop some classic post moves like Crowl from Wisconsin. It would benefit him to have more than one option when he gets the ball in the low post. This is why people are already thinking he will be behind Morez and Amani next year imo.
 
#95      
For the rankings don't matter crowd, who are the guys not on that list, that have been Illini greats (or at least very goods)? Mike Davis? though his recruitment was very weird.
There is no crowd that says "rankings don't matter." However, there is a crowd that says "rankings are not the end-all be-all" and "guys outside the top 100 can still be good/great."

You taking Trent Frazier (outside top 100) or Rich McBridge (28) in a draft? Coleman Hawkins or Omar Payne? Andres Feliz or Adam Miller? Trent Meacham or Crandall Head? I could keep going, but you get the point. Just b/c a guy is rated #35 (cough, Skyy, cough) doesn't mean he's a better add for our program than a guy outside the top 100 (a la DGL).

How many great Illinois players did we let leave the state primarily b/c we were more focused on higher rated players that ended up not being as good? Fred VanVleet. Ulis. Kaminsky. The list is a long one. Sure, the higher the rating, the greater the probability of success, but it's slight up until a certain point. People act like this is a science that is way more cut and dry than it is.
 
#97      
There is no crowd that says "rankings don't matter." However, there is a crowd that says "rankings are not the end-all be-all" and "guys outside the top 100 can still be good/great."

You taking Trent Frazier (outside top 100) or Rich McBridge (28) in a draft? Coleman Hawkins or Omar Payne? Andres Feliz or Adam Miller? Trent Meacham or Crandall Head? I could keep going, but you get the point. Just b/c a guy is rated #35 (cough, Skyy, cough) doesn't mean he's a better add for our program than a guy outside the top 100 (a la DGL).

How many great Illinois players did we let leave the state primarily b/c we were more focused on higher rated players that ended up not being as good? Fred VanVleet. Ulis. Kaminsky. The list is a long one. Sure, the higher the rating, the greater the probability of success, but it's slight up until a certain point. People act like this is a science that is way more cut and dry than it is.
I wholeheartedly agree with your post. And with the benefit of hindsight and knowing how guys turned out, I would absolutely take Trent over Rich McBride. But, coming out of HS before Rich hurt his back, dude was a walking bucket! It would have been really interesting to see how he would have fared had he been completely healthy, because even at "partial ability", he was pretty good! The other comps are pretty easy choices....
 
#98      
I know this post will draw a fair share of ridicule, but it is always interesting to read anonymous posts about what is wrong with the recruiting decisions of our coaching staff or the play of our players written by a bunch of guys who had to buy a ticket to get close to the court after their high school or noon at the Y career was over.
 
#99      

Cool that it was in the Lou Boudreau room at Thorton. In addition to being a great baseball player, he also captained and was a great player for the Illini basketball team. Partial excerpt from his bio for the Illini HOF:

"As an Illini, Boudreau served as captain of Illini baseball and basketball teams. He led the Illini to both basketball and baseball Big Ten titles during the 1936-37 season before earning All-America honors in basketball in 1938. Boudreau is one of just three athletes (along with Grange and Butkus) to have their Illini number retired."
Very cool indeed.

If an Illini number is retired, is it retired just for that athlete's sport, or retired across all Illini sports? I've always thought the former, but is Lou's retired for baseball, basketball, or both? Did he even wear the same number for both sports? I should know more about this great Illini, but to me growing up he was always the Cubs radio guy.
 
#100      
There is no crowd that says "rankings don't matter." However, there is a crowd that says "rankings are not the end-all be-all" and "guys outside the top 100 can still be good/great."

The only way their "he's a 3 star, so there is no possible way he will be useful" arguments sound even remotely valid if they also point to everyone else and refer to them as "rankings don't matter crowd".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.