Point taken. But who among us think that Tommy Edman is the longterm solution in centerfield. From all reports Victor Scott is waiting in the wings
It all links together
You have a few guys who are poor defensively, Edman gives you real good defense and the offense is extra. Cardinals have/will be bringing up guys like SS Winn and OF Scott who they think will stick around the organization for the next 10 years. It just works out Edman plays multiple positions which is a great thing. Edman is not a superstar but is too good to be sitting on the bench.
Big thing will be staying healthy. I feel confident in the infield defense of 3B Arenado, SS Winn(as much as you can in a rookie), 2B Donovan and 1B Goldy.
If Carlson showed more with his bat, he would be in CF. He hasn't done that yet
If Gorman showed more defense at 2B, he would be at 2B. He hasn't done that yet
Cardinals have to play to strengths and Marmol/Mo have already said they don't want to move Edman between OF and infield all the time. Noot, Walker, Edman with Carlson and Burleson for now. I like Scott a ton but don't see him starting the season in the majors unless an injury/trade.