I've contended for 30 plus years that Tepper as head coach was among the worst D1 power conference head coaches in the modern era. The 1994 season is exhibit A. But when you look in totality at what he inherited (a solid top 25 or better program) vs what he left behind (a dumpster fire that didn't win a game in 1997 & one of the worst D1 power conference teams of all time) it speaks to how AWFUL AWFUL AWFUL he was as a head coach. A great human being of that I have no doubt but just a disaster as a head coach.
Performance falling off a cliff coinciding with the exact moment the last Mac-era recruit left town tells the whole story.
That whole sequence…
Stoner fired for corruption
Mac promoted to both HC and AD.
Mac taking the Texas job.
Trustees declining to do a coaching search or to wait to hire a coach until after they’d hired an AD and promoting Tepper to HC.
Hiring Guenther as AD.
Guenther for some reason sticking with Tepper, a guy he didn’t hire, after missing a bowl in 93.
It’s just not how a big time program is run and Illinois stopped being a big time program. Bizarrely, they repeated many of the same mistakes in the whole Beckman>Cubit>Smith transition 20+ years later.