Coaching Carousel

#126      
Has he coached at any level......ever?

This trend of hiring former NBA stars with little to no coaching experience to coach their alma mater is not a good trend, IMO.

Clyde Drexler was abysmal at Houston. Chris Mullin has been really bad at St. John's. At least Ewing has some prior experience, but even then, I didn't really like that hire at Georgetown.


This is going to prove to be an absolutely terrible mistake by Memphis, IMO.

He does have 3 state championships in Tennessee at East High in Memphis and on an AAU squad, but that doesn't really mean much. Whole different beast.
 
#127      

TownieMatt

CU Expat
Chicago
Hardaway has zero coaching experience. Zip. Zilch. Nada. I guess that theory that some people always propose out there that if you just hire an alum who's a true "Insert School Name Here" guy then everything will go swimmingly is about to be put to the test. I hope he hires some really good assistants with plenty of x's and o's experience. Seriously, I hope it goes well for him because people in Memphis need something positive to be excited about.

Hardaway has been an AAU and high school coach for several years (his HS team wins state every year). Say what you will about making the jump from coaching at that level to high-D1, but that isn't "Zip. Zilch. Nada." coaching experience.

He'll get players, especially because of his AAU connections, and he'll likely get kids from the area to stay. I even think he could be a passable X and Os guy. My concern would be how he adjusts to managing a high-D1 program off-the-court.
 
#128      
He also coaches James Wiseman who will probably stay in Memphis. I've heard Wiseman is not in the same teir talent-wise as Ayton, Thamba, Jackson Jr, etc.
 
#129      
Hardaway has zero coaching experience. Zip. Zilch. Nada. I guess that theory that some people always propose out there that if you just hire an alum who's a true "Insert School Name Here" guy then everything will go swimmingly is about to be put to the test. I hope he hires some really good assistants with plenty of x's and o's experience. Seriously, I hope it goes well for him because people in Memphis need something positive to be excited about.
Have seen him coach in Dallas many times in AAU tournaments.
 
#130      

Deleted member 631370

D
Guest
He does have 3 state championships in Tennessee at East High in Memphis and on an AAU squad, but that doesn't really mean much. Whole different beast.


Well that's respectable at least. I just glanced at his Wiki page, and there's nothing on there about his HS coaching resume.

Still.....stepping up to the college game is a huge move. I assume he'll be able to recruit, but that hasn't been a big problem at Memphis until just recently. Pastner was a fantastic recruiter, and a truly awful coach.
 
#131      
#133      
There seems to be lots of smoke regarding Chris Mack to Louisville. If he takes the job, considering they have no current 2018 commits, I wonder if they jump in late with Ramey and Jones. Ramey because he was formerly committed there and Jones because Xavier is currently in his final four.
 
#134      

BananaShampoo

Captain 'Paign
Phoenix, AZ
Hardaway has been an AAU and high school coach for several years (his HS team wins state every year). Say what you will about making the jump from coaching at that level to high-D1, but that isn't "Zip. Zilch. Nada." coaching experience.

He'll get players, especially because of his AAU connections, and he'll likely get kids from the area to stay. I even think he could be a passable X and Os guy. My concern would be how he adjusts to managing a high-D1 program off-the-court.
Okay, based on my limited (Wikipedia) research it made no mention of him doing any sort of coaching. So that's something at least. Still don't think it ends well, but hope it does.
 
#135      

TownieMatt

CU Expat
Chicago
Okay, based on my limited (Wikipedia) research it made no mention of him doing any sort of coaching. So that's something at least. Still don't think it ends well, but hope it does.

I'm expecting a boom-then-bust tenure. He'll grab a few big recruits and get people excited, but I could easily see it going south once the novelty of having Penny on the sidelines wears off.
 
#136      

Serious Late

Peoria via Denver via Ann Arbor via Albuquerque vi
Okay, based on my limited (Wikipedia) research it made no mention of him doing any sort of coaching. So that's something at least. Still don't think it ends well, but hope it does.

There is a pretty good E:60 piece on how Penny got into coaching as a result of his friend's battle with cancer.

E:60 Report
 
#137      
Has he coached at any level......ever?

This trend of hiring former NBA stars with little to no coaching experience to coach their alma mater is not a good trend, IMO.

Clyde Drexler was abysmal at Houston. Chris Mullin has been really bad at St. John's. At least Ewing has some prior experience, but even then, I didn't really like that hire at Georgetown.


This is going to prove to be an absolutely terrible mistake by Memphis, IMO.

Doesn't really matter, the program was lost under Smith, the attendance and the black cloud hanging over them usually is telling. Penny can only be viewed as a ++++ hire. He will recruit the area/state, he will push up tempo offense, and he will put BUTTS back in the seats.

All plus', even if he falters, one could argue the program will be far and away in a better place than it is now.:chief:
 
#138      
Not doubting the "smoke," nor doubting the ability of Louisville to pay big bucks, but if you are a hot, up and coming coach like Mack,do you want to rebuild a potential dumpster fire like Louisville? Especially with the FBI, and possibly NCAA hanging over your head? Louisville is not a blue blood the NCAA will ignore, IMHO. If sanctions are sever enough, can they recover?

Similar thoughts on Musslemen to Arizona. Lots of positives, but also the potential to sink the program for awhile, although UA is closer to a blue blood wrt to the NCAA P-o-v. Again, all my opinion.

Yeah could totally see him staying there's arguments on both sides. A year or two ago Louisville is considered a top 10 job between the ACC, money, facilities, recent and historic success. But how much of that is because of cheating? Mack's alma mater is Xavier so could definitely see him staying, but his wife is from Louisville. Also, if there was a time to leave, it'd be after this season to avoid a rebuild because their roster was senior heavy. I could easily see it going either way. I've also seen Shaka tied there, but Texas would have to lower his buyout since it's massive.

I think Arizona will shoot higher than Musselmen, but may strike out considering all the uncertainty there.
 
#139      

sacraig

The desert
Yeah could totally see him staying there's arguments on both sides. A year or two ago Louisville is considered a top 10 job between the ACC, money, facilities, recent and historic success. But how much of that is because of cheating? Mack's alma mater is Xavier so could definitely see him staying, but his wife is from Louisville. Also, if there was a time to leave, it'd be after this season to avoid a rebuild because their roster was senior heavy. I could easily see it going either way. I've also seen Shaka tied there, but Texas would have to lower his buyout since it's massive.

I think Arizona will shoot higher than Musselmen, but may strike out considering all the uncertainty there.

I'm starting to doubt that Arizona will make a change. There's some really shady reporting behind the Schlabach report.
 
#140      
I'm starting to doubt that Arizona will make a change. There's some really shady reporting behind the Schlabach report.

It'd be on more than just that. At a program that expects final fours and national titles, he has lost to a double digit seed three straight years and has yet to make a final four. He loses all five starters off this years team and has no one signed or committed for next year. And his long-time assistant Book Richardson is facing 60 years of prison time (has an incentive to talk to reduce the sentence), so Miller could easily be implicated in the FBI probe, even if it's not due to paying Ayton.
 
#144      

Deleted member 631370

D
Guest
There seems to be lots of smoke regarding Chris Mack to Louisville. If he takes the job, considering they have no current 2018 commits, I wonder if they jump in late with Ramey and Jones. Ramey because he was formerly committed there and Jones because Xavier is currently in his final four.


Strange considering Xavier is Chris Mack's alma mater.

Louisville definitely has a higher ceiling than Xavier, and basketball is life in the state of Kentucky. But ever since Xavier joined the new Big East, they've been a legit national power.
 
#145      

BananaShampoo

Captain 'Paign
Phoenix, AZ
Doesn't really matter, the program was lost under Smith, the attendance and the black cloud hanging over them usually is telling. Penny can only be viewed as a ++++ hire. He will recruit the area/state, he will push up tempo offense, and he will put BUTTS back in the seats.

All plus', even if he falters, one could argue the program will be far and away in a better place than it is now.:chief:
He will put butts in seats only if he wins. That will always be the case. A name coach will only get you so far in the beginning without, regardless of sport. Lovie is a case in point. Once he starts winning the butts will return.
 
#146      

PJD86

Texas
Strange considering Xavier is Chris Mack's alma mater.

Louisville definitely has a higher ceiling than Xavier, and basketball is life in the state of Kentucky. But ever since Xavier joined the new Big East, they've been a legit national power.


I think anyone of his ilk would have to think long and hard about Louisville not knowing exactly where that program ends up when all the FBI stuff is over. I wouldn't touch it unless I was a lower tier guy and the $$$ said go.
 
#148      

foby

Bonnaroo Land
Strange considering Xavier is Chris Mack's alma mater.

Louisville definitely has a higher ceiling than Xavier, and basketball is life in the state of Kentucky. But ever since Xavier joined the new Big East, they've been a legit national power.

Agreed. ATM Xavier > Louisville. I think the smoke is only steam.
 
#149      

sacraig

The desert
It'd be on more than just that. At a program that expects final fours and national titles, he has lost to a double digit seed three straight years and has yet to make a final four. He loses all five starters off this years team and has no one signed or committed for next year. And his long-time assistant Book Richardson is facing 60 years of prison time (has an incentive to talk to reduce the sentence), so Miller could easily be implicated in the FBI probe, even if it's not due to paying Ayton.

I agree that the program has high expectations. However, at least on the fan side of things, I haven't seen the furor for Miller's ouster that I expected after the exit from the tournament (I live in Tucson). Given, I don't spend much time with the donor class that would actually have a voice, but Joe Q. Wildcat fan is still not fully aboard the "Fire Miller" train just yet.

I think that, if he was going to be fired after this season based on what is known now, he would have been fired already. In order for him not to coach here in 2018-2019, the FBI probe is going to have to uncover some real, unassailable dirt on him. This honestly makes the most sense, because the program may have a hard time drawing the level of replacement coaches it otherwise might on account of the uncertainty around the probe.

Now, if he flubs next season, I think there's a much better shot of him being shown the door based on performance.

I have been doubting this more as time goes on. A lot of "experts" will be eating crow. Especially that arrogant Jay Bilas:mad:

I saw an article that 247 published recently that basically laid out that the allegations put forth by Schlabach were essentially impossible based on the timing. That's not to say there isn't other shady stuff going on, of course (after all, Book Richardson is one of the people who got caught in the probe), but it seems like the Schlabach report is questionable at best.

Personally, I am just waiting for the dust to settle before I thumb my nose at anyone. Who knows, we may still get caught up in this (or literally any other school, for that matter).
 
#150      

dgcrow

Kelso, WA
Lorenzo Romar, former head coach at St. Louis U and U of Washington, is returning as head coach at Pepperdine. He was also the head man there from 1996 to 1999. Romar was Associate Head Coach at Arizona this past season. Ken Bone, former head coach at Portland State and Washington State, will be his associate head coach.
 
Last edited: