A well put together treatise, sir. In my multi-decade presence on Loyalty (in one form or another), I've lamented our over-inflated sense of self worth many times, most recently here:Well in essence, I don’t disagree with you.
The Illini fan “inferiority” thing is real. Sometimes it manifests as more of a full “persecution complex”…”of course that happened we’re Illinois…blah blah…
(As you all know. lol)
I think what it comes down to is: for the 10th-11th winningest D1 Basketball program…we arguably do not have the post season success commensurate with that stature. We are not alone… other schools have similar historical resumes. Some are the opposite; and are weighted
disproportionately the other way.
And fair or not…the world sees and remembers TOURNAMENT success. We cling to ‘89 and ‘05 partially because we are rabid fans…but partially because it’s what we have. We don’t have that much post season success as a program. That’s just the way it is. (That doesn’t mean it should stay that way!)
We have a rich collective history…and we’re proud of it. But the world at large just doesn’t generally know or care. That’s a tough thing to hear as a rabid Illini fan…but it’s true.
Don’t believe me? Do you consider Utah a basketball juggernaut? Their win total is
VERY comparable to us? Were you even aware that was the case?
Do you think we are superior to Utah?
I do, sure but I am a biased Illini fan.
How do Utah fans view themselves?
If they thought of themselves as equals…they would have a valid argument based on actual data. Most people on the street would probably say Illinois has the better program of the two. But if your criteria is total program wins…Utah has a claim.
But since we’re talking about Utah….
Utah has a better all-time win total than Nova and Michigan State? But the last
two have been relatively consistent fixtures in March.
Ask 5 people on the street…of those 3, who has a better basketball program and see what they tell you…
People have short memories and they remember a few consecutive, flashy teams from the tournament…and that becomes the collective perception of the world.
And we Illini fans pick up on that collective perception of the casual fan more than we want to admit. And it pisses us off. Lol
https://www.illinoisloyalty.com/post/college-hoops-coaching-carousel.31175/post-1915327
We've had many, many, many years of disappointment, highlighted by bursts of brilliance. We love the O&B, and live and die with their success or lack thereof. But we are not, regrettably, actually as good and historic as many here believe.