DC Bobby Hauck out at Illinois

Status
Not open for further replies.
#452      
Agree. The defense was better than expected against OSU. I don’t understand why Hauck was not given the season to play it out.
Better than expected doesn’t mean it’s going in the right direction. Had 9 guys on the field one play, communication issues all season. Hauck didn’t want the season to play it out.
 
#453      
I think there is some rewriting of history here. Pretty much the entire board was down about our talent level on defense, from the time we started losing guys to the portal up into the season. Obviously, we have our share of ThaKids, but the consensus was that we were down on defensive talent, likely because we didn't have the money.

As to the midseason firing, you do it because you just can't have screwing up fundamentals like tackling and number of men on the field. It demonstrates a lack of discipline. Will it make a difference? Who knows. I came into this season hoping for six wins and I still do.
 
#455      
Are we unable to grasp nuance?? Some of these statements are just over the top. How often in life is a negative outcome solely due to a single factor? I suppose that's what is to be expected from a message board, and I am probably guilty of it too at times,

From my perspective (which I know all of you are just on the edge of your seats with popcorn and cottage cheese anxious to hear):

-We under projected the cost of DL and let some guys transfer out that in hindsight we likely would have paid their market rate or at least closer to it and would have made a stronger effort to keep them - McCulloom,Tomiwa, Coenen, and Neal are all arguably better than what we have now.
-The handling of AH's departure from the staff (which is potentially great for BB's brand in the coaching industry and hopefully lands us a rockstar DC this offseason) set us way back in the coaching hiring cycle and then we got left at the altar by the Seahawks/former uOFm guy so we scrambled and got Hauck which did not work out nearly as well as the most optimistic projections.
-The DL we brought in after getting some unanticipated defections into the portal are not at the same level as the guys that left.
-this is was a drastic scheme change and even if Hauck had been the rockstar hire we hoped, we were bound to have some issues due to scheme change as well.
-While BB does get involved in the day to day, he is probably a little bit more CEO. So did he have awareness of what was being done by the GM, he likely largely relied on Patrick Embleton to have an accurate feel of prices in the player market. Clearly that was a huge miss, and I'd like to hope that we consider a change at that or other related positions involved with those decisions next offseason.
-Even with all of the benefits of the doubt given and factoring in that the D has arguably improved to some degree - having things as glaring and embarrassing as having 2 guys not on the field is pretty bad. I'm sure before and after that BB had been and continued to think about what direction he would go with Defensive coaching immediately and in the offseason.
-Hauck is an older un-retired accomplished coach who gave it a shot and saw that a lot of the things that he liked and was comfortable doing at the lower level and as a HC were not successful here with him as a DC, and he simply decided for in his own best interest and possibly in the best interest of the players and the coaches that he brought with him that it would be better for all parties that he step down now.

I'm in no way plugged in other than I read articles online, watch the press conferences and pay more attention to certain posters here than everyone else, but that's my overall summary/thoughts....and I'm pretty sure all of the factors above account for some percentage greater than 0 and less than 100 for the Dline makeup, overall Defensive performance, and Hauck's separation 4 games into the season.
 
#457      
Better than expected doesn’t mean it’s going in the right direction. Had 9 guys on the field one play, communication issues all season. Hauck didn’t want the season to play it out.
Sure, mistakes happened. Still no excuses for firing a coach after 4 games. How do we know he would not have turned it around?
Fire him at the end of the season if it doesn’t work out.
 
#458      
I haven't a clue. It's painfully obvious, but I think it's a form of self soothing. They want to find someone to blame versus addressing the problem, which is significant. They are hoping that one decision fixes the problem and don't want to accept the fact that that entire side of the ball needs an upgrade and that can't be fixed this year.

There is no way that a reasonable person can't see that the guys we throw out there are slower, less athletic and can't physically match up with the opponent. These other teams a just bigger, taller, faster and have better athletes.....on defense.

We spent our money on the offense. If the reverse was true, these same people would want Lunney fired.

This is not an easy fix when we have no financial answers. That's the crux of the issue.
Fully understand firing Hauck doesn't magically make the defense good or even average. The ship is already heading in one direction and it's not going to change directions mid-season. Here's what I honestly expect: the defense will gradually improve over the season, probably as it would have if we retained Bobby, if not even a little better.

Also, people on the message board complaining about Hauck had no influence on what happened. Either his heart wasn't in it or Bret determined the results weren't good enough. There is little point in defending him now.
 
#459      
I haven't a clue. It's painfully obvious, but I think it's a form of self soothing. They want to find someone to blame versus addressing the problem, which is significant. They are hoping that one decision fixes the problem and don't want to accept the fact that that entire side of the ball needs an upgrade and that can't be fixed this year.

There is no way that a reasonable person can't see that the guys we throw out there are slower, less athletic and can't physically match up with the opponent. These other teams a just bigger, taller, faster and have better athletes.....on defense.

We spent our money on the offense. If the reverse was true, these same people would want Lunney fired.

This is not an easy fix when we have no financial answers. That's the crux of the issue.

What’s scary is we don’t have much returning for the defense next year.
 
#464      
Better than expected doesn’t mean it’s going in the right direction. Had 9 guys on the field one play, communication issues all season. Hauck didn’t want the season to play it out.
I mean, there were times where only 10 players were on field earlier this year (if I recall correctly).

I wouldn't be surprised if the trend continued, we play a 4-2-2 sequence for a snap.

Reality is that something had to change and fast. Will it be enough to turn the unit around? No clue, but cleaning up communication and personnel on field will be a good first step.
 
#465      
I mean, there were times where only 10 players were on field earlier this year (if I recall correctly).

I wouldn't be surprised if the trend continued, we play a 4-2-2 sequence for a snap.

Reality is that something had to change and fast. Will it be enough to turn the unit around? No clue, but cleaning up communication and personnel on field will be a good first step.
10 fine it happens, 12 fine it happens, 9 can’t happen. I actually don’t know if I’ve ever seen it happen in college football. Also don’t forget the Duke game when we had 11 and the 11th guy ran off causing an offsides because the communication was butchered.
 
#467      
10 fine it happens, 12 fine it happens, 9 can’t happen. I actually don’t know if I’ve ever seen it happen in college football. Also don’t forget the Duke game when we had 11 and the 11th guy ran off causing an offsides because the communication was butchered.
That is the play I was thinking of as 10 guys. Simply mind-boggling communication gaffe. These personnel miscues were a clear indication that there were major communication issues at play.

I have never seen a 9 players on field error before, but if it did happen, it better be game 1...not game 1 in B1G play.
 
#468      
It's a blank sheet of paper next year. Hope Larry Gies' stock portfolio is doing well!

Realistically what starters back for next year? juice, Barna, Farrell and Holmes? You hope guys like Eberhart, Hankins and Beerman can also step up. But it’s pretty bad how little we return and the talent that’s left
 
#469      
Realistically what starters back for next year? juice, Barna, Farrell and Holmes? You hope guys like Eberhart, Hankins and Beerman can also step up. But it’s pretty bad how little we return and the talent that’s left
Well and I mean the offense too without Houser.

Heaven knows what the price level will be, what the roster rules will be, we've been very resistant to the entropy of the sport under Bielema but no one avoids it forever.

10 fine it happens, 12 fine it happens, 9 can’t happen. I actually don’t know if I’ve ever seen it happen in college football. Also don’t forget the Duke game when we had 11 and the 11th guy ran off causing an offsides because the communication was butchered.
It's one of those tip of the iceberg things where if we can't even do THAT right, there's much more systemic problems.
 
#470      
What are the expectations this weekend for our defense now that we have a new coach calling the shots? If we let up 28+ to Purdue, where does the blame go?
Meh, fans will blame whoever they want but it matters little. Doesn’t change the players on the field. We can try changing scheme a little or try simplifying the playbook to try and put the players in better positions, but that doesn’t matter much if our defensive front can’t get any penetration, let alone pressure without blitzing, and can’t stop the run without stacking the box or run blitzing. At this point it’s what it is and we have to try making the most of what we have this year and work towards fixing the talent problem for next year
 
#471      
Fully understand firing Hauck doesn't magically make the defense good or even average. The ship is already heading in one direction and it's not going to change directions mid-season. Here's what I honestly expect: the defense will gradually improve over the season, probably as it would have if we retained Bobby, if not even a little better.

Also, people on the message board complaining about Hauck had no influence on what happened. Either his heart wasn't in it or Bret determined the results weren't good enough. There is little point in defending him now.
I'm not willing to throw the towel in on our defense yet. I've seen it turned around here before with no changes in personnel or coaches.
 
#472      
Aaron Henry is another story altogether.

View attachment 51861
giphy.gif
 
#474      
Well and I mean the offense too without Houser.

Heaven knows what the price level will be, what the roster rules will be, we've been very resistant to the entropy of the sport under Bielema but no one avoids it forever.


It's one of those tip of the iceberg things where if we can't even do THAT right, there's much more systemic problems.

Atleast for the offense you have valentine, Barnett, Dixon, Trimble, Abney,Stoffel, Faegin. The only linemen that will graduate is Renfro. You also have Konkey and Rankin. With that being said any of these guys could transfer. But this is a pretty good start.

Hopefully this time around when we bring in a dc they are able to bring players with them for the defense.
 
#475      
I haven't a clue. It's painfully obvious, but I think it's a form of self soothing. They want to find someone to blame versus addressing the problem, which is significant. They are hoping that one decision fixes the problem and don't want to accept the fact that that entire side of the ball needs an upgrade and that can't be fixed this year.

There is no way that a reasonable person can't see that the guys we throw out there are slower, less athletic and can't physically match up with the opponent. These other teams a just bigger, taller, faster and have better athletes.....on defense.

We spent our money on the offense. If the reverse was true, these same people would want Lunney fired.

This is not an easy fix when we have no financial answers. That's the crux of the issue.
As to your last sentence, I would think this is when the AD would step in and point out to the monied supporters that Illinois needs more resources to compete at a higher level. Pure speculation on my part.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back